医师与药师对药品说明书绝对禁忌证清晰度与临床相关性的看法
本研究通过匿名在线调查,向27名药师和27名医师提供24个临床案例,评估他们对药品说明书中20个常被遗漏或忽视的绝对禁忌证的解释及不依从原因。结果显示专家对禁忌证的形式符合性解释高度异质,仅1/17案例所有专家意见一致;不依从主因为可监测患者、缺乏替代治疗及急性/严重情况。
要点
- 专家对说明书禁忌证解释异质,仅5.8%案例意见一致。
- 70.8%案例中多数专家对临床相关性达成一致。
- 不依从主因包括可监测、无替代治疗及紧急情况。
核心结论
- 专家基于临床案例对说明书禁忌证解释存在分歧,提示需提升其临床实用性。
研究设计与样本
- 针对20个常被遗漏或忽视的绝对禁忌证设计匿名在线调查,含24个临床案例,由27名药师和27名医师完成。
主要发现
- 仅1/17(5.8%)案例所有专家对禁忌证形式符合性答案一致。
- 在17/24(70.8%)临床案例中多数专家对禁忌证临床相关性达成一致。
- 不依从禁忌证的关键原因包括「可监测患者」、「缺乏替代治疗」和「急性/严重情况」。
关键数值与推荐
- 辛伐他汀说明书中「活动性肝病」禁忌证的10个预设答案选项,每个选项至少被6名专家选择。
临床怎么用
- 临床药师应关注说明书禁忌证解释的异质性,结合患者监测条件、替代治疗及病情紧急程度评估用药风险。
局限性
- 样本量较小(27名药师和27名医师),可能影响结果代表性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Previous work has identified several limitations in "Summaries of Product Characteristics" (SmPCs), which are associated with risks for patients. The aim of this study was to evaluate pharmacists' and physicians' interpretation of contraindications in SmPCs and reasons for their nonadherence in clinical routine. METHODS: For 20 commonly missed or ignored absolute contraindications, an anonymous online survey providing 24 clinical example cases (one or two per contraindication) for physicians and pharmacists was developed. Experts in medication safety were asked whether the respective case fulfilled the definition of the contraindication in the SmPC: (a) formally, irrespective of the clinical relevance of the contraindication (17 cases), and (b) whether the contraindication was deemed clinically relevant in each respective case (24 cases). RESULTS: Twenty-seven pharmacists and 27 physicians completed the survey. For only one case (1/17; 5.8%) did all experts agree on the same answer option regarding the formal fulfilment of a given contraindication statement. Experts gave heterogeneous answers regarding the interpretation of a contraindication. For instance, among 10 predefined answer options for the contraindication "active liver disease" in the SmPC of simvastatin, every option was selected by at least six experts. In 17/24 (70.8%) clinical example cases a majority of experts agreed on the clinical relevance of a given contraindication. Key reasons for nonadherence to contraindications were "patient monitoring possible", "lack of alternative treatment" and "acute/severe situations". CONCLUSIONS: Experts' disagreement on the interpretation of contraindications in SmPCs using clinical example cases indicates that further efforts are needed to improve their usability in clinical routine.
引用
- Andrikyan W, Sponfeldner MI, Jung-Poppe L, et al. Physicians' and pharmacists' perspective on clarity and clinical relevance of absolute contraindications in "Summaries of Product Characteristics". Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2024. PMID: 39511858. doi:10.1111/bcp.16331
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。