文献速递药物不良反应与药物警戒

利物浦因果评估工具与Naranjo量表预测药物不良反应可能性的比较:一项回顾性队列研究

Comparison of the Liverpool Causality Assessment Tool vs. the Naranjo Scale for predicting the likelihood of an adverse drug reaction: A retrospective cohort study.
PubMed 文献 · Br J Clin Pharmacol · 2023-03-22

该回顾性队列研究纳入伦敦健康科学中心临床药理学诊所的924份疑似药物不良反应(ADR)病历,其中529份有客观检查支持或反对ADR诊断,比较利物浦因果评估工具与Naranjo量表预测ADR的敏感度和特异度。结果显示利物浦工具敏感度97.2±2.4%、特异度2.3±1.57%,Naranjo量表敏感度81.2±5.69%、特异度13.2±3.56%。结论认为利物浦工具比Naranjo量表更敏感,但两者特异度均较差,且阳性预测值和阴性预测值均低,需进一步检查确认或排除ADR。

要点

  • 利物浦工具敏感度97.2±2.4%,高于Naranjo量表的81.2±5.69%。
  • 利物浦工具特异度仅2.3±1.57%,Naranjo量表为13.2±3.56%。
  • 两者阳性预测值均低(利物浦34.1%,Naranjo 32.7%),需进一步检查确认ADR。

核心结论

  • 利物浦因果评估工具在评估可能ADR时比Naranjo量表更敏感,但两者特异度均较差。
  • 利物浦工具可作为其他检查不易获得时的有用筛查工具,但两者低阳性预测值和阴性预测值提示需进一步检查确认或排除ADR。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,回顾伦敦健康科学中心临床药理学诊所924份疑似ADR病历,其中529份有客观检查支持或反对ADR诊断。
  • 参与者年龄范围1个月至93岁,用利物浦工具和Naranjo量表分别评分,并与实验室或再暴露试验结果比较。

主要发现

  • 利物浦工具敏感度97.2±2.4%、特异度2.3±1.57%,阳性预测值34.1%、阴性预测值61.5%。
  • Naranjo量表敏感度81.2±5.69%、特异度13.2±3.56%,阳性预测值32.7%、阴性预测值57.5%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 评分从Possible至Definite视为ADR阳性,Unlikely/Doubtful视为阴性,以实验室或临床再暴露试验确认结果。

临床怎么用

  • 利物浦工具可用于其他检查不易获得时筛查疑似ADR,但因其特异度低,阳性结果需进一步检查确认。
  • Naranjo量表敏感度较低,两者阴性预测值均不高,阴性结果也不能完全排除ADR。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: The aim of this study is to compare the Liverpool Causality Assessment Tool vs. Naranjo Scale for screening suspected adverse drug reaction (ADR) cases. METHODS: We retrospectively reviewed patient charts with a history of suspected ADR, scored using both tools, and determined how each correlates with laboratory and other investigations. A total of 924 charts from the Clinical Pharmacology Clinic at the London Health Sciences Centre were reviewed, and 529 charts contained objective findings to support or against the diagnosis of ADR. The participant age ranged from 1 month to 93 years. We determined that the sensitivity (SN) and specificity (SP) of Liverpool and Naranjo tools for predicting ADRs with scores ranging from Possible to Definite were considered positive and Unlikely/Doubtful as negative for ADR. These results were confirmed by laboratory or clinical (re-challenge) testing in 529 cases. RESULTS: Liverpool causality tool had SN of 97.2 ± 2.4% and SP of 2.3 ± 1.57%. The positive (PPV) and negative predictive values (NPV) were 34.1 and 61.5%, respectively. The Naranjo Scale had SN of 81.2 ± 5.69% and SP of 13.2 ± 3.56%. PPV and NPV were 32.7 and 57.5%, respectively. CONCLUSION: The Liverpool Causality Assessment Tool is a more sensitive tool than the Naranjo Scale in the assessment of possible ADRs, but both tools have poor SP. The Liverpool Tool can be a useful screening tool in settings where other tests may not be readily available. However, the low PPV and NPV of both tools suggest that to pursue further testing is needed to confirm or deny an ADR.

来源:Br J Clin Pharmacol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Um SH, Abuzgaia A, Rieder M, et al. Comparison of the Liverpool Causality Assessment Tool vs. the Naranjo Scale for predicting the likelihood of an adverse drug reaction: A retrospective cohort study. Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2023. PMID: 36849649. doi:10.1111/bcp.15704

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。