临床药理学与治疗学教师指南:种族医学、包容性与多样性
本文指出种族是社交建构而非生物学本质,但医学指南常基于自我认同种族做出推荐,其依据是种族与未测量的健康相关因素(如药物基因组学、饮食、日晒)的相关性。教师常无意中将种族呈现为生物学本质,可能强化刻板印象与医疗差异。本指南由临床药理学与治疗学教师撰写,旨在帮助同行反思和改进种族医学指南的教学,并使临床案例更包容多样。
要点
- 种族是社交建构,基于种族的治疗推荐反映的是异质群体平均值而非个体真相。
- 教学需阐明种族与健康的关系易受社会经济地位、种族主义、祖先和环境偏倚影响。
- 临床案例应避免刻板印象,反映真实患者的多样性以促进包容性教学。
核心结论
- 种族无生物学本质,基于种族的医学指南推荐反映的是异质群体平均值,不能推广至所有个体。
- 教师应反思教学,避免将自我报告的种族呈现为具有生物学本质,以减少医疗差异的强化。
- 临床案例需更具包容性和多样性,避免刻板印象和偏倚。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为临床药理学与治疗学教师撰写的指南,基于教学观察与反思,旨在帮助同行改进种族医学教学。
主要发现
- 许多教师对种族与生物学关系的复杂性认识不足,无意中在课堂上将自我报告的种族描绘为具有生物学本质。
- 这可能导致学生将同种族人群视为生物学或遗传学上同质,并相信基于种族的推荐适用于所有个体。
- 教学中使用的临床案例存在许多刻板印象和偏倚,未普遍反映真实患者的多样性。
关键数值与推荐
- 医学指南中基于种族的推荐(如针对黑人高血压患者的治疗建议)基于临床试验中自我认同种族与实际但常未测量的健康相关因素(如药物基因组学、饮食、日晒)的显著相关性。
- 种族与健康的关系易受社会经济地位、种族主义、祖先和环境等因素偏倚,限制基于种族推荐的普遍性。
临床怎么用
- 临床药学智能体医生在解读和使用基于种族的指南推荐时,应认识到其反映群体平均值而非个体生物学本质。
- 在患者评估中考虑药物基因组学、饮食、环境等未测量因素,避免仅凭种族推断个体特征。
- 教学和临床案例设计应避免刻板印象,纳入多样化的患者特征以促进包容性。
局限性
- 本文为教学指南,未报告系统检索范围或定量研究数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The relationship between race and biology is complex. In contemporary medical science, race is a social construct that is measured via self-identification of study participants. But even though race has no biological essence, it is often used as variable in medical guidelines (e.g., treatment recommendations specific for Black people with hypertension). Such recommendations are based on clinical trials in which there was a significant correlation between self-identified race and actual, but often unmeasured, health-related factors such as (pharmaco)genetics, diet, sun exposure, etc. Many teachers are insufficiently aware of this complexity. In their classes, they (unintentionally) portray self-reported race as having a biological essence. This may cause students to see people of shared race as biologically or genetically homogeneous, and believe that race-based recommendations are true for all individuals (rather than reflecting the average of a heterogeneous group). This medicalizes race and reinforces already existing healthcare disparities. Moreover, students may fail to learn that the relation between race and health is easily biased by factors such as socioeconomic status, racism, ancestry, and environment and that this limits the generalizability of race-based recommendations. We observed that the clinical case vignettes that we use in our teaching contain many stereotypes and biases, and do not generally reflect the diversity of actual patients. This guide, written by clinical pharmacology and therapeutics teachers, aims to help our colleagues and teachers in other health professions to reflect on and improve our teaching on race-based medical guidelines and to make our clinical case vignettes more inclusive and diverse.
引用
- Bakkum MJ, Verdonk P, Thomas EG, et al. A Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics Teacher's Guide to Race-Based Medicine, Inclusivity, and Diversity. Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2022. PMID: 36325997. doi:10.1002/cpt.2786
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。