迷失在翻译中:药物警戒术语跨语言差异的多语言调查
本研究通过83名药物警戒专家小组,调查了26个药物警戒术语在26种语言中的翻译情况,以判断语言差异对药物警戒沟通的影响程度。结果显示术语可分为三类:跨语言形式相似型、部分相似型及差异显著型。结论认为翻译困难可能导致药物警戒信息沟通误解,建议避免使用隐喻表达并编制多语言术语表。
要点
- 药物警戒术语翻译存在三类差异,可能影响跨语言沟通准确性。
- 隐喻表达应避免用于严肃科学出版物以减少翻译困难。
- 建议编制多语言术语表并用于专用机器翻译器。
核心结论
- 药物警戒信息沟通中的误解可能源于翻译困难。
- 隐喻表达最好避免用于严肃科学出版物以减少翻译难度。
- 可编程专用机器翻译器的多语言术语和定义表将很有价值。
研究设计与样本
- 通过83名药物警戒专家组成的小组,调查26个药物警戒术语在26种语言中的翻译情况。
主要发现
- 第一类术语在所有或几乎所有调查语言中形式相似,如「信号」和「风险」。
- 第二类术语在一些语言中形式相似但并非所有语言,如「药物警戒」和「监测」。
- 第三类术语在不同语言间存在重大差异,如「危害」。
临床怎么用
- 在药物警戒沟通中注意翻译差异可能导致的误解。
- 科学出版物中避免使用隐喻表达以降低翻译难度。
- 可考虑使用多语言术语表辅助翻译和沟通。
局限性
- 已发表的指南提供翻译方法指导,但复杂耗时且主要用于翻译患者报告结局工具。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Although English is the universal language of science, it is nevertheless the first language of only about 6% of the world's population, and 75% of people do not speak English at all. It is therefore important that accurate translations of scientific information should be available, not only for professionals but also for the general public. This applies to pharmacovigilance as much as to any other discipline. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to determine how pharmacovigilance terms are translated into other languages, in order to judge the extent to which differences between languages might impair communication in pharmacovigilance. METHODS: I surveyed the translation of 26 pharmacovigilance terms into 26 languages via a panel of 83 pharmacovigilance experts. RESULTS: Three types of terms emerged: Type 1-those that are similar in form across all, or almost all, of the languages surveyed (e.g. 'signal' and 'risk'); Type 2-terms that are similar in form across some languages but not all (e.g. 'pharmacovigilance' and 'surveillance'); Type 3-terms for which there are major differences across languages (e.g. 'hazard'). CONCLUSION: Misconceptions in the communication of pharmacovigilance information may arise through difficulties in translation. Metaphorical expressions are best avoided in serious scientific publications, in order to reduce the difficulties of translation. A multilingual glossary of terms and definitions, which could be used to program a dedicated machine translator, would be of value. Published guidelines offer guidance to methods of translation, but they are complex and time-consuming and are mostly used in translating instruments for eliciting patient-reported outcomes.
引用
- Aronson JK. Lost in Translation: A Multilingual Survey of Interlinguistic Variations in Terms Used in Pharmacovigilance. Drug Saf. 2022. PMID: 36131124. doi:10.1007/s40264-022-01223-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。