宫内胎儿死亡中胎儿生长受限的共识定义:德尔菲法
国际围产病理专家小组采用改良在线德尔菲法,经多轮评分与70%同意阈值,形成宫内胎儿死亡回顾性诊断胎儿生长受限的共识定义:产前临床诊断或出生体重低于第3百分位或10项贡献变量中至少5项。该定义有助于改善后续妊娠管理与结局。
要点
- 共识定义包含产前临床诊断胎儿生长受限、出生体重低于第3百分位或10项贡献变量中至少5项。
- 10项贡献变量涉及临床风险因素及尸检体重、脑重、足长、肝重、胎盘重等低于第10百分位指标。
- 对胎儿死亡至分娩间隔的校正方法未达成共识。
核心结论
- 形成了宫内胎儿死亡中胎儿生长受限的共识定义,用于改善后续妊娠管理与结局。
研究设计与样本
- 国际围产病理专家小组改良在线德尔菲调查,第一轮52名专家参与,88%(46/52)完成所有轮次。
- 开放问题收集变量,2名及以上专家提出的变量以5点Likert量表评分,后续轮次以70%同意水平确定变量纳入与阈值。
主要发现
- 共识定义包括产前临床诊断胎儿生长受限,或出生体重低于第3百分位,或10项贡献变量中至少5项。
- 10项贡献变量为:临床产前病史风险因素、出生体重低于第10百分位、尸检时体重低于第10百分位、脑重低于第10百分位、足长低于第10百分位、肝重低于第10百分位、胎盘重低于第10百分位、脑重与肝重比值高于4、胎盘重与出生体重比值高于第90百分位、胎盘功能不全/灌注不良的组织学或大体特征。
关键数值与推荐
- 变量与阈值纳入标准为70%同意水平。
- 共识定义阈值:出生体重低于第3百分位,或10项贡献变量中至少5项。
- 贡献变量阈值包括低于第10百分位的出生体重、尸检体重、脑重、足长、肝重、胎盘重,脑重/肝重比值高于4,胎盘重/出生体重比值高于第90百分位。
临床怎么用
- 可用于胎儿尸检时回顾性诊断胎儿生长受限,辅助评估宫内胎儿死亡原因。
- 共识定义有望改善后续妊娠的管理与结局。
局限性
- 对胎儿死亡至分娩间隔的校正方法等方面未达成共识。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT.—: Fetal growth restriction is a risk factor for intrauterine fetal death. Currently, definitions of fetal growth restriction in stillborns are heterogeneous. OBJECTIVES.—: To develop a consensus definition for fetal growth restriction retrospectively diagnosed at fetal autopsy in intrauterine fetal death. DESIGN.—: A modified online Delphi survey in an international panel of experts in perinatal pathology, with feedback at group level and exclusion of nonresponders. The survey scoped all possible variables with an open question. Variables suggested by 2 or more experts were scored on a 5-point Likert scale. In subsequent rounds, inclusion of variables and thresholds were determined with a 70% level of agreement. In the final rounds, participants selected the consensus algorithm. RESULTS.—: Fifty-two experts participated in the first round; 88% (46 of 52) completed all rounds. The consensus definition included antenatal clinical diagnosis of fetal growth restriction OR a birth weight lower than third percentile OR at least 5 of 10 contributory variables (risk factors in the clinical antenatal history: birth weight lower than 10th percentile, body weight at time of autopsy lower than 10th percentile, brain weight lower than 10th percentile, foot length lower than 10th percentile, liver weight lower than 10th percentile, placental weight lower than 10th percentile, brain weight to liver weight ratio higher than 4, placental weight to birth weight ratio higher than 90th percentile, histologic or gross features of placental insufficiency/malperfusion). There was no consensus on some aspects, including how to correct for interval between fetal death and delivery. CONCLUSIONS.—: A consensus-based definition of fetal growth restriction in fetal death was determined with utility to improve management and outcomes of subsequent pregnancies.
引用
- Beune IM, Damhuis SE, Ganzevoort W, et al. Consensus Definition of Fetal Growth Restriction in Intrauterine Fetal Death: A Delphi Procedure. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2021. PMID: 32882006. doi:10.5858/arpa.2020-0027-OA
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。