米兰系统唾液腺细胞病理学不确定类别的细胞病理学家与细胞技术员间观察者变异
该研究评估细胞病理学家(CP)与细胞技术员(CT)在米兰系统(MSRSGC)下判读唾液腺不确定类别病变的一致性。2011-2016年86例不确定细针穿刺(48例有随访)经4名CP和2名CT盲法独立判读,CP与最终签署细胞病理学家(FCP)的一致率48.8%-60.5%,CT为22.1%-36%;κ值CP为0.403-0.539,CT为0.091-0.254;结论认为MSRSGC可重复性尚可但不确定类别变异大。
要点
- CP与FCP一致率48.8%-60.5%,CT仅22.1%-36%
- κ值CP为0.403-0.539,CT为0.091-0.254
- MSRSGC可重复性存在但不确定类别变异大
核心结论
- CP的一致率 modestly 高于CT,但不确定类别存在显著观察者间变异。
- MSRSGC仍能提供一定的可重复性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2011-2016年86例不确定唾液腺细针穿刺,其中48例有随访。
- 4名CP和2名CT对切片进行独立盲法判读并按MSRSGC分类。
主要发现
- CP与最终签署细胞病理学家(FCP)的一致率范围为48.8%至60.5%,CT为22.1%至36%。
- 全组观察者间κ值为0.314;以FCP为参考,CP的κ值范围为0.403至0.539,CT为0.091至0.254。
- 全部病例中一致程度为uniform 12.8%、majority 31.4%、divided 38.4%、minimal 10.5%、no agreement 6.9%;随访病例中分别为16.7%、35.4%、31.3%、8.3%、6.3%。
- 诊断挑战包括区分淋巴瘤与反应性过程以及区分黏液与黏液样物质。
临床怎么用
- MSRSGC可用于唾液腺细胞病理判读,但不确定类别需警惕观察者间差异。
- 应加强对CT和CP的MSRSGC教育培训以提高整体诊断准确性。
局限性
- 不确定类别样本量有限(86例,仅48例有随访),可能影响结果外推。
- 研究为回顾性设计,仅纳入不确定类别病例。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The indeterminate categories in the Milan System for Reporting Salivary Gland Cytopathology (MSRSGC) are diagnostically challenging because of inherent heterogeneity and complexity, with wide interobserver variability (IOV). Herein, the authors explore the concordance rate (CR) between cytopathologists (CPs) and cytotechnologists (CTs) in interpreting indeterminate salivary gland lesions using the MSRSGC. METHODS: Between 2011 and 2016, 86 indeterminate fine-needle aspirations had slides available for review, of which 48 had follow-up. Four CPs and 2 CTs performed an independent, blinded review of these slides and categorized them according to the MSRSGC. The CRs between CTs and CPs with the final sign-out cytopathologist (FCP) were assessed, and interobserver agreement was categorized into uniform, majority, divided, minimal, or no agreement. RESULTS: The overall CR with the FCP ranged from 48.8% to 60.5% for CPs and from 22.1% to 36% for CTs. IOV κ scores for the entire group were 0.314 and, with the FCP as the reference, ranged from 0.403 to 0.539 for CPs and from 0.091 to 0.254 for CTs. Uniform, majority, divided, minimal, and no agreement was noted in 12.8%, 31.4%, 38.4%, 10.5%, and 6.9%, respectively, of all cases and in 16.7%, 35.4%, 31.3%, 8.3%, and 6.3%, respectively, of the cases with follow-up. Diagnostic challenges included distinguishing lymphoma from a reactive process and distinguishing mucin from mucin-like material. CONCLUSIONS: CPs had modestly higher CRs compared with CTs; and, although the variable CRs highlight indeterminate IOV, the MSRSGC enables reproducibility. Characterizing larger cohorts in the indeterminate categories will further improve MSRSGC criteria. Moreover, education on the MSRSGC should include CTs and CPs to improve overall diagnostic accuracy.
引用
- Viswanathan K, Patel A, Abdelsayed M, et al. Interobserver variability between cytopathologists and cytotechnologists upon application and characterization of the indeterminate category in the Milan System for Reporting Salivary Gland Cytopathology. Cancer Cytopathol. 2020. PMID: 32573971. doi:10.1002/cncy.22312
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。