细胞病理医师超声引导与触诊引导细针穿刺的比较
该回顾性研究比较UCLA病理科FNA门诊中细胞病理医师实施的超声引导与触诊引导细针穿刺。共1029例,UGFNA 449例,PGFNA 580例。UGFNA不可诊断率6.7%,PGFNA 20.7%;随访不一致率5.4% vs 12.8%。结论:UGFNA性能更优。
要点
- UGFNA总体不可诊断率6.7%,显著低于PGFNA的20.7%。
- 甲状腺、头颈、涎腺病变及所有结节大小UGFNA不可诊断率均更低。
- UGFNA随访不一致率5.4%,显著低于PGFNA的12.8%。
核心结论
- 细胞病理医师实施的超声引导细针穿刺性能优于触诊引导细针穿刺。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入UCLA病理科FNA门诊由细胞病理医师实施的1029例FNA,比较UGFNA与PGFNA。
主要发现
- UGFNA 449例(43.6%),PGFNA 580例(56.4%)。
- UGFNA不可诊断率6.7%(30/449),PGFNA 20.7%(120/580)。
- 甲状腺病变不可诊断率UGFNA 6.0% vs PGFNA 33.3%。
- 头颈病变不可诊断率UGFNA 6.6% vs PGFNA 21.2%,涎腺病变6.2% vs 17.1%。
- 495例(48.1%)有随访,不一致率UGFNA 5.4% vs PGFNA 12.8%。
临床怎么用
- 在病理科FNA门诊中,对甲状腺、头颈及涎腺病变可优先考虑超声引导以减少不可诊断率。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性研究,仅48.1%病例有随访。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT.—: Although fine-needle aspiration (FNA) practice by pathologists is now well established, it has been primarily performed by manual palpation. In recent years, pathologists have begun to venture into ultrasound-guided FNAs (UGFNAs). Reports on experiences with this relatively new technique for pathologists have shown promising results. However to date, there have been few studies in the literature comparing pathologist-performed UGFNA with the more traditional pathologist-performed palpation-guided FNA (PGFNA). OBJECTIVE.—: To compare UGFNA to PGFNA by cytopathologists at an academic medical center. DESIGN.—: A retrospective study of FNAs performed by cytopathologists within the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) pathology departmental FNA clinic was performed. Data collected included performance technique (UGFNA versus PGFNA), lesion site and size, adequacy status (nondiagnostic rate), and number of passes per procedure. Corresponding surgical pathology/flow cytometric/cytogenetic result follow-up was compared to FNA results. Findings between UGFNA and PGFNA cases were compared. RESULTS.—: Of 1029 FNA cases during the study period, there were 449 UGFNA cases (43.6%) and 580 PGFNA cases (56.4%). Nondiagnostic rates with UGFNA and PGFNA were 6.7% (30 of 449 cases) and 20.7% (120 of 580 cases), respectively. Nondiagnostic rate was also significantly lower with UGFNA than with PGFNA for lesions within the thyroid (6.0% versus 33.3%), head and neck (6.6% versus 21.2%), and salivary gland (6.2% versus 17.1%), and across all nodule sizes. A total of 495 of 1029 FNA cases (48.1%) had follow-up. Discordance rate was significantly lower with UGFNA than with PGFNA (5.4% versus 12.8%). CONCLUSIONS.—: This study shows improved performance characteristics of cytopathologist-performed UGFNA versus PGFNA.
引用
- Conrad R, Yang SE, Chang S, et al. Comparison of Cytopathologist-Performed Ultrasound-Guided Fine-Needle Aspiration With Cytopathologist-Performed Palpation-Guided Fine-Needle Aspiration: A Single Institutional Experience. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2018. PMID: 29697276. doi:10.5858/arpa.2017-0123-OA
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。