细胞学涂片与液基制片用于二代测序的质量指标分析
该研究回顾性比较了细胞学涂片/液基制片(smears/LBPs)、粗针活检(core BX)和细胞块(CB)在309基因杂交捕获NGS检测中的质量指标。smears/LBPs的平均靶覆盖、中位插入片段大小和可用碱基百分比显著更高,而剪切后片段大小和重复率显著更低,提示其DNA质量优于福尔马林固定材料。
要点
- 细胞学涂片/液基制片NGS成功率88%,与粗针活检89%和细胞块97%相当。
- smears/LBPs的DNA质量指标更优:靶覆盖、插入片段和可用碱基更高,重复率更低。
- 当其他材料不足时,细胞学涂片/液基制片可作为分子检测的宝贵材料来源。
核心结论
- 细胞学涂片/液基制片的NGS检测成功率与粗针活检或细胞块相当,且DNA质量指标更优。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,连续纳入26例smears/LBPs、87例core BX和30例CB,均使用309癌症相关基因的杂交捕获NGS检测。
主要发现
- smears/LBPs的平均靶覆盖、中位插入片段大小和可用碱基百分比显著高于其他类别。
- smears/LBPs的剪切后片段大小和重复率显著低于其他类别。
关键数值与推荐
- smears/LBPs在平均靶覆盖、中位插入片段大小和可用碱基百分比上显著更高。
- smears/LBPs在剪切后片段大小和重复率上显著更低。
临床怎么用
- 当小活检等材料DNA浓度低或肿瘤比例不足导致NGS失败时,可优先考虑细胞学涂片/液基制片进行分子检测。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Next-generation sequencing (NGS) fails for many small biopsies (BXs) because of a low overall DNA concentration or tumor percentage. Cytology smears and liquid-based preparations (LBPs), or smears/LBPs, often contain abundant tumor cells and may provide adequate material for molecular testing when other materials are insufficient. This study examined the performance of smears/LBPs on a clinical NGS assay. METHODS: This study retrospectively reviewed quality metrics from consecutive smear/LBP, core BX, and cell block (CB) cases run on a hybrid-capture NGS assay interrogating 309 cancer-related genes. The following quality metrics were compared: adequacy rate, initial DNA concentration, postshearing fragment size, post-library preparation fragment size, fragment size difference, insert size, total reads, passing-filter reads aligned, percent passing-filter unique reads aligned, mean target coverage, percentage of loci with >100× coverage, percent duplication rate, percent selected bases, and percent usable bases on bait. RESULTS: Twenty-three of 26 smears/LBPs (88%) were successfully sequenced, whereas 77 of 87 core BXs (89%) and 29 of 30 CBs (97%) were. The mean target coverage, median insert size, and percent usable bases were significantly higher in the smear/LBP category. The postshearing fragment size and the percent duplication were significantly lower for smears/LBPs. CONCLUSIONS: The adequacy rate of cytology smears/LBPs for NGS is comparable to that of core BXs or CBs. Increased values for the mean insert size, mean target coverage, and percent usable bases, along with a lower duplication rate, suggest that smears/LBPs provide higher quality DNA than formalin-fixed material. Cytology smears/LBPs can serve as a valuable source of material for molecular testing. Cancer Cytopathol 2017;125:786-94. © 2017 American Cancer Society.
引用
- Hwang DH, Garcia EP, Ducar MD, et al. Next-generation sequencing of cytologic preparations: An analysis of quality metrics. Cancer Cytopathol. 2017. PMID: 28727266. doi:10.1002/cncy.21897
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。