乳腺病理会诊实践的特征分析
该研究回顾性分析了一家三级医疗中心的乳腺病理会诊实践,包括985例私人会诊和4981例连续内部病例(其中358例经多位病理学家复核)。会诊最常见原因为交界性异型性、乳头状病变分类和评估浸润。内部病例复核率为7.2%,异型性诊断病例的复核率显著高于良性或癌。免疫组化在会诊和内部复核中的应用率分别为39.7%和21.2%。结论证实了乳腺病理中诊断挑战的领域,并支持病理学家合理使用专家会诊。
要点
- 私人会诊最常见原因为交界性异型性(33.3%)、乳头状病变分类(17.2%)和评估浸润(14%)。
- 内部病例复核率为7.2%,异型性诊断复核率(24.1%)显著高于良性(4.1%)或癌(10.1%)。
- 免疫组化辅助诊断在私人会诊中占39.7%,内部复核中占21.2%。
核心结论
- 研究证实了乳腺病理中诊断挑战的领域,并支持病理学家合理使用专家会诊。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析一家三级医疗中心的乳腺病理会诊病例,包括985例私人会诊和4981例连续内部病例(其中358例经多位病理学家复核)。
- 评估会诊诊断原因、内部复核率、免疫组化使用以及私人会诊与外部诊断的一致性。
主要发现
- 私人会诊最常见原因为交界性异型性(292/878,33.3%)、乳头状病变分类(151/878,17.2%)、评估浸润(123/878,14%)、癌分型(75/878,8.5%)、梭形细胞病变分类(67/878,7.6%)和纤维上皮性病变分类(65/878,7.4%)。
- 内部病例中358例(7.2%)经复核,最常见原因为交界性异型性(90/358,25.1%)、癌分型(63/358,17.6%)、分期/预后特征(59/358,16.5%)、纤维上皮性病变分类(45/358,12.6%)、评估浸润(37/358,10.3%)、乳头状病变分类(20/358,5.6%)和梭形细胞病变分类(18/358,5.0%)。
- 内部病例中,最终诊断为异型性的病例复核率(58/241,24.1%)显著高于良性(119/2933,4.1%)或癌(182/1807,10.1%)诊断。
- 免疫组化辅助诊断在私人会诊中占39.7%(391/985),在内部复核病例中占21.2%(76/359)。
临床怎么用
- 乳腺病理诊断中,交界性异型性、乳头状病变、评估浸润和癌分型是常见会诊原因,应合理利用专家会诊。
- 对于异型性诊断的病例,内部复核率较高,提示需要加强质量控制。
- 免疫组化在会诊病例中应用较多,有助于解决诊断难题。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
CONTEXT: - Intradepartmental consultation is a routine practice commonly used for new diagnoses. Expert interinstitutional case review provides insight into particularly challenging cases. OBJECTIVE: - To investigate the practice of breast pathology consultation at a large tertiary care center. DESIGN: - We reviewed breast pathology cases sent for private consultation and internal cases reviewed by multiple pathologists at a tertiary center. Requisitions and reports were evaluated for diagnostic reason for consultation, rate of multiple pathologist review at the tertiary center, use of immunohistochemistry, and, for private consultation cases, type of sender and concordance with the outside diagnosis. RESULTS: - In the 985 private consultation cases, the most frequent reasons for review were borderline atypia (292 of 878; 33.3%), papillary lesion classification (151 of 878; 17.2%), evaluating invasion (123 of 878; 14%), subtyping carcinoma (75 of 878; 8.5%), and spindle cell (67 of 878; 7.6%) and fibroepithelial (65 of 878; 7.4%) lesion classification. Of 4981 consecutive internal cases, 358 (7.2%) were reviewed, most frequently for borderline atypia (90 of 358; 25.1%), subtyping carcinoma (63 of 358; 17.6%), staging/prognostic features (59 of 358; 16.5%), fibroepithelial lesion classification (45 of 358; 12.6%), evaluating invasion (37 of 358; 10.3%), and papillary (20 of 358; 5.6%) and spindle cell (18 of 358; 5.0%) lesion classification. Of all internal cases, those with a final diagnosis of atypia had a significantly higher rate of review (58 of 241; 24.1%) than those with benign (119 of 2933; 4.1%) or carcinoma (182 of 1807; 10.1%) diagnoses. Immunohistochemistry aided in diagnosis of 39.7% (391 of 985) and 21.2% (76 of 359) of consultation and internally reviewed cases, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: - This study confirms areas of breast pathology that represent diagnostic challenge and supports that pathologists are appropriately using expert consultation.
引用
- East EG, Zhao L, Pang JC, et al. Characteristics of a Breast Pathology Consultation Practice. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2017. PMID: 28353380. doi:10.5858/arpa.2016-0371-OA
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。