文献速递乳腺病理

乳腺病理医师诊断一致性:NHSBSP外部质量评估方案的启示

Diagnostic concordance of breast pathologists: lessons from the National Health Service Breast Screening Programme Pathology External Quality Assurance Scheme.
PubMed 文献 · Histopathology · 2016-12-28

不一致原因包括方案方法学局限和诊断困难病例,进一步复核发现病理医师误判13例(5.4%),平均不一致率仅4.2%,表明乳腺病理医师表现高。

要点

  • UK乳腺病理医师总体诊断一致率处于几乎完美范围。
  • 诊断困难病例包括乳头状病变、复杂硬化性病变等,需额外工作或二次意见。

核心结论

  • 乳腺病理医师的诊断表现高,排除方案方法学局限后真实诊断困难病例更少。

主要发现

  • 不一致原因包括编码错误(n=7)、切片代表性差异(n=18)和诊断困难病例(n=28)。
  • 进一步复核发现病理医师误判13例(5.4%),平均不一致率仅4.2%。

关键数值与推荐

  • 方案方法学局限中编码错误7例,切片代表性差异18例。
  • 诊断困难病例28例,包括乳头状病变12例、复杂硬化性病变7例、导管内上皮增生性病变6例、特殊肿瘤类型1例。
  • 病理医师误判13例(5.4%),平均不一致率4.2%。

临床怎么用

  • 对诊断困难病例(如乳头状病变、复杂硬化性病变)建议追加免疫组化或二次意见。

局限性

  • 方案方法学局限如编码错误和切片代表性差异可能影响一致性评估。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

AIMS: Previous concordance studies examining accuracy of breast diagnosis by pathologists, typically targeting difficult, histologically challenging breast lesions using artificial and restrictive environments, have reported aberrantly high levels of diagnostic discordance. The results of these studies may be misinterpreted by non-pathologists and raise concerns relating to routine practice. This study aims to assess the diagnostic agreement among UK breast pathologists. METHODS: Two hundred and forty consecutive breast lesions, submitted by participants from their routine practice, included in the UK National Health Service Breast Screening Programme (NHSBSP) breast pathology EQA scheme during the last 10 years were reviewed. An average of approximately 600 participants viewed each case. Data on diagnostic categories (benign, atypical, in-situ malignant and invasive malignant) were collected. In this study, benign and atypical diagnoses were grouped together. RESULTS: The overall diagnostic agreement level was in the almost perfect range. Thirty-five cases (14.6%) showed diagnostic concordance of ≤95%. Reasons for discordance included one or more of: (1) scheme methodology limitations such as: (i) miscoding of certain lesions (e.g. phyllodes tumours and lobular neoplasia) (n = 7) and (ii) variable representation of the index lesion on glass slides (n = 18); and (2) diagnostically challenging cases that may be interpreted more easily using immunohistochemistry (n = 28). These latter included benign and malignant papillary lesions (n = 12), complex sclerosing lesions (n = 7), intraductal epithelial proliferative lesions (n = 6) and an unusual special tumour type (n = 1). Further review identified pathologists' misinterpretation in 13 cases (5.4%), with an average discordance rate of only 4.2%. CONCLUSIONS: The performance of breast pathologists is high. Exclusion of the effect of the scheme methodology limitations highlights further the high performance rate and identifies true diagnostically challenging entities. These difficult cases may benefit from additional diagnostic work-up and second opinions.

来源:Histopathology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rakha EA, Ahmed MA, Aleskandarany MA, et al. Diagnostic concordance of breast pathologists: lessons from the National Health Service Breast Screening Programme Pathology External Quality Assurance Scheme. Histopathology. 2016. PMID: 28028831. doi:10.1111/his.13117

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。