文献速递细胞病理与分子病理

细胞学免疫细胞化学外部质量评估:英国NEQAS十年分析

External Quality Assessment of Immunocytochemistry on Cytology Samples: A 10-Year Analysis of the United Kingdom National External Quality Assessment Scheme for Immunocytochemistry and In-Situ Hybridisation Cytopathology Module.
PubMed 文献 · Arch Pathol Lab Med · 2026-05-19

结果显示90.3%的玻片染色质量满意,且随时间显著改善;细胞块平均评分高于细胞离心涂片(15.77 vs 15.19,P<.001)。参与者自评与专家评估仅弱相关(r=.30),倾向于高估自身表现。

要点

  • 细胞学ICC整体质量满意率达90.3%,且十年间持续改善。
  • 细胞块标准化程度最高,评分优于细胞离心涂片(15.77 vs 15.19)。
  • 参与者自评与专家评估相关性弱(r=.30),EQA仍具重要价值。

核心结论

  • 细胞学ICC整体表现满意并持续改善,细胞块是最稳健的标准化方式。
  • 参与者自评与专家评估不一致,EQA在识别质量差距和指导改进方面仍有持续价值。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析英国NEQAS ICC & ISH细胞学模块2014年6月至2024年5月的41轮EQA数据,涉及140家实验室。
  • 由专家评估员使用预定义评分系统(范围0-20,满意≥13)评估UK NEQAS提供玻片和参与者室内质控玻片的ICC质量。

主要发现

  • 细胞块平均评分高于细胞离心涂片(15.77 vs 15.19,P<.001),亚优结果更少。
  • 室内质控中甲醇固定平均评分高于福尔马林固定(16.36 vs 16.05,P=.003),但亚优率更高;丙酮和乙醇固定表现较差。
  • 不适当的对照选择是亚优结果的主要原因。
  • 参与者自评与专家评估弱相关(r=.30),且倾向于高估表现。

关键数值与推荐

  • 评分系统范围0-20,满意阈值≥13。
  • 细胞块 vs 细胞离心涂片平均评分:15.77 vs 15.19(P<.001)。
  • 甲醇固定 vs 福尔马林固定室内质控平均评分:16.36 vs 16.05(P=.003)。
  • 参与者自评与专家评估相关系数r=.30。

临床怎么用

  • 推荐优先使用细胞块进行ICC标准化,非细胞块样本可优化甲醇固定作为可行替代。
  • 实验室应重视对照选择,避免不适当对照导致亚优结果。
  • 参与者应结合EQA专家反馈纠正自评偏差,持续改进染色质量。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

CONTEXT.—: Immunocytochemistry (ICC) is central to diagnostic cytopathology, yet achieving consistent staining quality remains challenging owing to technical complexity and limited standardization. External quality assessment (EQA) programs provide an objective framework for benchmarking ICC performance across laboratories. OBJECTIVE.—: To analyze performance trends, technical variables, and participant self-assessment in the United Kingdom National External Quality Assessment Scheme for Immunocytochemistry and In-Situ Hybridisation (UK NEQAS ICC & ISH) cytopathology module during a 10-year period. DESIGN.—: Data from 41 EQA runs (June 2014-May 2024) involving 140 laboratories were analyzed. ICC quality on UK NEQAS-provided cytology slides and participant in-house control slides was evaluated by expert assessors using a predefined scoring system (range, 0-20; satisfactory ≥13). Expert scores, participant self-assessment, and assessors' comments were reviewed. RESULTS.—: Of 14 639 slides assessed, 90.3% achieved satisfactory staining quality, with significant improvement over time. Cell blocks showed higher mean scores and fewer suboptimal results than cytospins (15.77 versus 15.19; P < .001). Fixation influenced performance on in-house controls: methanol-fixed preparations had higher mean scores than formalin-fixed samples (16.36 versus 16.05; P = .003) but a higher suboptimal rate, while acetone- and ethanol-fixed samples performed less well. Inappropriate control selection was a major cause of suboptimal results. Participant self-assessment correlated weakly with expert evaluation (r = .30) and tended to overestimate performance. CONCLUSIONS.—: ICC performance in cytology is generally satisfactory and improving. While cell blocks offer the most robust standardization, optimized methanol fixation represents a viable alternative for non-cell block samples. The discordance between participant self-assessment and expert review highlights the continuing value of EQA in identifying quality gaps and guiding improvement.

来源:Arch Pathol Lab Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Roque RR, Kirbis IS, Parry S, et al. External Quality Assessment of Immunocytochemistry on Cytology Samples: A 10-Year Analysis of the United Kingdom National External Quality Assessment Scheme for Immunocytochemistry and In-Situ Hybridisation Cytopathology Module. Arch Pathol Lab Med. 2026. PMID: 42156080. doi:10.5858/arpa.2025-0617-OA

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。