乳腺病理第二意见(外部专家转诊)实践:诺丁汉经验
结果显示,79%的病例初始诊断被确认或倾向于其中一种建议诊断,其中17%的病例管理发生轻微改变;18%的病例分类发生显著改变并导致患者管理建议显著变化;2%的病例无法最终分类并需进一步专家意见。研究结论认为外部转诊对疑难、罕见和难以分类的乳腺病变具有价值。
要点
- 乳腺病理第二意见会诊中,79%的病例初始诊断被确认或倾向建议诊断,17%管理轻微改变。
- 18%的病例分类发生显著改变并导致患者管理建议显著变化。
- 最常见的转诊病变为乳头状病变(19%)、纤维上皮性病变(17%)和浸润性癌(17%)。
核心结论
- 外部专家转诊对疑难、罕见和难以分类的乳腺病变具有价值,专家意见可优化分类并改善患者护理。
主要发现
- 最常见病变为乳头状病变(19%)、纤维上皮性病变(17%)、浸润性癌(17%)、伴异型性的导管内上皮增生(9%)和梭形细胞病变(8%)。
- 79%的病例初始诊断被确认或倾向于其中一种建议诊断,其中129例(17%)管理发生轻微改变。
- 132例(18%)病变分类发生显著改变,导致患者管理建议显著变化。
- 14例(2%)无法最终分类,需进一步专家意见。
临床怎么用
- 对疑难、罕见和难以分类的乳腺病变,可考虑外部专家第二意见会诊以优化分类和患者管理。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Breast pathology is a challenging field, and discrepancies in diagnoses exist and can affect patient management. This study aims to review a breast referral practice and assess the pattern and frequency of breast lesions sent for an external expert review and evaluate potential impacts on patients' care. METHODS AND RESULTS: Seven hundred and forty cases that were referred to Nottingham City Hospital for a second opinion between 2019 and 2022 which have slides and reports were retrieved and reviewed. Reasons for referral, initial diagnosis, proffered specialist opinion and any discrepancy or potential impacts of management were assessed. The most frequent entities were papillary lesions (19%), fibroepithelial lesions (17%), invasive carcinomas that were sent for confirmation of the invasive diagnosis or subtyping of the invasive tumour (17%), intraductal epithelial proliferation with atypia (9%) and spindle cell lesions (8%). Other entities included biphasic tumours such as adenomyoepithelioma, as well as vascular and nipple lesions. Few cases were sent for prognostic classification or comments on the management, and in occasional cases no initial diagnosis was offered. After reviewing the cases by the expert pathologists, the initial diagnosis was confirmed or one of the suggested diagnoses was preferred in 79% of cases, including 129 cases (17%) in which the opinion resulted minor changes in the management. Significant changes in the classification of lesions were made in 132 cases (18%) which resulted in significant change in the patient management recommendation. In 14 cases (2%) a final classification was not possible, and further specialist opinion was obtained. Comments on the differential diagnosis and advice on further patient management were provided in most cases. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the value of external referral of challenging, rare and difficult to classify breast lesions. It also highlights the most common breast lesions that are likely to be challenging, and specialist opinion can refine their classification to improve patient care.
引用
- Rakha EA, Adebayo LA, Abbas A, et al. Second opinion (external specialist referral) practice of breast pathology: the Nottingham experience. Histopathology. 2023. PMID: 37356966. doi:10.1111/his.14993
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。