Claudin-4在细胞学标本转移性癌诊断中优于MOC-31和Ber-EP4
该回顾性研究纳入229例细胞学标本(211例积液和18例细针穿刺),比较Claudin-4与MOC-31、Ber-EP4在鉴别癌与间皮瘤及良性/间皮增生中的诊断价值。Claudin-4特异性和阳性预测值均为100%,灵敏度93.7%低于MOC-31但特异性更优;Ber-EP4灵敏度最低(91.6%)。Claudin-4阳性可排除间皮来源,与Ber-EP4联合可提高模糊样本的诊断效能。
要点
- Claudin-4鉴别癌与间皮瘤特异性100%,阳性可排除间皮来源。
- Claudin-4灵敏度93.7%,低于MOC-31但特异性与PPV最高。
- 细胞稀少的不确定样本,Claudin-4联合Ber-EP4可提高诊断效能。
核心结论
- Claudin-4可作为癌的单一标志物,灵敏度高且特异性优于MOC-31和Ber-EP4。
- Claudin-4阳性时可排除间皮来源。
- 在细胞稀少的不确定样本中,Claudin-4与Ber-EP4联合可获得最高的综合灵敏度和特异性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入229例细胞学标本,包括211例积液和18例细针穿刺标本。
- 细胞学分类:134例癌、28例间皮瘤、46例不确定(可疑和非典型)、21例良性。
- 不确定病例根据临床和病理进一步重新分类为良性26例、间皮瘤11例、癌9例。
- 细胞块切片行Claudin-4染色,并与既往MOC-31和Ber-EP4染色结果比较。
主要发现
- 间皮瘤(0/39)和良性积液(0/47)均无Claudin-4阳性,143例癌中134例阳性。
- Claudin-4特异性和PPV均为100%,高于MOC-31和Ber-EP4。
- Claudin-4灵敏度93.7%,低于MOC-31。
- MOC-31特异性和PPV最低,但灵敏度和NPV最高。
- Ber-EP4灵敏度最低(91.6%)。
关键数值与推荐
- Claudin-4鉴别癌与间皮瘤/良性增生的特异性100%,PPV 100%。
- Claudin-4灵敏度93.7%。
- Ber-EP4灵敏度91.6%。
- Claudin-4阳性可排除间皮 lineage。
临床怎么用
- Claudin-4可作为鉴别癌与间皮瘤的首选单一标志物。
- Claudin-4阳性时无需额外标志物即可排除间皮来源。
- 对细胞稀少的不确定样本,推荐Claudin-4与Ber-EP4联合使用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Claudin-4 is a sensitive and specific marker for carcinoma in effusion cytology. The authors examined the diagnostic use of claudin-4 versus MOC-31 and Ber-EP4 by comparing their sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV), and negative predictive value (NPV) in differentiating carcinoma from mesothelioma and benign/mesothelial hyperplasia in effusion specimens. METHODS: This retrospective study comprised a cohort of 229 cytology specimens, including 211 effusion fluid and 18 fine-needle aspiration specimens. Cytologic categories included 134 carcinoma, 28 mesothelioma, 46 indefinite (suspicious and atypical), and 21 benign. Cell block sections were stained for claudin-4 and compared with those previously stained for MOC-31 and Ber-EP4. Indefinite cases were further reclassified based on clinical and pathologic findings into benign (26 cases), mesothelioma (11 cases), and carcinoma (nine cases). RESULTS: None of the mesotheliomas (0/39) or benign effusions (0/47) were positive for claudin-4, whereas 134 of the 143 carcinoma specimens were positive. Compared to MOC-31 and Ber-EP4, claudin-4 had the highest specificity and PPV (100% for each), followed by Ber-EP4. Claudin-4 showed high sensitivity (93.7%), albeit lower than MOC-31. MOC-31 had the lowest specificity and PPV but the highest sensitivity and NPV. Ber-EP4 had the lowest sensitivity (91.6%). CONCLUSIONS: Claudin-4 can be used as a single marker for carcinoma with high sensitivity and superior specificity compared with MOC-31 and Ber-EP4. Mesothelial lineage can be ruled out when claudin-4 is positive. In equivocal cytology samples with few scattered cells of interest, a panel of claudin-4 and Ber-EP4 results in the highest combined sensitivity and specificity.
引用
- Najjar S, Gan Q, Stewart J, et al. The utility of claudin-4 versus MOC-31 and Ber-EP4 in the diagnosis of metastatic carcinoma in cytology specimens. Cancer Cytopathol. 2022. PMID: 36522809. doi:10.1002/cncy.22672
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。