细胞病理医师面向患者的沟通:诊断错误披露框架
本文讨论病理医师向患者直接披露医疗错误的障碍与必要性,指出细胞病理医师因细针穿刺(FNA)操作与患者建立关系而具有优势。文章以FNA案例为基础,提供披露医疗错误的框架、启发式原则和结构化对话系统,帮助缺乏经验的病理医师在困难的披露对话中找到自己的表达方式。
要点
- 病理医师常因缺乏信心和培训而不直接向患者披露错误。
- 细胞病理医师在FNA操作中与患者建立关系,具备直接披露优势。
- 直接披露错误需培训、练习和预先反思,文章提供结构化对话框架。
核心结论
- 病理医师直接向患者披露医疗错误需要培训、练习和预先反思,细胞病理医师因FNA操作中的患者关系而具有独特优势。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为论述性文章,以FNA案例为基础,提供披露医疗错误的框架、启发式原则和结构化对话系统。
主要发现
- 病理医师常报告错误但很少直接向患者披露,障碍包括缺乏信心、缺乏培训以及缺乏与患者的既有关系。
- 细胞病理医师在FNA操作中经常与患者互动并建立融洽关系,相比外科或临床病理医师具有直接披露的优势。
临床怎么用
- 细胞病理医师应通过培训、练习和预先反思来熟悉向患者披露错误,并可借助本文提供的框架和谈话要点指导披露对话。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Medical errors are a major source of harm to patients. Regulatory bodies mandate and patient safety experts advocate the disclosure of medical errors to patients to promote transparency and to create accountability for improving health care processes. Although pathologists regularly report errors-either to pathology or clinical colleagues or via internal safety reporting systems-few pathologists directly disclose those errors to patients. Yet many pathologists are interested in participating in the direct disclosure of medical errors to patients and may even be mandated to do so. When surveyed on why they do not directly disclose errors to patients, pathologists commonly cite a lack of confidence and a lack of training. Another barrier cited is the lack of a preexisting relationship between the pathologist and the patient. With respect to this last barrier, cytopathologists have a distinct advantage over surgical or clinical pathologists, as many cytopathologists regularly interact with and develop a rapport with patients when they are performing fine-needle aspiration (FNA) procedures. To improve the safety culture in pathology, direct error disclosure practices must be developed, supported, and strengthened. It is critical for cytopathologists to be comfortable with disclosing errors to patients. Being comfortable with disclosing an error, however, requires training, practice, and advance reflection. Using a practical, case-based format centered around FNA examples, this article addresses how to disclose a medical error to a patient. It provides a framework, heuristic principles, and structured conversation systems and talking points to guide the inexperienced pathologist to find his or her voice in a challenging disclosure conversation.
引用
- Harris CK, Darrell CM, VanderLaan PA, et al. Patient-facing communication for cytopathologists: A framework for disclosing diagnostic error. Cancer Cytopathol. 2022. PMID: 35904882. doi:10.1002/cncy.22627
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。