细胞角蛋白7/20协调作用再审视:机器学习优化转移性癌穿刺细胞块免疫组化解读算法
该研究基于1145例转移性癌穿刺细胞块免疫组化病例,利用机器学习生成决策树预测原发部位,并与两种人工设计算法比较。含免疫组化输入时决策树一致率94.5%、总准确率83.6%,加入临床数据后提升至95.3%和85.8%,优于人工算法(P < .001)。CDX2和TTF-1在模型准确性中权重最高,预测力超过细胞角蛋白7和20。
要点
- 机器学习决策树加入临床数据后一致率95.3%、准确率85.8%,优于人工免疫组化算法。
- CDX2和TTF-1免疫组化权重最高,预测力超过细胞角蛋白7和20。
- 历史诊断在非不确定病例中更准确,但不确定诊断视为不一致时机器学习占优。
核心结论
- 细胞角蛋白7和20在免疫组化 panel 中可能被CDX2、TTF-1等器官特异性标记物取代。
- 机器学习生成的算法优于人工设计算法,但不及整合临床和细胞学评估的专家判断。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入1145例接受免疫组化检测的转移性癌穿刺标本。
- 选取6个病例数最多的组进行机器学习和预测分析,生成决策树预测原发部位。
- 比较机器学习决策树与两种人工设计免疫组化算法的性能。
主要发现
- 免疫组化输入时决策树一致率94.5%、总准确率83.6%。
- 加入临床数据后一致率95.3%、总准确率85.8%,超过人工算法(P < .001)。
- 历史诊断更准确,但将不确定诊断视为不一致时机器学习占优(P < .001)。
- CDX2和TTF-1免疫组化在模型准确性中权重最高,位于决策树根部,特征重要性评分更高,预测力超过细胞角蛋白7和20。
临床怎么用
- 转移性癌穿刺细胞块免疫组化 panel 可考虑纳入CDX2、TTF-1等器官特异性标记物,而非仅依赖细胞角蛋白7/20。
- 机器学习决策树可作为辅助工具优化免疫组化解读,但专家整合临床和细胞学评估仍是更优判断。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) is a robust diagnostic technique often used for tissue diagnosis of metastatic carcinoma. For interpretation of FNA cytology, cell block immunohistochemistry (IHC) and clinicocytologic parameters are indispensable. In this review of a large cohort, the current report: 1) describes clinicocytologic parameters and immunoprofiles of aspirates of metastatic carcinoma, 2) compares the predictivity of immunostains and classical approaches for IHC interpretation, and 3) describes machine learning-based algorithms for IHC interpretation. METHODS: Aspirates of metastatic carcinoma that had IHC performed were retrieved. Clinicocytologic parameters, IHC results, the corresponding primary site, and histologic diagnoses were recorded. By using machine learning, decision trees for predicting the primary site were generated, their performance was compared with 2 human-designed algorithms, and the primary site was suggested in the historical diagnosis. RESULTS: In total, 1145 cases were identified. The 6 most populated groups were selected for machine learning and predictive analysis. With IHC input, the decision tree achieved a concordance rate of 94.5% and overall accuracy of 83.6%, which improved to 95.3% and 85.8%, respectively, when clinical data were incorporated and exceeded the human-designed IHC algorithms (P < .001). The historical diagnosis was more accurate unless indeterminate diagnoses were regarded as discordant (P < .001). CDX2 and TTF-1 immunostains had the highest weight in model accuracy, occupied the root of the decision trees, scored higher as features of importance, and outperformed the predictive power of cytokeratins 7 and 20. CONCLUSIONS: Cytokeratins 7 and 20 may be superseded in immunostaining panels, including organ-specific immunostains such as CDX2 and TTF-1. Machine learning generates algorithms that surpasses human-designed algorithms but is inferior to expert assessment integrating clinical and cytologic assessment.
引用
- Chan RCK, Lee ALS, To CCK, et al. The role of cytokeratin 7/20 coordination revisited-Machine learning identifies improved interpretative algorithms for cell block immunohistochemistry in aspirates of metastatic carcinoma. Cancer Cytopathol. 2022. PMID: 35213075. doi:10.1002/cncy.22559
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。