文献速递运动医学关节外科

ACL移植物初始张紧力越高,螺钉固定后移植物力越高,与螺钉直径无关:一项生物力学研究

A Higher Initial Tensioning Force of an ACL Graft Results in a Higher Graft Force After Screw Fixation Irrespective of the Screw Diameter: A Biomechanical Study.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2021-10-21

该生物力学研究在猪四股软组织移植物模型上,测试不同额外关节外张紧力(EATF:20 N、80 N、最大手动)和不同螺钉直径(6、7、8 mm)对关节内移植物力(IAGF)在固定后100分钟内的变化。结果显示EATF≥80 N时所有螺钉直径下100分钟IAGF均更大,而螺钉直径与100分钟IAGF无显著关联;释放EATF后IAGF下降55%至77%。

要点

  • 初始EATF≥80 N与100分钟时更高的IAGF相关,且不受螺钉直径影响。
  • 不同螺钉直径(6、7、8 mm)与100分钟IAGF无显著关联。
  • 释放EATF后100分钟内IAGF下降55%至77%。

核心结论

  • 初始EATF≥80 N与100分钟时显著更大的IAGF相关。
  • 软组织移植物在生物可吸收干涉螺钉逆行置入后IAGF大幅下降。
  • 无法就螺钉直径对IAGF的影响给出推荐。

研究设计与样本

  • 控制实验室研究,使用猪四股软组织移植物插入胫骨ACL隧道。
  • 共9个研究组,每组10个胫骨,测试不同EATF(20 N、80 N、最大手动)和螺钉直径(6、7、8 mm)的效果。
  • 在释放EATF后测量IAGF至100分钟。

主要发现

  • EATF≥80 N时所有螺钉尺寸在100分钟时IAGF均更大。
  • 100分钟时IAGF与不同螺钉直径无显著关联。
  • 置入胫骨螺钉在所有组中显著增加IAGF,但7或8 mm螺钉组施加最大手动EATF时例外。
  • 与螺钉置入结束时相比,释放EATF后100分钟时IAGF下降55%至77%。

关键数值与推荐

  • EATF≥80 N时100分钟IAGF显著更大。
  • 释放EATF后IAGF下降55%至77%。
  • 螺钉直径在隧道宽度1 mm范围内(6、7、8 mm)对100分钟IAGF无显著影响。

临床怎么用

  • 根据此模型,为获得生物可吸收干涉螺钉固定后更高的残余移植物力,应施加初始EATF≥80 N。
  • 释放EATF后移植物力显著下降,提示术后重建膝关节不能仅靠固定维持机械稳定。

局限性

  • 研究为猪离体生物力学模型,结论外推至人体需谨慎。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The intra-articular graft force (IAGF) in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction decreases quickly over the first hours after surgery. Nevertheless, little is known about whether the initial extra-articular tensioning force (EATF) and screw diameter affect the graft force after fixation. PURPOSE: To investigate the effects of different EATFs on the IAGF of a soft tissue graft fixated via a bioabsorbable interference screw over 100 minutes after fixation and to evaluate the effects of different screw diameters within 1 mm of the tunnel width during this process. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: In this biomechanical study, a porcine quadruple-strand soft tissue graft was inserted into the tibial anterior cruciate ligament tunnel. On the extra-articular side, 3 loads were applied during retrograde insertion of the bioabsorbable interference screw (6, 7, and 8 mm): 20 N, 80 N, and maximum manual EATF (Nmax). Nine study groups consisting of 10 tibiae each were created to test the effects of different EATFs and screw sizes. The IAGF was measured up to 100 minutes after the EATF was released. RESULTS: An EATF ≥80 N resulted in a larger IAGF for all screw sizes at 100 minutes. There were no significant associations between the IAGF at 100 minutes and different screw diameters. Inserting the tibial screw significantly increased the IAGF in all groups, with the exception of Nmax applied in groups with 7- or 8-mm screws. When compared with the end of screw insertion, after the release of the EATF, the IAGF dropped by 55% to 77 % at 100 minutes. CONCLUSION: An initial EATF ≥80 N is associated with a significantly larger IAGF at 100 minutes in this cadaveric simulation. The IAGF in soft tissue grafts decreased substantially after the retrograde placement of an interference screw. A recommendation regarding screw diameter with respect to the IAGF cannot be given. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: To obtain a higher residual graft force after bioabsorbable interference screw fixation, an initial EATF ≥80 N should be applied according to this model. The significant decrease in graft force after the release of the EATF indicates that the reconstructed knee cannot be mechanically stabilized after the surgery.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kayaalp ME, Collette R, Kruppa P, et al. A Higher Initial Tensioning Force of an ACL Graft Results in a Higher Graft Force After Screw Fixation Irrespective of the Screw Diameter: A Biomechanical Study. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 34672786. doi:10.1177/03635465211047861

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。