厚颈股骨柄在陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换中颈部-内衬撞击和切迹风险高
本研究回顾性分析了456例接受陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换的患者,中位随访13年。结果显示,厚颈股骨柄设计下,股骨颈-陶瓷内衬撞击(柄颈切迹)的比例为11%,且28mm头比32mm头更易发生撞击(90% vs 70%)。陶瓷头骨折率为2%,均为28mm短颈头。无撞击病例出现陶瓷骨折或金属沉着。
要点
- 厚颈股骨柄在陶瓷对陶瓷THA中颈部切迹发生率为11%。
- 28mm头较32mm头发生柄颈切迹的风险更高(OR 3.77)。
- 陶瓷头骨折率为2%,均发生在28mm短颈头。
核心结论
- 厚颈股骨柄设计在陶瓷对陶瓷THA中导致不可接受的高比例颈部-内衬撞击和陶瓷部件骨折,尤其使用28mm头时。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2003年5月至2010年4月同一三级医院接受初次THA的621例患者,最终456例(73%)完成至少10年随访,平均年龄50±14岁,中位随访13年(10-17年)。
主要发现
- 柄颈切迹(撞击)比例为11%(49/456),切迹组与非切迹组杯外展和前倾无差异。
- 切迹组中28mm头比例高于非切迹组(90% vs 70%;OR 3.77 [95%CI 1.46-9.73];p=0.004)。
- 49例切迹髋均无陶瓷头或内衬骨折或金属沉着证据。
- 陶瓷头骨折率2%(9/456),均发生在28mm短颈头;陶瓷内衬骨折率0.2%(1/456);噪音发生率6%(27/456)。
- 髋臼骨溶解发生率2%(7/456);末次随访mHHS为91±12分;13年无植入物翻修生存率97%(95%CI 96%-99%),无再手术生存率96%(95%CI 95%-98%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 杯松动标准:倾斜≥4°或移位≥4mm;柄松动标准:下沉>3mm、位置任何改变或连续透亮线>2mm。
- 骨溶解评估通过CT扫描在57%(262/456)患者中进行。
- 柄颈切迹的X线检测可靠性:观察者内κ=0.963(p<0.001),观察者间κ=0.975(p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 建议避免在陶瓷对陶瓷 bearings 中使用厚颈股骨柄设计,尤其是28mm头。
- 术后随访应关注X线柄颈切迹,以及噪音、陶瓷骨折等并发症。
局限性
- 回顾性研究,19%患者失访,8%患者死亡,可能引入选择偏倚。
- 仅57%患者进行CT评估骨溶解,可能存在低估。
- 研究仅针对一种厚颈柄设计,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recently, impingement between the femoral stem and ceramic liner, which appears as a notch in the stem neck on radiographs, has emerged as a new complication. However, the proportion of impingement, potential risk factors, and related complications are poorly elucidated. QUESTION/PURPOSES: In patients who underwent ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) THA and had at least 10 years of follow-up, we asked: (1) What proportion had radiographic evidence of stem neck-ceramic liner impingement (notching of the stem), and what implant design, implantation factors, or complications such as ceramic fracture or metallosis are associated with impingement? (2) How common are the complications of noise and ceramic fracture? (3) What are the radiologic changes (including fixation of femoral and acetabular components, osteolysis, and heterotopic ossification) and clinical outcomes as determined by the modified Harris hip score (mHHS) for this cohort? (4) What is the survivorship with implant revision as the endpoint and with reoperation for any reason as the endpoint after CoC THA using a thick-neck stem design? METHODS: Between May 2003 and April 2010, 643 patients underwent primary THA at a tertiary referral hospital. After excluding patients with metal-on-polyethylene and with ceramic-on-polyethylene implants, 621 patients were considered eligible for this study. All patients received the same hemispherical titanium cup, a standard-length tapered titanium stem, and a CoC bearing. Of those, 19% (115) were lost to follow-up before 10 years, and 8% (50) were excluded because they died before the minimum follow-up duration of 10 years, leaving 73% (456) for analysis. Patients had a mean age of 50 ± 14 years and were followed for a median (range) of 13 years (10 to 17). The mean cup abduction was 38° ± 5°, and the mean cup anteversion was 26° ± 7°. To determine the proportion of patients with the neck-liner impingement, we analyzed the plain radiographs of every patient during follow-up to detect notches around the stem. The detection of stem neck notches on the radiographs was reliable (intraobserver reliability: κ = 0.963; p < 0.001 and interobserver reliability: κ = 0.975; p < 0.001). To evaluate factors related to notching, we compared the possible confounding factors including gender, age, BMI, implant position, neck length, and head diameter. Complications such as ceramic fracture, noise, dislocation, and periprosthetic joint infection were recorded. Noise was evaluated via interview and with the Hip Noise Assessment Questionnaire, which assessed the noise qualitatively. For clinical outcome, we assessed the mHHS, which includes pain and function scales (0 [worst] to 100 [best]), every visit. Tilting of at least 4° or migration of at least 4 mm was the criteria for cup loosening; subsidence more than 3 mm, any change in position, or a continuous radiolucent line greater than 2 mm was the criteria for stem loosening. To evaluate osteolysis, we performed CT scans in 57% (262 of 456) of patients. Kaplan-Meier survivorship analysis was performed using the endpoints of survivorship free from implant revision and survivorship free from reoperation for any cause. RESULTS: The proportion of stem neck notching was 11% (49 of 456). There were no differences in cup abduction and anteversion between hips with notches and those without notches. Notched hips were more likely to have 28-mm than 32-mm heads (90% [44 of 49] versus 70% [285 of 407]; odds ratio 3.77 [95% CI 1.46 to 9.73]; p = 0.004). None of the 49 notched hips had a ceramic head or liner fracture or evidence of metallosis. A ceramic head fracture was reported in 2% (9 of 456); all fractures occurred in 28-mm short neck heads. A ceramic liner fracture occurred in 0.2% (1 of 456), and noise was noted in 6% (27 of 456). Acetabular osteolysis developed in 2% (7 of 456). The mHHS was 91 ± 12 points at the final follow-up. The survivorship free from implant revision was 97% (95% CI 96% to 99%), and the survivorship free from reoperation for any cause was 96% (95% CI 95% to 98%) at 13 years. CONCLUSION: The proportion of stems with neck-ceramic liner impingement and ceramic component fracture were unacceptably high after the use of a thick-neck stem design, especially when a 28-mm head was used. We have discontinued the use of this stem design and we recommend that such stems should not be used when CoC bearings are used. As these findings might be generalized to other bearing couples, further studies focused on polyethylene liner wear and local metallosis due to thick stem neck are warranted. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Kim HS, Park JW, Lee SJ, et al. High Risk of Neck-liner Impingement and Notching Observed with Thick Femoral Neck Implants in Ceramic-on-ceramic THA. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 34699410. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。