植入物品牌组合、数据掩盖可能性及骨科数据评估 panel 在全膝关节置换术中的作用
该研究通过假设性植入物品牌组合计算兼容植入物构建组合的数量,发现简单膝关节组合有4种组合,每增加一个组件选项数量翻倍,添加第三种选项乘以1.3,引入非骨水泥选项乘以4,最终可达192种组合。结论认为品牌组合的多样化导致大量兼容组合,翻修率未在此粒度审查,存在真实结果被掩盖的风险。
要点
- 膝关节品牌组合内多变异体导致数百种兼容植入物构建组合。
- 翻修率目前未在植入物组合层面审查,真实结果可能被掩盖。
- 骨科数据评估 panel 在监测植入物性能中发挥作用。
核心结论
- 膝关节品牌组合中添加多个变异体导致大量(数百)兼容植入物构建组合,翻修率未在此粒度审查,存在真实结果被掩盖的风险。
研究设计与样本
- 研究提出假设性植入物品牌组合,并计算兼容植入物构建组合的数量。
主要发现
- 简单膝关节组合(骨水泥固定CR和PS组件,含或不含髌骨)有4种组合。
- 每个组件有两个选项时数量翻倍,导致32种组合;添加第三个选项乘以1.3。
- 引入兼容非骨水泥选项及混合效应乘以4。
- 两个股骨组件(CR和PS)、两个衬垫选项和髌骨,均骨水泥和非骨水泥版本,导致192种可能兼容组合。
- 有品牌提供远多于两个选项。
临床怎么用
- 临床应关注植入物品牌组合的复杂性对结果评估的影响。
- 需在更细粒度审查翻修率以避免数据掩盖。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Knee arthroplasty surgery is a highly effective treatment for arthritis and disorders of the knee. There are a wide variety of implant brands and types of knee arthroplasty available to surgeons. As a result of a number of highly publicized failures, arthroplasty surgery is highly regulated in the UK and many other countries through national registries, introduced to monitor implant performance, surgeons, and hospitals. With time, the options available within many brand portfolios have grown, with alternative tibial or femoral components, tibial insert materials, or shapes and patella resurfacings. In this study we have investigated the effect of the expansion of implant brand portfolios and where there may be a lack of transparency around a brand name. We also aimed to establish the potential numbers of compatible implant construct combinations. METHODS: Hypothetical implant brand portfolios were proposed, and the number of compatible implant construct combinations was calculated. RESULTS: A simple knee portfolio with cemented cruciate-retaining (CR) and posterior-stabilized (PS) components, with and without a patella, has four combinations. If there are two options available for each component, the numbers double for each option, resulting in 32 combinations. The effect of adding a third option multiplies the number by 1.3. Introducing compatible uncemented options, with the effect of hybrids, multiplies the number by 4. An implant portfolio with two femoral components (both in CR and PS), with two insert options and a patella, all in cemented and uncemented versions leads to 192 possible compatible implant construct combinations. There are implant brands available to surgeons with many more than two options. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that the addition of multiple variants within a knee brand portfolio leads to a large number (many hundreds) of compatible implant construct combinations. Revision rates of implant combinations are not currently reviewed at this level of granularity, leading to the risk of camouflage of true outcomes. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(10):1555-1560.
引用
- Phillips JRA, Tucker K. Implant brand portfolios, the potential for camouflage of data, and the role of the Orthopaedic Data Evaluation Panel in total knee arthroplasty. Bone Joint J. 2021. PMID: 34587804. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.103B10.BJJ-2021-0284.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。