患者姿势影响反肩置换模拟活动度:基于术前规划软件的建模研究
本研究利用30例患者全躯干CT和三维术前规划软件虚拟植入反肩假体,分析三种姿势类型对模拟活动度的影响。结果发现姿势类型显著影响除屈曲外各平面活动度,C型姿势活动度最差;调整假体配置可减轻B型和C型姿势的负面影响。
要点
- C型姿势患者模拟内收、外展、后伸和外旋活动度均显著低于A型姿势。
- 较低后倾、较高颈干角和小同心盂球在C型姿势中整体活动度更差。
- C型姿势患者采用较高后倾、较低颈干角和较大或偏心盂球可能有利。
核心结论
- 不同姿势类型影响模拟反肩置换术后的活动度,且不依赖于假体配置。
- 基于肩胸廓方向的个体化假体配置选择似乎可减轻B型和C型姿势的负面影响。
研究设计与样本
- 计算机实验室研究,分析30例患者(20男10女,平均年龄65±17岁)的全躯干CT扫描。
- 根据肩胛骨内旋测量将姿势分为A型(直立、肩胛骨后缩)、B型(中间)和C型(后凸、肩胛骨前伸)。
- 三名肩外科医生使用三维术前规划软件独立虚拟植入短、弯曲、干骺端压配柄反肩假体,并自动生成不同假体配置,共3720种组合。
主要发现
- 无论假体配置如何,姿势类型对除屈曲外所有运动平面的计算活动度有强烈影响。
- C型姿势与A型姿势相比,模拟内收中位数5°(IQR -7°至20°) vs 15°(IQR 7°至22°),p<0.01。
- C型姿势与A型姿势相比,模拟外展中位数63°(IQR 48°至78°) vs 72°(IQR 63°至82°),p<0.01。
- C型姿势与A型姿势相比,模拟后伸中位数4°(IQR -8°至12°) vs 19°(IQR 8°至27°),p<0.01。
- C型姿势与A型姿势相比,模拟外旋中位数7°(IQR -5°至22°) vs 28°(IQR 13°至39°),p<0.01。
关键数值与推荐
- 肩胛骨内旋测量定义姿势类型的组内相关系数为0.87,表明分类可靠。
- C型姿势患者中,较低后倾、较高颈干角和小同心盂球导致内收、后伸和外旋活动度严重受限至0°以下。
临床怎么用
- C型姿势患者可能受益于较高后倾、较低颈干角和较大或下偏心盂球。
- 未来反肩置换术后活动度研究应考虑患者姿势和肩胸廓方向。
局限性
- 本研究为计算机模拟研究,结果需临床验证。
- 样本量有限(30例患者),可能影响普遍性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Component selection and placement in reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (RTSA) is still being debated. Recently, scapulothoracic orientation and posture have emerged as relevant factors when planning an RTSA. However, the degree to which those parameters may influence ROM and whether modifiable elements of implant configuration may be helpful in improving ROM among patients with different postures have not been thoroughly studied, and modeling them may be instructive. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Using a dedicated expansion of a conventional preoperative planning software, we asked: (1) How is patient posture likely to influence simulated ROM after virtual RTSA implantation? (2) Do changes in implant configuration, such as humeral component inclination and retrotorsion, or glenoid component size and centricity improve the simulated ROM after virtual RTSA implantation in patients with different posture types? METHODS: In a computer laboratory study, available whole-torso CT scans of 30 patients (20 males and 10 females with a mean age of 65 ± 17 years) were analyzed to determine the posture type (Type A, upright posture, retracted scapulae; Type B, intermediate; Type C, kyphotic posture with protracted scapulae) based on the measured scapula internal rotation as previously described. The measurement of scapular internal rotation, which defines these posture types, was found to have a high intraclass correlation coefficient (0.87) in a previous study, suggesting reliability of the employed classification. Three shoulder surgeons each independently virtually implanted a short, curved, metaphyseal impaction stem RTSA in each patient using three-dimensional (3D) preoperative surgical planning software. Modifications based on the original component positioning were automatically generated, including different humeral component retrotorsion (0°, 20°, and 40° of anatomic and scapular internal rotation) and neck-shaft angle (135°, 145°, and 155°) as well as glenoid component configuration (36-mm concentric, 36-mm eccentric, and 42-mm concentric), resulting in 3720 different RTSA configurations. For each configuration, the maximum potential ROM in different planes was determined by the software, and the effect of different posture types was analyzed by comparing subgroups. RESULTS: Irrespective of the RTSA implant configuration, the posture types had a strong effect on the calculated ROM in all planes of motion, except for flexion. In particular, simulated ROM in patients with Type C compared with Type A posture demonstrated inferior adduction (median 5° [interquartile range -7° to 20°] versus 15° [IQR 7° to 22°]; p < 0.01), abduction (63° [IQR 48° to 78°] versus 72° [IQR 63° to 82°]; p < 0.01), extension (4° [IQR -8° to 12°] versus 19° [IQR 8° to 27°]; p < 0.01), and external rotation (7° [IQR -5° to 22°] versus 28° [IQR 13° to 39°]; p < 0.01). Lower retrotorsion and a higher neck-shaft angle of the humeral component as well as a small concentric glenosphere resulted in worse overall ROM in patients with Type C posture, with severe restriction of motion in adduction, extension, and external rotation to below 0°. CONCLUSION: Different posture types affect the ROM after simulated RTSA implantation, regardless of implant configuration. An individualized choice of component configuration based on scapulothoracic orientation seems to attenuate the negative effects of posture Type B and C. Future studies on ROM after RTSA should consider patient posture and scapulothoracic orientation. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: In patients with Type C posture, higher retrotorsion, a lower neck-shaft angle, and a larger or inferior eccentric glenosphere seem to be advantageous.
引用
- Moroder P, Urvoy M, Raiss P, et al. Patient Posture Affects Simulated ROM in Reverse Total Shoulder Arthroplasty: A Modeling Study Using Preoperative Planning Software. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 34669618. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000002003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。