文献速递关节外科

不同年龄组全膝与单髁置换长期结局的匹配比较:基于英格兰、威尔士、北爱尔兰和马恩岛国家关节登记数据库的分析

A Matched Comparison of Long-Term Outcomes of Total and Unicompartmental Knee Replacements in Different Ages Based on National Databases: Analysis of Data From the National Joint Registry for England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and the Isle of Man.
PubMed 文献 · J Arthroplasty · 2021-10-05

该研究基于国家关节登记与医院 Episode 统计数据库,将 54,215 例单髁置换(UKR)与 54,215 例全膝置换(TKR)进行倾向评分匹配,比较不同年龄组的长期结局。结果显示 UKR 的 10 年翻修率(12% vs 5%,HR 2.31,P < .001)和再手术率(25% vs 21%,HR 1.12,P < .001)更高,但 10 年死亡率更低(13.6% vs 15.5%,HR 0.86,P < .001)。结论认为 UKR 决策应结合年龄权衡翻修/再手术与死亡风险,>75 岁组 UKR 的绝对死亡减少大于再手术增加。

要点

  • UKR 10 年翻修率 12% 高于 TKR 5%(HR 2.31,P < .001)。
  • UKR 10 年再手术率 25% 略高于 TKR 21%(HR 1.12,P < .001)。
  • UKR 10 年死亡率 13.6% 低于 TKR 15.5%(HR 0.86,P < .001)。

核心结论

  • UKR 相比匹配的 TKR 翻修率更高、再手术率略高,但死亡率更低。
  • UKR 决策应部分基于翻修/再手术与死亡风险的平衡,该平衡受患者年龄影响。
  • 在 >75 岁组,数据提示 UKR 相比 TKR 的绝对死亡减少大于再手术率增加。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于 National Joint Registry 与 Hospital Episode Statistics 数据库的倾向评分匹配比较。
  • 共纳入 54,215 例 UKR 和 54,215 例 TKR,采用 Kaplan-Meier 和回归分析比较翻修、再手术、死亡及 3 个月并发症。
  • 证据等级为 III 级。

主要发现

  • UKR 10 年翻修率 12% vs TKR 5%(HR 2.31,P < .001)。
  • UKR 10 年再手术率 25% vs TKR 21%(HR 1.12,P < .001)。
  • UKR 10 年死亡率 13.6% vs TKR 15.5%(HR 0.86,P < .001)。
  • UKR 医疗并发症(P < .001)和手术相关并发症(P < .001)更低,死亡 HR 0.61(P = .02)。
  • 每 100 例 UKR 替代 TKR 的 10 年绝对差异:<55 岁多 7 例再手术少 1 例死亡;55-64 岁多 6 例再手术多 2 例死亡;65-74 岁多 4 例再手术少 2 例死亡;≥75 岁多 3 例再手术少 4 例死亡。

关键数值与推荐

  • UKR 10 年翻修率 12%,TKR 5%(HR 2.31,P < .001)。
  • UKR 10 年再手术率 25%,TKR 21%(HR 1.12,P < .001)。
  • UKR 10 年死亡率 13.6%,TKR 15.5%(HR 0.86,P < .001)。
  • UKR 死亡 HR 0.61(P = .02);医疗并发症 P < .001,手术相关并发症 P < .001。

临床怎么用

  • 选择 UKR 或 TKR 时应结合患者年龄权衡翻修/再手术风险与死亡风险。
  • 对 >75 岁患者,UKR 相比 TKR 的绝对死亡减少大于再手术率增加,可据此个体化决策。
  • 需向患者说明 UKR 翻修率高于 TKR 但死亡率更低的长期结局差异。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The 2 main treatment options for end-stage single compartment knee arthritis are unicompartmental (UKR) or total knee replacement (TKR). We compared the long-term outcomes in different age groups. METHODS: In total, 54,215 UKRs and 54,215 TKRs from the National Joint Registry and Hospital Episode Statistics database were propensity score matched and Kaplan-Meier and regression analysis used to compare revision, reoperation, mortality, and 3-month complications. RESULTS: UKR had higher 10-year revision rates (12% vs 5%, hazard ratio [HR] 2.31, P < .001) and 10-year reoperation rates (25% vs 21%, HR 1.12, P < .001). UKR had lower 10-year mortality rates (13.6% vs 15.5%, HR 0.86, P < .001). UKR had lower rates of medical (P < .001) and procedure related (P < .001) complications and deaths (HR 0.61, P = .02). If 100 patients had a UKR instead of a TKR then over 10 years, if they were <55 years old there would be 7 more reoperations and 1 less death; if they were 55-64 years old there would be 6 more reoperations and 2 more deaths; if they were 65-74 years old there would be 4 more reoperations and 2 less deaths; and if they were ≥75 years old there would be 3 more reoperations and 4 less deaths. CONCLUSION: UKR has higher revision and slightly higher reoperation rates but lower mortality rates than matched TKR. The decision to do a UKR should, in part, be based on the balance of these risks, which are influenced by patient age. In the elderly group (>75 years) the data suggests that UKR compared to TKR has a greater absolute reduction in mortality than the increase in reoperation rate. LEVELS OF EVIDENCE: III.

来源:J Arthroplasty,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mohammad HR, Liddle AD, Judge A, et al. A Matched Comparison of Long-Term Outcomes of Total and Unicompartmental Knee Replacements in Different Ages Based on National Databases: Analysis of Data From the National Joint Registry for England, Wales, Northern Ireland, and the Isle of Man. J Arthroplasty. 2021. PMID: 34619307. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2021.09.018

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。