不同全膝关节置换假体设计在一期翻修治疗假体周围感染中的临床结局
该回顾性研究纳入211例感染膝关节假体患者,最终161例完成分析,按翻修假体类型分四组,平均随访6年。结果显示总体翻修率23%,感染控制率91%,各组翻修率与功能评分无显著差异;无菌性失败多发生于Citak C型股骨形态。
要点
- 铰链与非铰链假体在一期翻修后翻修率及功能结局无显著差异。
- 总体翻修率23%,感染复发率9%,感染控制率91%。
- Citak C型股骨形态患者中无菌性失败比例较高。
核心结论
- 一期翻修治疗假体周围感染总体翻修率较高,但感染控制率良好。
- 铰链假体可获得与非铰链假体相似的翻修率和功能结局。
- Citak C型股骨形态可能是无菌性失败的风险因素。
研究设计与样本
- 按翻修假体类型分为四组:双髁全膝置换至旋转铰链、旋转铰链至旋转铰链、旋转铰链至全铰链、全铰链至全铰链。
- 平均随访6年(范围3至9年,标准差1.9),最低随访3年。
- 功能结局采用术后牛津膝关节评分(OKS,60分制,分数越低疼痛越轻、功能越好)。
- 股骨形态按Citak分类系统确定。
主要发现
- 最终随访时总体手术翻修率为23%(37/161),假体周围感染复发率为9%(15/161)。
- 无菌性松动病例中74%(14/19)发生于Citak C型股骨形态(组1为75%,组2为56%,组3为100%,组4为100%)。
关键数值与推荐
- 总体翻修率23%(37/161),感染复发率9%(15/161)。
- 无菌性松动中Citak C型占74%(14/19)。
临床怎么用
- 一期翻修治疗假体周围感染时,铰链假体可作为与非铰链假体等效的选择。
- 术前应评估股骨形态(Citak分类),C型患者需警惕无菌性失败风险。
- 需个体化选择翻修假体设计,并加强术后随访监测。
局限性
- 回顾性设计,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 样本量有限,部分组别病例数较少(如组4仅19例)。
- 平均随访6年,不足以评估长期假体生存率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite the growing number of studies reporting on the best surgical treatment in the management of periprosthetic joint infection, there are no robust data regarding the type of infected prosthesis before any kind of exchange arthroplasty. To overcome these shortcomings, we asked the following questions: (1) What is the survivorship of nonhinged and hinged knee implants after one-stage exchange arthroplasty and (2) what is the functional outcome after one-stage exchange procedure focusing on knee prostheses and the type of prior infected knee implant. In a secondary radiographic analysis, we also investigated if (3) the type of femoral bone morphology measured by the inner femoral diameter influences the rate of aseptic failures also in patients with periprosthetic joint infection. METHODS: Between January 2011 and December 2017, we performed a retrospective designed study including 211 patients with infected knee prostheses. After all, seventy-six percent (161 of 211 patients) were available for final data analysis. These patients were divided into four groups as per the performed implant revision: (1) bicondylar total knee arthroplasty to rotating hinge implant, (2) rotating hinge to rotating hinge implant, (3) rotating hinge to full hinge implant, and (4) full hinge to full hinge implant. The mean follow-up (FU) was six years (range 3 to 9; standard deviation = 1.9), whereas a minimum FU of three years was required for inclusion. Survivorship and group analysis were performed, and the functional outcome was assessed using postoperative Oxford Knee Scores at the latest FU (60-point scale with lower scores representing less pain and greater function). Furthermore, in all cases, femoral bone morphology was determined as per the Citak classification system. RESULTS: At the final FU, the overall surgical revision rate was 23% (37/161 patients) with nine percent (15/161 patients) suffering a periprosthetic joint infection relapse. Group 1 consisted of 51, group 2 consisted of 67, group 3 consisted of 24, and group 4 consisted of 19 patients. The lowest overall revision rate was found in group 2 (16%, n = 11), compared with 28% (n = 14) in group 1, 29% (n = 7) in group 3, and 26% (n = 5) in group 4; however, no significant differences were found (P = .902). The functional outcome (Oxford Knee Score) was clinically constant in all groups, with 32 points in group 1, 37 points in group 2, 33 points in group 3, and 35 points in group 4 (P = .107). Concerning the number of patients with aseptic loosening as per bone morphology, 74% (14/19) of all aseptic loosening cases appeared in femoral bone type C morphologies according to Citak (75% in group 1, 56% in group 2, 100% in group 3, and 100% in group 4). CONCLUSIONS: The results obtained suggest a generally high overall revision rate (25%) with a good infection control rate (91%). Although we were unable to work out a specific group of patients with a statistically significant differing outcome, it is interesting to see that hinged implants can reach more or less the same functional outcome and revision rates as nonhinged implants, when it comes to revision surgeries. In this study, a relatively high number of aseptic failures contributed to a high overall revision rate. In this context, the bone morphology, measured as per the Citak classification system, could be confirmed as a risk factor for aseptic failures also in septic patients. Therefore, further research might focus on revision knee implant design.
引用
- Ohlmeier M, Alrustom F, Citak M, et al. The Clinical Outcome of Different Total Knee Arthroplasty Designs in One-Stage Revision for Periprosthetic Infection. J Arthroplasty. 2021. PMID: 34648923. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2021.10.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。