文献速递运动医学关节外科

肩关节钙化性肌腱炎关节镜治疗:肩袖修复与清创的临床与结构结果比较

Clinical and Structural Results of Rotator Cuff Repair Compared With Rotator Cuff Debridement in Arthroscopic Treatment of Calcifying Tendinitis of the Shoulder.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2021-09-16

回顾性队列研究纳入44例(46肩)肩关节钙化性肌腱炎患者,平均随访58.4个月,比较关节镜下钙化灶清除后附加肩袖修复(22例)与单纯肩袖清创(22例)的临床与结构结果。修复组在Constant评分、ASES评分、SST及疼痛、功能、满意度NRS上均显著优于清创组,且术后肌腱完整性(Sugaya分级)修复组更优。结论认为两种方法中期结果均良好至优秀,但附加修复者临床与结构结果更佳。

要点

  • 关节镜下钙化灶清除后附加肩袖修复较单纯清创可显著改善Constant、ASES、SST及疼痛、功能、满意度评分。
  • 修复组术后肌腱完整性(Sugaya I级80%)优于清创组(Sugaya II级64%),差异有统计学意义(P=.004)。
  • 清创组约三分之一患者术后O'Brien试验阳性,修复组无阳性。

核心结论

  • 关节镜下钙化灶清除后附加肩袖修复或单纯清创均可获得良好至优秀的中期临床与结构结果。
  • 附加修复肌腱缺损的患者临床结果显著更优,且肌腱完整性(Sugaya分级)显著更好。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,证据等级3级,纳入44例患者(46肩),平均随访58.4个月。
  • 修复组22例接受附加肩袖修复,清创组22例接受单纯肩袖清创,两组在性别、年龄及钙化灶大小和一致性(Gärtner和Bosworth分类)上可比。
  • 29例患者(清创组14例,修复组15例)在随访时接受磁共振成像以Sugaya分类评估结构结果。

主要发现

  • 所有患者对手术结果满意;修复组100%、清创组95.7%表示愿意再次接受手术。
  • 修复组 vs 清创组:Constant评分86.2 vs 80.6(P=.04),ASES评分98.3 vs 88.9(P=.004),SST 11.6 vs 10(P=.005)。
  • 修复组 vs 清创组:疼痛NRS 0.1 vs 0.8(P=.007),功能NRS 9.6 vs 8.8(P=.008),满意度NRS 9.8 vs 9.1(P=.036)。
  • 术后肌腱完整性:修复组80% Sugaya I级,清创组64% Sugaya II级,差异有统计学意义(P=.004)。
  • 术后临床评估修复组无O'Brien试验阳性,清创组约三分之一呈阳性。

关键数值与推荐

  • Constant评分修复组86.2 vs 清创组80.6(P=.04)。
  • ASES评分修复组98.3 vs 清创组88.9(P=.004)。
  • SST修复组11.6 vs 清创组10(P=.005)。
  • 疼痛NRS修复组0.1 vs 清创组0.8(P=.007);功能NRS 9.6 vs 8.8(P=.008);满意度NRS 9.8 vs 9.1(P=.036)。
  • Sugaya分级:修复组80% I级,清创组64% II级(P=.004)。

临床怎么用

  • 对于肩关节钙化性肌腱炎行关节镜下钙化灶清除的患者,附加肩袖修复可能带来更优的临床评分与肌腱完整性。
  • 术后O'Brien试验阳性在单纯清创组更常见,提示附加修复可能有助于减少残留体征。

局限性

  • 回顾性队列设计,证据等级3级。
  • 仅29例患者(清创组14例,修复组15例)完成随访磁共振成像结构评估。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Arthroscopic treatment of calcifying tendinitis of the shoulder reveals good to excellent results. However, whether the tendon needs to be repaired after removal of the calcific deposit or simply debrided remains unclear. PURPOSE: To evaluate the structural and clinical results after arthroscopic calcific deposit removal with additional rotator cuff repair or rotator cuff debridement. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: A total of 44 patients (46 shoulders) were enrolled in this retrospective cohort study with a mean follow-up of 58.4 months. Patients underwent arthroscopic removal of a calcific deposit and bursectomy after failed nonoperative treatment. A total of 22 patients received additional rotator cuff repair irrespective of the degree of debridement (the repair group), whereas 22 patients received a simple rotator cuff debridement without additional repair (the debridement group). Groups were comparable in sex, age, and size and consistency of the deposits according to the Gärtner and Bosworth classifications. Clinical evaluation was performed by the Constant score, Simple Shoulder Test, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) score, and numerical rating scales for pain, function, and satisfaction. In 29 patients (14 in the debridement group and 15 in the repair group), additional magnetic resonance imaging at follow-up was performed to evaluate the structural results using the Sugaya classification. RESULTS: All patients were satisfied with the results of surgery; 100% of the repair group and 95.7% of the debridement group reported they would undergo the surgical procedure again. Comparison of the clinical results showed significantly better results in the repair group versus the debridement group for the Constant score (86.2 vs 80.6, respectively; P = .04), the ASES score (98.3 vs 88.9; P = .004), the Simple Shoulder Test (11.6 vs 10; P = .005), and the numerical rating scales for pain (0.1 vs 0.8; P = .007), function (9.6 vs 8.8; P = .008), and satisfaction (9.8 vs 9.1; P = .036). Comparison of the postoperative tendon integrity showed 80% Sugaya grade I in the rotator cuff repair group and 64% Sugaya grade II in the debridement group, with a statistically significant difference in favor of the repair group (P = .004). Postoperative clinical evaluation revealed no positive O'Brien tests in the repair group, whereas approximately one-third of the debridement group showed a positive O'Brien test during examination. CONCLUSION: Arthroscopic removal of calcific deposits with rotator cuff debridement or cuff repair showed good to excellent clinical and structural midterm results. However, patients who underwent additional repair of the tendon defect had significantly better clinical results as well as better structural results in terms of tendon integrity.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lorbach O, Haupert A, Berger C, et al. Clinical and Structural Results of Rotator Cuff Repair Compared With Rotator Cuff Debridement in Arthroscopic Treatment of Calcifying Tendinitis of the Shoulder. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 34528841. doi:10.1177/03635465211037690

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。