文献速递运动医学关节外科

关节镜与微创小切口肩袖修复:随机试验与荟萃分析

Arthroscopic Versus Mini-open Rotator Cuff Repair: A Randomized Trial and Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Sports Med · 2021-09-15

这项随机对照试验在9个中心23名外科医生中比较全关节镜(AA)与微创小切口(MO)肩袖修复,274例完成随访。两组WORC评分从术前40改善至2年时AA组89、MO组93,校正均差3.4(95%CI -0.4至7.2),各时间点无统计学显著差异;荟萃分析汇总既往试验亦无显著差异。

要点

  • AA与MO肩袖修复在2年WORC评分上无统计学显著差异。
  • 荟萃分析汇总所有研究,主要结局标准化均差-0.06(95%CI -0.34至0.22)。

核心结论

  • AA与MO肩袖修复均带来大幅临床获益,且不良事件少,有强证据表明两者临床改善等效。

研究设计与样本

  • 随机对照试验,证据等级1级,在9个中心由23名外科医生实施,274例完成随访(MO组138例,AA组136例)。
  • 术前1个月及术后2周、6周、3、6、12、18、24个月收集WORC、ASES、SPADI疼痛亚量表、SF-12、用药与不良事件,并测量活动度与力量。
  • 盲法放射科医生在基线与1年时通过MRI评估肩袖完整性;采用意向性分析协方差,协变量为术前WORC评分、年龄和撕裂大小。
  • 荟萃分析汇总MO与AA修复主要结局的既往试验。

主要发现

  • WORC评分从术前40改善至2年时AA组89、MO组93,校正均差3.4(95%CI -0.4至7.2)。
  • 两组活动度与力量随时间恢复相似;MRI显示肌肉相对脂肪改善极小(AA n=3;MO n=2),多数 worsening(AA n=25;MO n=24)或保持不变(AA n=70;MO n=70)。
  • 术后阿片类药物使用显著减少(从21%降至5%)。
  • 荟萃分析显示所有汇总研究中主要结局的标准化均差为-0.06(95%CI -0.34至0.22),无显著差异。

临床怎么用

  • 对于非手术治疗失败的完全性肩袖撕裂患者,AA与MO修复均可作为等效的临床选择。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Patients with complete rotator cuff tears who fail a course of nonoperative therapy can benefit from surgical repair. PURPOSE: This randomized trial compared mini-open (MO) versus all-arthroscopic (AA) rotator cuff repair. STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial; Level of evidence, 1. METHODS: Patients with rotator cuff tears were randomized to undergo MO or AA repair at 9 centers by 23 surgeons. The primary outcome (Western Ontario Rotator Cuff Index [WORC]) and secondary outcomes (American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons [ASES] score, Shoulder Pain and Disability Index [SPADI] pain subscale, 12-Item Short Form Health Survey [SF-12], reported medication use, adverse events), as well as measurements of range of motion and strength, were collected at 1 month before surgery; at 2 and 6 weeks postoperatively; and at 3, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months postoperatively. A blinded radiologist evaluated rotator cuff integrity on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at baseline and 1 year. Intention-to-treat analysis of covariance with the preoperative WORC score, age, and tear size as covariates assessed continuous outcomes. Sex differences were assessed. A meta-analysis synthesized the primary outcome between MO and AA repair with previous trials. RESULTS: From 954 patients screened, 411 were ineligible (276 because of recovery with physical therapy), 449 were screened at surgery (175 ineligible), and 274 completed follow-up (138 MO and 136 AA). The AA and MO groups were similar before surgery. WORC scores improved from 40 preoperatively to 89 (AA) and 93 (MO) at 2 years, for an adjusted mean difference of 3.4 (95% CI, -0.4 to 7.2). There were no statistically significant differences between the AA and MO groups at any time point. All secondary patient-reported outcomes were not significantly different between the MO and AA groups, except the 2-year SPADI pain score (8 vs 12, respectively; P = .02). A similar recovery in range of motion and strength occurred in both groups over time. MRI indicated minimal improvement in muscle relative to fat (AA: n = 3; MO: n = 2), with most worsening (AA: n = 25; MO: n = 24) or remaining unchanged (AA: n = 70; MO: n = 70). Opioid use was significantly reduced after surgery (from 21% to 5%). The meta-analysis indicated no significant standardized mean difference between groups in the primary outcome across all pooled studies (standardized mean difference, -0.06 [95% CI, -0.34 to 0.22]). CONCLUSION: Both AA and MO rotator cuff repair provide large clinical benefits, with few adverse events. There is strong evidence of equivalent clinical improvements. TRIAL REGISTRATION: NCT00128076.

来源:Am J Sports Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. MacDermid JC, Bryant D, Holtby R, et al. Arthroscopic Versus Mini-open Rotator Cuff Repair: A Randomized Trial and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 34524031. doi:10.1177/03635465211038233

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。