优化腕管松解手术的成本与结局:社会与医疗系统视角的成本效果分析
该成本效果分析比较了三种腕管松解策略:手术室开放、操作室开放及手术室内镜。结果显示操作室开放手术在社会与医疗系统视角下均最具成本效果,概率敏感性分析中分别有55%和61%的迭代中为优势策略。
要点
- 操作室开放腕管松解较手术室开放和内镜手术更具成本效果。
- 操作室开放手术在社会视角下每例平均总成本29738美元,QALY为0.88。
- 内镜手术成本更高且QALY略低,在多数敏感性分析中不具优势。
核心结论
- 与手术室开放和手术室内镜相比,操作室开放腕管松解在提供良好结局的同时最小化医疗系统和社会成本。
研究设计与样本
- 采用决策分析模型比较三种策略的成本与健康效用,效用和概率参数来自文献,医疗成本基于Medicare门诊手术支付数据,间接成本与恢复和并发症导致的工作日损失相关。
主要发现
- 基础分析中,操作室开放手术在社会视角下每例平均总成本为29738±4098美元,QALY为0.88±0.08;手术室开放为30002±4098美元和0.88±0.08;内镜手术为41311±4833美元和0.87±0.08。
- 操作室开放手术在医疗系统视角下也最具成本效果。
- 概率敏感性分析中,操作室开放手术在社会和医疗系统视角下分别有55%和61%的迭代中为优势策略(更高QALY且更低成本)。
关键数值与推荐
- 支付意愿阈值设为100000美元/QALY。
- 单因素敏感性分析显示,当内镜手术成本为0、翻修率为0%、开放与内镜重返工作率相等或内镜术后工作日损失为0时,操作室开放和手术室开放仍比内镜更具成本效果。
- 当正中神经损伤率分别增至三倍(社会视角)和两倍(医疗系统视角),或操作室直接手术成本超过手术室时,手术室开放比操作室开放更具成本效果。
临床怎么用
- 在资源允许的情况下,优先选择操作室开放腕管松解以降低医疗系统和社会成本。
- 内镜手术仅在特定条件(如成本极低、翻修率极低或工作日损失极少)下可能具有成本效果。
- 决策时应考虑正中神经损伤率和操作室直接成本对成本效果的影响。
局限性
- 研究基于决策分析模型,参数来自文献和Medicare支付数据,可能不完全适用于其他医疗体系或人群。
- 未报告长期并发症和翻修率的详细数据,可能影响模型外推。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: It is unclear which carpal tunnel release (CTR) strategy (i.e., which combination of surgical technique and setting) is most cost-effective. A cost-effectiveness analysis was performed to compare (1) open CTR in the procedure room (OCTR/PR), (2) OCTR in the operating room (OCTR/OR), and (3) endoscopic CTR in the operating room (ECTR/OR). METHODS: A decision analytic model was used to compare costs and health utilities between treatment strategies. Utility and probability parameters were identified from the literature. Medical costs were estimated with Medicare ambulatory surgical payment data. Indirect costs were related to days out of work due to surgical recovery and complications. The effectiveness outcome was quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). Probabilistic sensitivity analyses and one-way sensitivity analyses were performed. Cost-effectiveness was assessed from the societal and health-care system perspectives with use of a willingness-to-pay threshold of $100,000/QALY. RESULTS: In the base-case analysis, OCTR/PR was more cost-effective than OCTR/OR and ECTR/OR from the societal perspective. The mean total costs and QALYs per patient were $29,738 ± $4,098 and 0.88 ± 0.08 for OCTR/PR, $30,002 ± $4,098 and 0.88 ± 0.08 for OCTR/OR, and $41,311 ± $4,833 and 0.87 ± 0.08 for ECTR/OR. OCTR/PR was also the most cost-effective strategy from the health-care system perspective. These findings were robust in the probabilistic sensitivity analyses: OCTR/PR was the dominant strategy (greater QALYs at a lower cost) in 55% and 61% of iterations from societal and health-care system perspectives, respectively. One-way sensitivity analysis demonstrated that OCTR/PR and OCTR/OR remained more cost-effective than ECTR/OR from a societal perspective under the following conditions: $0 surgical cost of ECTR, 0% revision rate following ECTR, equalization of the return-to-work rate between OCTR and ECTR, or 0 days out of work following ECTR. OCTR/OR became more cost-effective than OCTR/PR with the median nerve injury rate tripling and doubling from societal and health-care system perspectives, respectively, or if surgical direct costs in the PR exceeded those in the OR. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with OCTR/OR and ECTR/OR, OCTR/PR minimizes costs to the health-care system and society while providing favorable outcomes. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Economic and Decision Analysis Level III . See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Rogers MJ, Stephens AR, Yoo M, et al. Optimizing Costs and Outcomes for Carpal Tunnel Release Surgery: A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis from Societal and Health-Care System Perspectives. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2021. PMID: 34428186. doi:10.2106/JBJS.20.02126
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。