临界肩角与退变性肩袖撕裂关联的争议:一项荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入14项病例对照和横断面研究(1154例病例、1271例对照),评估临界肩角(CSA)测量可靠性和其与肩袖撕裂(RCT)的关联。CSA测量信度优秀,病例组CSA较对照组大3.3°(95%CI 2.3°-4.4°),但异质性高(I2=93%),95%预测区间(-0.4°至7.1°)包含无差异。
要点
- CSA测量信度优秀,组内和组间可靠性范围分别为0.91-0.99和0.87-0.99。
- 病例组CSA较对照组平均大3.3°,但异质性高(I2=93%),预测区间包含无差异。
- 全层撕裂、未规定放射投照标准、小样本及高偏倚风险研究中间差异更大。
核心结论
- CSA可可靠测量,但病例与对照间的CSA差异从很大到几乎无差异不等,当前证据难以确定CSA与RCT关联的强度和确切性质。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,证据等级4级;检索MEDLINE、EMBASE和CINAHL数据库至2019年6月30日,纳入报告CSA与RCT关联的病例对照和横断面研究。
主要发现
- 共纳入14项研究,包括1154例病例和1271例对照;79%(11/14)的研究评估了CSA测量信度,组内可靠性范围0.91-0.99,组间可靠性范围0.87-0.99。
- 与对照组相比,RCT病例的CSA测量值更大(3.3°,95%CI 2.3°-4.4°),但异质性高(I2=93%),95%预测区间(-0.4°至7.1°)包含无差异。
- 荟萃回归分析显示若干方法学因素与异质性显著相关:仅纳入全层撕裂、未使用特定放射投照标准、样本量较小及偏倚风险较高的研究中间CSA差异趋于更大。
临床怎么用
- 临床解读CSA与肩袖撕裂关联时需考虑研究间高异质性,不能仅凭CSA单一指标判定风险。
- 测量CSA时应规范放射投照视角,并注意全层撕裂与部分撕裂的差异可能影响关联强度。
局限性
- 纳入研究间存在高度异质性(I2=93%),且受方法学因素(如撕裂类型、投照标准、样本量和偏倚风险)显著影响。
- 证据等级为4级,当前证据难以确定CSA与RCT关联的强度和确切性质。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The role of the critical shoulder angle (CSA) as a risk factor for rotator cuff tear (RCT) remains controversial. Studies on the association between the CSA and RCT show considerable differences in design, and this could be responsible for the variation in study results. PURPOSE: To (1) describe the reliability of CSA measurement and (2) evaluate the results of the studies reporting the association between the CSA and RCT using meta-analytical techniques to explore potential sources of variation of study results. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: MEDLINE, EMBASE, and CINAHL electronic databases were searched through June 30, 2019. Case-control and cross-sectional studies reporting the association of the CSA and RCT were selected. The weighted mean difference in the CSA was estimated using a random-effects model. Prediction interval was computed to better express uncertainties in the effect estimate. Metaregression and subgroup analyses were performed to explore potential sources of heterogeneity. RESULTS: A total of 14 studies, including 1154 cases and 1271 controls, were identified. Of these studies, 79% (11/14) assessed the reliability of the CSA measurement, demonstrating an excellent intraobserver (range, 0.91-0.99) and interobserver (range, 0.87-0.99) reliability. Compared with controls, cases with RCT showed larger measurements of the CSA (3.3° [95% CI, 2.3°- 4.4°]). However, there was a high heterogeneity (I2 = 93%), and the 95% prediction interval (-0.4° to 7.1°) included no difference in the CSA. Results of the metaregression analysis showed a significant association of several methodological aspects with the heterogeneity. The difference in the CSA tended to be larger when only full-thickness tears were included, when no specific defined criterion for assessing radiographic viewing perspective was used, in studies with smaller sample sizes, and in studies at higher risk of bias. CONCLUSION: While the CSA can be reliably measured, the difference in the CSA between cases and controls varied from very large to modest or almost no difference. Several determinants of heterogeneity were determined. Owing to this heterogeneity, it is difficult to gain an insight into the strength and exact nature of the association between the CSA and RCT with the current evidence.
引用
- Rojas Lievano J, Bautista M, Woodcock S, et al. Controversy on the Association of the Critical Shoulder Angle and the Development of Degenerative Rotator Cuff Tears: Is There a True Association? A Meta-analytical Approach. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 34432551. doi:10.1177/03635465211027305
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。