全踝关节置换活动平台与固定平台假体三年再手术与翻修率比较
本研究基于302例接受全踝关节置换患者,比较同一厂商相似设计的活动平台(Salto)与固定平台(Salto Talaris)假体3年内再手术与翻修率;活动平台全因再手术风险比1.42(95%CI 0.67-3.00,p=0.36),组件翻修风险比3.31(95%CI 0.93-11.79,p=0.06),金属组件翻修风险比2.78(95%CI 0.58-13.33,p=0.20),活动平台再手术31例 vs 固定平台14例(p=0.07),活动平台再手术范围更广泛;结论支持固定平台设计短期失败率更低。
要点
- 3年内活动平台全因再手术风险比为1.42,无统计学差异。
- 组件翻修风险比3.31,活动平台翻修率约为固定平台3倍。
- 活动平台再手术31例,固定平台14例,活动平台手术范围更广。
核心结论
- 本研究支持固定平台设计在短期失败方面更具优势。
- 活动平台假体在TAA术后3年翻修率约为固定平台的3倍。
- 活动平台再手术(含后续手术)更常见且原因和类型更广泛。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心队列研究,纳入2004年1月至2018年3月3个中心2名外科医生连续302例TAA患者。
- 活动平台组171例接受Salto假体,固定平台组131例接受Salto Talaris假体。
- 主要结局为3年内首次全因再手术、任何金属组件翻修及任何组件(含聚乙烯衬垫)翻修的时间。
主要发现
- 全因再手术调整风险比1.42(95%CI 0.67-3.00,p=0.36)。
- 组件翻修调整风险比3.31(95%CI 0.93-11.79,p=0.06)。
- 金属组件翻修调整风险比2.78(95%CI 0.58-13.33,p=0.20)。
- 活动平台组再手术31例,固定平台组14例(p=0.07)。
- 活动平台组再手术手术范围更广泛。
关键数值与推荐
- 全因再手术调整风险比1.42(95%CI 0.67-3.00,p=0.36)。
- 组件翻修调整风险比3.31(95%CI 0.93-11.79,p=0.06)。
- 金属组件翻修调整风险比2.78(95%CI 0.58-13.33,p=0.20)。
- 再手术例数活动平台31例 vs 固定平台14例(p=0.07)。
临床怎么用
- 在選択全踝关节置换假体时,固定平台设计可能降低短期翻修风险。
- 活动平台假体需关注再手术范围更广泛的可能性。
- 与患者沟通时,应说明活动平台翻修率约为固定平台3倍但组间差异未达统计学显著。
局限性
- 研究为非随机队列,假体选择按时间分期(2013年前活动平台,2012年后固定平台),存在时间偏倚。
- 样本量302例,组件翻修事件数少,置信区间宽。
- 仅比较同一厂商两种假体,随访限于3年,不能外推至其他设计或长期结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Currently, the implants utilized in total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) are divided between mobile-bearing 3-component and fixed-bearing 2-component designs. The literature evaluating the influence of this mobility difference on implant survival is sparse. The purpose of the present study was therefore to compare the short-term survival of 2 implants of similar design from the same manufacturer, surgically implanted by the same surgeons, in fixed-bearing or mobile-bearing versions. METHODS: All patients were enrolled who underwent TAA with either the mobile-bearing Salto (Tornier and Integra) or the fixed-bearing Salto Talaris (Integra) in 3 centers by 2 surgeons between January 2004 and March 2018. All patients who underwent TAA from January 2004 to April 2013 received the Salto implant, and all patients who underwent TAA after November 2012 received the Salto Talaris implant. The primary outcome was time, within 3 years, to first all-cause reoperation, revision of any metal component, and revision of any component, including the polyethylene insert. Secondary outcomes included the frequency, cause, and type of reoperation. RESULTS: A total of 302 consecutive patients were included, of whom 171 received the mobile-bearing and 131 received the fixed-bearing implant. The adjusted hazard ratio for all-cause reoperation was 1.42 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.67 to 3.00; p = 0.36); for component revision, 3.31 (95% CI, 0.93 to 11.79; p = 0.06); and for metal component revision, 2.78 (95% CI, 0.58 to 13.33; p = 0.20). A total of 31 reoperations were performed in the mobile-bearing group compared with 14 in the fixed-bearing group (p = 0.07). More extensive reoperation procedures were performed in the mobile-bearing group. CONCLUSIONS: With the largest comparison of 2 implants of similar design from the same manufacturer, the present study supports the use of a fixed-bearing design in terms of short-term failure. We found a 3-times higher rate of revision among mobile-bearing implants compared with fixed-bearing implants at 3 years after TAA. Reoperations, including first and subsequent procedures, tended to be less common and the causes and types of reoperations less extensive among fixed-bearing implants. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic Level III. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Assal M, Kutaish H, Acker A, et al. Three-Year Rates of Reoperation and Revision Following Mobile Versus Fixed-Bearing Total Ankle Arthroplasty: A Cohort of 302 Patients with 2 Implants of Similar Design. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2021. PMID: 34424866. doi:10.2106/JBJS.20.02172
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。