统一分类系统对骨水泥锥形滑动柄假体周围骨折的信度与效度
本研究评估统一分类系统(UCS)对骨水泥锥形滑动(PTS)柄术后假体周围股骨骨折(PFF)的信度与效度,由6名观察者对71例患者影像进行两次分类。观察者间一致性κ=0.442(中等),观察者内κ=0.672(显著),但B型骨折κ值低至0.095-0.360;与术中茎干稳定性比较的效度κ=0.300(一般)。结论认为UCS对PTS柄PFF分类不理想,信效度低于其他柄型。
要点
- UCS对PTS柄PFF的观察者间信度中等(κ=0.442),B型骨折一致性差(κ=0.095-0.360)。
- UCS与术中茎干稳定性判断的效度仅为一般(κ=0.300),影像学松动定义不清。
- 建议对PTS柄PFF行正式术中茎干稳定性测试,不应仅依赖UCS分类。
核心结论
- UCS对骨水泥PTS柄PFF的分类信度和效度不满意,低于既往其他柄型的报告。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析两中心2012年2月25日至2020年5月19日连续收治的71例PFF患者影像,由6名观察者(3名髋关节顾问医师和3名培训医师)分两次独立分类,间隔平均22.7天(16-29天)。
主要发现
- 观察者间百分比一致率为58.5%,总体κ=0.442(中等);B型骨折κ值最低(0.095-0.360)。
- 观察者内信度平均κ=0.672(范围0.447-0.867),为显著一致。
- 效度评估基于50例手术治疗的UCS B型PFF,与术中茎干稳定性记录比较,百分比一致率65.7%,平均κ=0.300(范围0.160-0.4400),仅为一般一致。
关键数值与推荐
- 信度解释采用Landis和Koch标准:κ=0.442为中等一致,κ=0.672为显著一致,κ=0.300为一般一致。
临床怎么用
- 对PTS柄PFF,UCS分类信效度有限,影像学茎干松动判断不可靠,应行正式术中茎干稳定性测试。
局限性
- 效度分析仅纳入手术治疗的UCS B型PFF(n=50),未涵盖所有类型;样本量有限且为回顾性设计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: This aim of this study was to assess the reliability and validity of the Unified Classification System (UCS) for postoperative periprosthetic femoral fractures (PFFs) around cemented polished taper-slip (PTS) stems. METHODS: Radiographs of 71 patients with a PFF admitted consecutively at two centres between 25 February 2012 and 19 May 2020 were collated by an independent investigator. Six observers (three hip consultants and three trainees) were familiarized with the UCS. Each PFF was classified on two separate occasions, with a mean time between assessments of 22.7 days (16 to 29). Interobserver reliability for more than two observers was assessed using percentage agreement and Fleiss' kappa statistic. Intraobserver reliability between two observers was calculated with Cohen kappa statistic. Validity was tested on surgically managed UCS type B PFFs where stem stability was documented in operation notes (n = 50). Validity was assessed using percentage agreement and Cohen kappa statistic between radiological assessment and intraoperative findings. Kappa statistics were interpreted using Landis and Koch criteria. All six observers were blinded to operation notes and postoperative radiographs. RESULTS: Interobserver reliability percentage agreement was 58.5% and the overall kappa value was 0.442 (moderate agreement). Lowest kappa values were seen for type B fractures (0.095 to 0.360). The mean intraobserver reliability kappa value was 0.672 (0.447 to 0.867), indicating substantial agreement. Validity percentage agreement was 65.7% and the mean kappa value was 0.300 (0.160 to 0.4400) indicating only fair agreement. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that the UCS is unsatisfactory for the classification of PFFs around PTS stems, and that it has considerably lower reliability and validity than previously described for other stem types. Radiological PTS stem loosening in the presence of PFF is poorly defined and formal intraoperative testing of stem stability is recommended. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(8):1339-1344.
引用
- Jain S, Mohrir G, Townsend O, et al. Reliability and validity of the Unified Classification System for postoperative periprosthetic femoral fractures around cemented polished taper-slip stems. Bone Joint J. 2021. PMID: 34334039. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.103B8.BJJ-2021-0021.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。