外科医生经验与亚专科对AO脊柱骶骨分类系统可靠性的影响
这项横断面调查研究评估了172名不同亚专科和经验年限的外科医生对26例骶骨骨折CT影像的两次分类评估。结果显示AO脊柱骶骨分类系统在整体形态和亚型分类上具有优良的观察者内和观察者间信度,各经验组和亚专科组准确率均较高,但分类正确率随经验年限显著差异。
要点
- AO脊柱骶骨分类系统在各亚专科和经验水平医生中均显示优良的信度与准确率。
- 骨折形态分类正确率超过90%,亚型分类正确率超过80%。
- 分类正确率随经验年限有显著差异,但不受亚专科影响。
核心结论
- AO脊柱骶骨分类系统在不同亚专科和经验水平的外科医生中具有普遍适用性,信度、可重复性和准确率均可接受。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查研究,纳入26例高分辨率CT影像,由172名代表不同亚专科(普通骨科、神经外科、骨科脊柱、骨科创伤)和经验年限(<5年、5-10年、11-20年、>20年)的研究者进行两次独立评估。
主要发现
- 总体观察者内信度:形态分类k=0.87,亚型分类k=0.77。
- 所有四个经验组观察者间信度:整体形态分类k=0.842/0.850(评估1/评估2),整体亚型分类k=0.719/0.751。
- 普通骨科、神经外科和骨科脊柱外科医生在整体形态分类上显示优良的观察者间信度,在整体亚型分类上显示实质性观察者间信度。
- 各经验类别和亚专科医生根据金标准正确分类骨折形态超过90%病例,骨折亚型超过80%病例。
- 骨折形态(评估1:P=0.024,评估2:P=0.006)和亚型(P2<0.001)的正确整体分类按经验年限有显著差异,但按亚专科无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 观察者内信度:形态k=0.87,亚型k=0.77。
- 观察者间信度:整体形态k=0.842/0.850,整体亚型k=0.719/0.751。
- 正确分类率:形态>90%,亚型>80%。
- 经验年限对正确分类的影响:形态P=0.024(评估1)、P=0.006(评估2),亚型P2<0.001。
临床怎么用
- AO脊柱骶骨分类系统可用于不同亚专科和经验水平的外科医生进行骶骨骨折分类,具有可接受的信度和准确率。
- 经验年限可能影响分类正确率,但亚专科不影响,提示该系统具有普遍适用性。
局限性
- 研究为横断面调查,证据等级为4级。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY DESIGN: Cross-sectional survey. OBJECTIVE: To determine the influence of surgeons' level of experience and subspeciality training on the reliability, reproducibility, and accuracy of sacral fracture classification using the Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Osteosynthesefragen Spine Sacral Classification System. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: A surgeons' level of experience or subspecialty may have a significant effect on the reliability and accuracy of sacral classification given various levels of comfort with imaging assessment required for accurate diagnosis and classification. METHODS: High-resolution computerized tomography (CT) images from 26 cases were assessed on two separate occasions by 172 investigators representing a diverse array of surgical subspecialities (general orthopedics, neurosurgery, orthopedic spine, orthopedic trauma) and experience (<5, 5-10, 11-20, >20 yrs). Reliability and reproducibility were calculated with Cohen kappa coefficient (k) and gold standard classification agreement was determined for each fracture morphology and subtype and stratified by experience and subspeciality. RESULTS: Respondents achieved an overall k = 0.87 for morphology and k = 0.77 for subtype classification, representing excellent and substantial intraobserver reproducibility, respectively. Respondents from all four practice experience groups demonstrated excellent interobserver reliability when classifying overall morphology (k = 0.842/0.850, Assessment 1/Assessment 2) and substantial interobserver reliability in overall subtype (k = 0.719/0.751) in both assessments. General orthopedists, neurosurgeons, and orthopedic spine surgeons exhibited excellent interobserver reliability in overall morphology classification and substantial interobserver reliability in overall subtype classification. Surgeons in each experience category and subspecialty correctly classified fracture morphology in over 90% of cases and fracture subtype in over 80% of cases according to the gold standard. Correct overall classification of fracture morphology (Assessment 1: P = 0.024, Assessment 2: P = 0.006) and subtype (P2 < 0.001) differed significantly by years of experience but not by subspecialty. CONCLUSION: Overall, the Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Osteosynthesefragen spine sacral classification system appears to be universally applicable among surgeons of various subspecialties and levels of experience with acceptable reliability, reproducibility, and accuracy.Level of Evidence: 4.
引用
- Karamian BA, Schroeder GD, Levy HA, et al. The Influence of Surgeon Experience and Subspeciality on the Reliability of the AO Spine Sacral Classification System. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2021. PMID: 34392274. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000004199
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。