骨质量差、多节段手术及窄高融合器与LLIF术中终板损伤和远期融合器下沉相关:系统综述
结果显示,骨密度T值≤-1.0、年龄>65岁和女性与两类下沉高风险相关;融合器宽度≥22 mm可避免远期下沉,高度≤11 mm可避免术中终板损伤;多节段LLIF应谨慎。
要点
- 骨密度T值≤-1.0、年龄>65岁和女性是LLIF术后融合器下沉的高危因素。
- 融合器宽度≥22 mm有助于避免远期下沉,高度≤11 mm可减少术中终板损伤。
- 多节段LLIF因下沉风险高,可考虑先行后路或椎间孔入路直接减压。
核心结论
- 骨质量差、年龄>65岁和女性患者应被告知融合器下沉风险高。
- 术中应避免使用窄融合器以减少远期下沉,同时谨慎使用高融合器以避免术中终板损伤。
- 多节段LLIF因间接减压效果难以维持,可考虑先行直接减压。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索Medline、Embase、Cochrane Library、PubMed和Web of Science从1997年至2020年的文献。
- 采用GRADE方法评估证据质量,纳入研究证据质量为中至极低。
主要发现
- 双能X线吸收法T值≤-1.0、年龄>65岁和女性与两类融合器下沉(术中终板损伤和远期下沉)高风险相关。
- 融合器宽度≥22 mm有助于避免远期融合器下沉,融合器高度≤11 mm被部分研究推荐用于避免术中终板损伤。
- 多节段LLIF因融合器下沉风险高,维持间接减压效果困难。
- 无骨质疏松或肥胖的患者,单独LLIF可能足够;多危险因素患者应考虑辅助内固定以维持椎间盘高度和防止下沉进展。
- 骨移植、融合器材料、终板条件和辅助内固定对融合器下沉的影响尚不明确或有争议。
关键数值与推荐
- 骨密度T值≤-1.0、年龄>65岁和女性被视为两类融合器下沉的高风险因素。
- 融合器宽度≥22 mm有助于避免远期融合器下沉。
- 融合器高度≤11 mm被部分研究推荐以避免术中终板损伤。
- 多节段LLIF应格外谨慎,因间接减压效果可能难以维持。
- 无骨质疏松或肥胖的患者,单独LLIF可能足够;多危险因素患者应考虑辅助内固定。
临床怎么用
- 术前应评估骨密度、年龄和性别,对高危患者进行下沉风险告知。
- 选择融合器时避免过窄(宽度<22 mm),谨慎使用高度>11 mm的融合器。
- 多节段LLIF可考虑先行后路或椎间孔入路直接减压。
- 对多危险因素患者考虑辅助内固定以维持椎间盘高度和防止下沉进展。
局限性
- 纳入研究证据质量为中至极低。
- 融合器材料、辅助内固定、骨移植和终板条件对下沉的影响尚不明确或有争议。
- 需要更大样本的前瞻性随机研究进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A major complication of lateral lumbar interbody fusion (LLIF) is cage subsidence, which may lead to clinical problems, including loss of disc height correction, altered spinal alignment, recurrent pain, and vertebral body fracture. A thorough review of the current knowledge about the risk factors for the two types of cage subsidence after LLIF-intraoperative endplate injury and late-onset cage subsidence-could bring attention to well-established risk factors for clinical consideration while identifying any incompletely characterized factors that require further research to clarify. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We performed a systematic review to answer the following questions: (1) Are bone quality and surrogates for bone quality, such as patient age and sex, associated with an increased likelihood of cage subsidence? (2) Are implant-related factors associated with an increased likelihood of cage subsidence? METHODS: Two independent reviewers comprehensively searched Medline, Embase, Cochrane Library, PubMed, and Web of Science from 1997 to 2020 to identify all potential risk factors for cage subsidence after LLIF. Discrepancies were settled through discussion during full-text screening. Search terms included "lateral" AND "interbody fusion" AND "subsidence" OR "settling" OR "endplate injury" OR "endplate violation" WITHOUT "cervical" OR "transforaminal" OR "biomechanical." Eligible studies were retrospective or prospective comparative studies, randomized controlled trials, and case series with sample sizes of 10 patients or more reporting risk factors for cage subsidence or endplate injury after LLIF. Studies that involved cervical interbody fusions and biomechanical and cadaveric experiments were excluded. The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) approach was used to assess the studies' quality of evidence. The initial database review found 400 articles. Thirty-four articles with moderate- to very-low-quality evidence met the inclusion criteria for analysis. A total of 3233 patients (58% [1860] of whom were female) were included in this review. Two types of cage subsidence were reviewed: late-onset cage subsidence, which occurs gradually postoperatively, and intraoperative endplate injury, which is derived from iatrogenic endplate violation during endplate preparation or cage insertion. Among 20 studies with moderate quality of evidence according to the GRADE criteria, eight studies reported risk factors for cage subsidence related to bone mineral density and its surrogates and 12 studies focused on risk factors regarding implant factors, including cage dimension, cage material, construct length, and supplementary instrumentation. RESULTS: Patients with a dual x-ray absorptiometry T-score of -1.0 or less, age older than 65 years, and female sex were considered to have a high risk of both types of cage subsidence. Regarding cage size, cage width ≥ 22 mm helped to avoid late-onset cage subsidence, and cage height ≤ 11 mm was recommended by some studies to avoid intraoperative endplate injuries. Studies recommended that multilevel LLIF should be conducted with extra caution because of a high risk of losing the effect of indirect decompression. Studies found that standalone LLIF might be sufficient for patients without osteoporosis or obesity, and supplementary instrumentation should be considered to maintain the postoperative disc height and prevent subsidence progression in patients with multiple risk factors. The effect of the bone graft, cage material, endplate condition, and supplementary instrumentation on cage subsidence remained vague or controversial. CONCLUSION: Patients with poor bone density, patients who are older than 65 years, and female patients should be counseled about their high risk of developing cage subsidence. Surgeons should avoid narrow cages when performing LLIF to minimize the risk of late-onset cage subsidence, while being cautious of an aggressive attempt to restore disc height with a tall cage as it may lead to intraoperative endplate injury. For multilevel constructs, direct decompression approaches, such as posterior and transforaminal LIF, should be considered before LLIF, since the effect of indirect decompression may be difficult to maintain in multilevel LLIF because of high risks of cage subsidence. The effect of the cage material and supplementary instrumentation require stronger evidence from prospectively designed studies with larger sample size that randomly assign patients to polyetheretherketone (PEEK) or titanium cages and different fixation types. Future research on intraoperative endplate injuries should focus on the specific timing of when endplate violation occurs with the help of intraoperative imaging so that attempts can be made to minimize its occurrence. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.
引用
- Wu H, Shan Z, Zhao F, et al. Poor Bone Quality, Multilevel Surgery, and Narrow and Tall Cages Are Associated with Intraoperative Endplate Injuries and Late-onset Cage Subsidence in Lateral Lumbar Interbody Fusion: A Systematic Review. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2022. PMID: 34324459. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001915
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。