关节镜下桶柄状半月板撕裂修复失败率的系统综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入38篇文献,评估关节镜下桶柄状半月板撕裂(BHMT)修复的失败率,并比较其与简单半月板撕裂的失败风险。结果显示BHMT修复的合并失败率为14.8%(95%CI 11.3%-18.3%),显著高于简单撕裂(RR=1.50,95%CI 1.05-2.15,P=.03)。内侧BHMT和孤立修复是失败的主要预测因素。
要点
- BHMT修复合并失败率为14.8%,高于简单半月板撕裂。
- 内侧BHMT修复失败风险显著高于外侧(RR=1.94,P=.003)。
- 孤立修复失败风险显著高于合并前交叉韧带重建(RR=1.77,P=.009)。
核心结论
- 关节镜下BHMT修复的合并失败率为14.8%(95%CI 11.3%-18.3%)。
- 内侧撕裂和孤立修复是BHMT修复失败的主要预测因素。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,证据等级4级。
- 两位独立研究者检索PubMed、Scopus、Cochrane Library和EMBASE,最终纳入38篇文章。
- 采用随机效应比例荟萃分析(按研究样本量加权),并构建森林图比较BHMT与简单撕裂等亚组。
- 通过荟萃回归分析评估年龄、性别、缝合技术、受伤至手术时间、平均缝合针数和随访时间对失败率的影响。
主要发现
- BHMT修复的合并失败率为14.8%(95%CI 11.3%-18.3%;I2=77.2%)。
- 17项研究提供BHMT修复失败率(46/311)和简单撕裂修复失败率(54/546),BHMT修复失败率显著更高(RR=1.50;95%CI 1.05-2.15;I2=0%;P=.03)。
- 内侧BHMT修复失败风险显著高于外侧(RR=1.94;95%CI 1.25-3.01;I2=0%;P=.003)。
- 孤立修复失败风险显著高于合并前交叉韧带重建(RR=1.77;95%CI 1.15-2.72;I2=0%;P=.009)。
- 红-红区与红-白区撕裂的失败率无统计学显著差异;荟萃回归中仅平均缝合针数对失败率有统计学显著影响。
临床怎么用
- 临床决策时可参考BHMT修复失败率约14.8%,尤其对内翻及孤立修复病例应加强术后评估与随访。
- 内侧BHMT和孤立修复患者失败风险更高,可考虑更个体化的康复或手术策略。
局限性
- 证据等级为4级,纳入研究以回顾性为主,异质性较高(I2=77.2%)。
- 部分亚组分析纳入研究数量有限,结论需谨慎解读。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Meniscal repair has become the treatment of choice for meniscal tears, especially in the subset of bucket-handle meniscal tears (BHMTs). However, a comprehensive estimate of the corresponding failure rate is not available, thus maintaining doubts about the healing potential of these tears. Furthermore, a wide range of factors to predict high failure rates have been reported but with conflicting evidence. PURPOSE: To determine the failure rate after arthroscopic repair of BHMTs as reported in the literature, compare this with the failure rate of simple meniscal tears extracted from the same studies, and analyze the influence of factors previously reported to be predictive of meniscal repair failure. STUDY DESIGN: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: A systematic search was conducted by 2 independent reviewers using principal bibliographic databases (PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and EMBASE). After a stepwise exclusion process, 38 articles met the inclusion criteria. Failure rate data were analyzed with a random-effects proportional meta-analysis (weighted for individual study size), and forest plots were constructed to determine any statistically significant differences between BHMTs versus simple tears (longitudinal, radial, or horizontal), medial versus lateral BHMTs, isolated procedures versus repairs with concomitant anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, and tears in red-red versus red-white zones. Moreover, a meta-regression analysis was conducted to evaluate the effect of patient age and sex, suture technique (in-out or all-inside), time from injury to surgery, mean number of stitches, and length of follow-up on failure rates. RESULTS: The pooled failure rate was 14.8% (95% CI, 11.3%-18.3%; I2 = 77.2%). A total of 17 studies provided failure rates of both BHMT repairs (46/311 repairs) and simple tear repairs (54/546 repairs), demonstrating a significantly higher failure rate for BHMT repairs (risk ratio [RR] = 1.50; 95% CI, 1.05-2.15; I2 = 0%; P = .03). Medial BHMT repairs (RR = 1.94; 95% CI, 1.25-3.01; I2 = 0%; P = .003) and isolated repairs (RR = 1.77; 95% CI, 1.15-2.72; I2 = 0%; P = .009) had statistically higher risk of failure, but no statistically significant difference was found between tears in red-red versus red-white zones. Among the other factors evaluated with meta-regression, only the mean number of stitches showed a statistically significant effect on failure rates. CONCLUSION: Based on the currently available literature, this systematic review provides a reasonably comprehensive analysis of failure rate after arthroscopic BHMT repair; failure is estimated to occur in 14.8% of cases. Medial tears and isolated repairs were the 2 major predictors of failure.
引用
- Costa GG, Grassi A, Zocco G, et al. What Is the Failure Rate After Arthroscopic Repair of Bucket-Handle Meniscal Tears? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 34161741. doi:10.1177/03635465211015425
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。