直接前入路与后入路全髋关节置换术:功能结局与费用的Meta分析
该Meta分析比较直接前入路(DAA)与后入路(PA)在全髋关节置换术中的功能结局和围手术期费用。DAA组手术时间更长、失血量更多,但住院时间平均缩短13.4小时,术后3周和6周Harris髋关节评分(HHS)更优;然而6-8周及之后的功能评分无显著差异。DAA组在手术室时间和输血方面的费用更高,但住院费用更低。
要点
- DAA在术后3周和6周HHS功能评分优于PA,但6-8周后差异消失。
- DAA手术时间更长、失血量更多,但住院时间平均缩短13.4小时。
- DAA在手术室时间和输血上费用更高,住院费用更低,总体累积成本更高。
核心结论
- DAA相比PA在THA术后早期功能和疼痛方面有优势,但优势持续时间短,后期无显著差异,且DAA累积成本更高。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA方案和Cochrane手册的Meta分析,检索多个在线数据库,进行非分层和分层Meta分析以检验纳入研究的混杂偏倚。
主要发现
- DAA组手术时间显著更长(p < 0.001),住院时间平均缩短13.4小时(95%CI 9.12至18;p < 0.001),失血量更多(p = 0.030)。
- DAA组术后3周(p < 0.001)和6周(p = 0.006)HHS显著更优,但6-8周(p = 0.230)、12周(p = 0.470)、6个月(p = 0.740)和1年(p = 0.610)无显著差异。
- SF-12生理评分在6周(p = 0.580)和1年(p = 0.360)、SF-12心理评分在6周(p = 0.170)和1年(p = 0.960)、UCLA活动量表在12周(p = 0.250)均无显著差异。
- 非分层和分层分析中,DAA组手术室时间费用平均多587.57美元(95%CI 263.83至1,010.29)至887.04美元(95%CI 574.20至1,298.88),输血费用平均多248.38美元(95%CI 1,003.40至1,539.90)至1,162.41美元(95%CI 645.78至7,441.30)。
- 住院时间费用DAA组分别平均少218.23美元和192.05美元。
临床怎么用
- 对于追求早期功能恢复的THA患者,可考虑DAA,但需权衡其更高的人力资源和费用成本。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: It has been suggested that the direct anterior approach (DAA) should be used for total hip arthroplasty (THA) instead of the posterior approach (PA) for better early functional outcomes. We conducted a value-based analysis of the functional outcome and associated perioperative costs, to determine which surgical approach gives the better short-term outcomes and lower costs. METHODS: This meta-analysis was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) protocol and the Cochrane Handbook. Several online databases were searched. Non-stratified and stratified meta-analyses were conducted to test the confounding biases in the studies which were included. The mean cost and probability were used to determine the added costs of perioperative services. RESULTS: The DAA group had significantly longer operating times (p < 0.001), reduced length of hospital stay by a mean of 13.4 hours (95% confidence interval (CI) 9.12 to 18; p < 0.001), and greater blood loss (p = 0.030). The DAA group had significantly better functional outcome at three (p < 0.001) and six weeks (p = 0.006) postoperatively according to the Harris Hip Score (HHS). However, there was no significant difference between the groups for the HHS at six to eight weeks (p = 0.230), 12 weeks (p = 0.470), six months (p = 0.740), and one year (p = 0.610), the 12-Item Short Form Survey (SF-12) physical score at six weeks (p = 0.580) and one year (p = 0.360), SF-12 mental score at six weeks (p = 0.170) and one year (p = 0.960), and University of California and Los Angeles (UCLA) activity scale at 12 weeks (p = 0.250). The mean non-stratified and stratified difference in costs for the operating theatre time and blood transfusion were $587.57 (95% CI 263.83 to 1,010.29) to $887.04 (95% CI 574.20 to 1,298.88) and $248.38 (95% CI 1,003.40 to 1,539.90) to $1,162.41 (95% CI 645.78 to 7,441.30), respectively, more for the DAA group. However, the mean differences in costs for the time in hospital were $218.23 and $192.05, respectively, less for the DAA group. CONCLUSION: The use of the DAA, rather than the PA, in THA has earlier benefits for function and pain. However, these are short-lasting, with no significant differences seen at later intervals. In addition the limited benefits were obtained with higher cumulative costs for DAA. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(6):1078-1087.
引用
- Awad ME, Farley BJ, Mostafa G, et al. Direct anterior approach has short-term functional benefit and higher resource requirements compared with the posterior approach in primary total hip arthroplasty : a meta-analysis of functional outcomes and cost. Bone Joint J. 2021. PMID: 34058867. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.103B6.BJJ-2020-1271.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。