机械臂辅助与手工全髋关节置换术的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析评估了半主动机械臂辅助全髋关节置换术(rTHA)的学习曲线,并比较了rTHA与手工全髋关节置换术(mTHA)在精度、患者报告功能结局、并发症和生存率方面的差异。共纳入17篇文章,Meta分析显示rTHA在髋臼组件安全区放置例数上显著多于mTHA(95%CI 4.10-7.94;p<0.001),且短期至中期随访的Harris髋关节评分显著更优(95%CI 0.46-5.64;p=0.020);但感染率、脱位率、总体并发症率和短期生存率无差异。rTHA学习曲线为12-35例,取决于评估目标。
要点
- rTHA髋臼组件安全区放置例数显著多于mTHA(95%CI 4.10-7.94;p<0.001)。
- rTHA短期至中期Harris髋关节评分显著优于mTHA(95%CI 0.46-5.64;p=0.020)。
- rTHA学习曲线为12-35例,取决于评估目标如手术时间、精度和团队协作。
核心结论
- rTHA学习曲线为12-35例,取决于评估目标如手术时间、精度和团队协作。
- rTHA在组件定位精度和功能结局方面优于mTHA,但短期至中期随访并发症率和生存率无差异。
- 目前缺乏高质量I级证据和成本分析比较rTHA与mTHA。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索PubMed、Medline和Google Scholar(2020年4月),遵循PRISMA声明。
- 初检501篇文章,全文筛选后纳入17篇满足标准的临床研究文章。
- 4项研究报告rTHA学习曲线,13项报告植入物定位,5项报告功能结局,10项报告并发症,4项报告生存率。
主要发现
- Meta分析显示rTHA组髋臼组件安全区放置例数显著多于mTHA组(95%CI 4.10-7.94;p<0.001)。
- rTHA组短期至中期随访Harris髋关节评分显著优于mTHA组(95%CI 0.46-5.64;p=0.020)。
- 感染率、脱位率、总体并发症率和短期随访生存率无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准为已发表的临床研究文章,报告rTHA(仅机械臂辅助)学习曲线或比较rTHA与mTHA的植入精度、功能结局、生存率或并发症。
- rTHA学习曲线范围为12-35例,取决于评估目标如手术时间、精度和团队协作。
临床怎么用
- rTHA可提高髋臼组件定位精度和短期至中期功能结局,但需注意学习曲线为12-35例。
- 短期至中期并发症率和生存率与mTHA无差异,决策时需结合成本分析(目前缺乏)综合考量。
局限性
- 缺乏高质量I级证据和成本分析比较rTHA与mTHA。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: The aims of this systematic review were to assess the learning curve of semi-active robotic arm-assisted total hip arthroplasty (rTHA), and to compare the accuracy, patient-reported functional outcomes, complications, and survivorship between rTHA and manual total hip arthroplasty (mTHA). METHODS: Searches of PubMed, Medline, and Google Scholar were performed in April 2020 in line with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis statement. Search terms included "robotic", "hip", and "arthroplasty". The criteria for inclusion were published clinical research articles reporting the learning curve for rTHA (robotic arm-assisted only) and those comparing the implantation accuracy, functional outcomes, survivorship, or complications with mTHA. RESULTS: There were 501 articles initially identified from databases and references. Following full text screening, 17 articles that satisfied the inclusion criteria were included. Four studies reported the learning curve of rTHA, 13 studies reported on implant positioning, five on functional outcomes, ten on complications, and four on survivorship. The meta-analysis showed a significantly greater number of cases of acetabular component placement in the safe zone compared with the mTHA group (95% confidence interval (CI) 4.10 to 7.94; p < 0.001) and that rTHA resulted in a significantly better Harris Hip Score compared to mTHA in the short- to mid-term follow-up (95% CI 0.46 to 5.64; p = 0.020). However, there was no difference in infection rates, dislocation rates, overall complication rates, and survival rates at short-term follow-up. CONCLUSION: The learning curve of rTHA was between 12 and 35 cases, which was dependent on the assessment goal, such as operating time, accuracy, and team working. Robotic arm-assisted total hip arthroplasty was associated with improved accuracy of component positioning and functional outcome, however no difference in complication rates or survival were observed at short- to mid-term follow-up. Overall, there remains an absence of high-quality level I evidence and cost analysis comparing rTHA and mTHA. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(6):1009-1020.
引用
- Ng N, Gaston P, Simpson PM, et al. Robotic arm-assisted versus manual total hip arthroplasty : a systematic review and meta-analysis. Bone Joint J. 2021. PMID: 34058875. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.103B6.BJJ-2020-1856.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。