文献速递脊柱外科

3D打印钻头导板与螺钉导板在椎弓根内外螺钉置入中的比较

A Comparison of Drill Guiding and Screw Guiding 3D-Printing Techniques for Intra- and Extrapedicular Screw Insertion.
PubMed 文献 · Spine (Phila Pa 1976) · 2021-06-15

一项随机尸体研究比较了3D打印钻头导板与额外螺钉导引技术(克氏针空心螺钉或模块化导板)在椎弓根内和椎弓根外螺钉轨迹中的准确性。结果显示,椎弓根内螺钉错位率低(2%),模块化导板可显著提高准确性(P=0.05);而椎弓根外螺钉的两种额外导引方法均未显著改善准确性(P=0.09),错位率仍高达24%。结论认为额外螺钉导引技术对椎弓根外螺钉并不优于常规钻头导板,颈椎椎弓根内螺钉常规钻头导板已具高准确性。

要点

  • 椎弓根内螺钉错位率低(2%),模块化导板较钻头导板显著提高准确性(P=0.05)。
  • 颈椎所有技术均准确置钉无突破。
  • 椎弓根外螺钉额外导引未显著改善准确性(P=0.09),错位率仍高(24%)。

核心结论

  • 额外螺钉导引技术对技术上要求高的椎弓根外螺钉技术并不优于常规3D打印钻头导板。
  • 对于椎弓根内螺钉置入,模块化导板可改善置入准确性;但在颈椎水平,常规3D打印钻头导板已表现出很高准确性,因此额外螺钉导引技术无益处。

研究设计与样本

  • 螺钉随机尸体研究,采用两项尸体实验比较钻头导板与两种引入额外螺钉导引的技术(克氏针空心螺钉或模块化导板)。
  • 根据随机化方案使用每种方法之一进行椎弓根内或椎弓根外螺钉置入,术后CT扫描并与术前计划融合进行详细3D螺钉偏差分析。

主要发现

  • 椎弓根内螺钉轨迹错位率低(2%),模块化导板与钻头导板相比准确性有统计学显著提高(P=0.05)。
  • 所有技术在颈椎螺钉置入中均准确无突破。
  • 对于椎弓根外螺钉轨迹,两种额外螺钉导引方法均未显著改善准确性(P=0.09),错位率仍高(24%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 椎弓根内螺钉错位率2%。
  • 模块化导板与钻头导板比较P=0.05。
  • 椎弓根外螺钉额外导引方法比较P=0.09,错位率24%。
  • 证据等级:3。

临床怎么用

  • 在颈椎椎弓根内螺钉置入中,常规3D打印钻头导板已足够准确,无需额外螺钉导引。
  • 对于椎弓根外螺钉轨迹,额外螺钉导引技术未显示优势,错位率仍较高,需谨慎评估。
  • 模块化导板可考虑用于改善椎弓根内螺钉置入准确性,但需结合具体节段和病例。

局限性

  • 本研究为尸体研究,结论外推至临床需谨慎。
  • 证据等级为3。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY DESIGN: Screw randomized cadaveric study. OBJECTIVE: To compare the accuracy of three-dimensional (3D)-printed drill guides versus additional screw guiding techniques for challenging intra- and extrapedicular screw trajectories. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Pedicle screw placement can be technically demanding, especially in syndromic scoliosis with limited bone stock. Recently, 3D-printing and virtual planning technology have become available as new tools to improve pedicle screw insertion. Differences in techniques exist, while some focus on guiding the drill, others also actively guide subsequent screws insertion. The accuracy of various 3D-printing-assisted techniques has been studied; however, direct comparative studies have yet to determine whether there is a benefit of additional screw guidance. METHODS: Two cadaveric experiments were conducted to compare drill guides with two techniques that introduce additional screw guiding. The screw guiding consisted of either k-wire cannulated screws or modular guides, which were designed to guide the screw in addition to the drill bit. Screws were inserted intra- or extrapedicular using one of each methods according to a randomization scheme. Postoperative computed tomography scanning was performed and fused with the preoperative planning for detailed 3D screw deviation analysis. RESULTS: For intrapedicular screw trajectories malpositioning was low (2%) and the modular guides revealed a statistically significant increase of accuracy (P = 0.05) compared with drill guides. All techniques showed accurate cervical screw insertion without breach. For the extrapedicular screw trajectories both additional screw guiding methods did not significantly (P = 0.09) improve accuracy and malpositioning rates remained high (24%). CONCLUSIONS: In this cadaveric study it was found that the additional screw-guiding techniques are not superior to the regular 3D-printed drill guides for the technically demanding extrapedicular screw technique. For intrapedicular screw insertion, modular guides can improve insertion; however, at cervical levels regular 3D-printed drill guides already demonstrated very high accuracy and therefore there is no benefit from additional screw guiding techniques. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3.

来源:Spine (Phila Pa 1976),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pijpker PAJ, Kuijlen JMA, Kraeima J, et al. A Comparison of Drill Guiding and Screw Guiding 3D-Printing Techniques for Intra- and Extrapedicular Screw Insertion. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2021. PMID: 34132234. doi:10.1097/BRS.0000000000004147

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。