文献速递创伤骨科

锁骨内侧骨折治疗后的功能结局与疼痛评分

What Are the Functional Outcomes and Pain Scores after Medial Clavicle Fracture Treatment?
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2021-01-01

美国两家三级转诊中心2010年至2019年回顾性纳入74例成人锁骨内侧骨折患者,31例获得至少1年随访(中位5年)。平均QuickDASH评分12±15、疼痛评分1±1,但1年、3年、5年死亡率分别为15%、22%、34%。

要点

  • 存活患者功能结局与疼痛缓解较好,平均QuickDASH 12±15、疼痛1±1。
  • 队列死亡率高:1年15%、3年22%、5年34%。
  • 现有样本量不足以检出与骨折移位、短缩或粉碎相关的因素。

核心结论

  • 锁骨内侧骨折存活患者至少1年随访时功能结局良好且疼痛缓解,但较高比例在伤后3年内死亡。
  • 结局指标与骨折移位、短缩或粉碎无关联,但样本量不足,结果应视为初步。

研究设计与样本

  • 美国单一都市区两家三级转诊中心的回顾性研究,经机构审查委员会批准。
  • 初始查询1950例锁骨骨折,识别74例成人锁骨内侧骨折且有至少1年随访者,最终31例(占总数42%、存活者65%)纳入分析。

主要发现

  • 伤后平均5±3年时平均QuickDASH评分12±15、疼痛评分1±1(10分Likert量表)。
  • 队列1年死亡率15%(11/74)、3年22%(16/74)、5年34%(25/74)。
  • 2例在伤后平均5±3年持续骨不连。
  • 现有样本量下未发现与QuickDASH或疼痛评分相关的因素,可能检验效能不足。

关键数值与推荐

  • 主要结局为至少1年时的QuickDASH评分(中位5年,范围2至10年)。
  • 次要结局为10分Likert量表疼痛评分。
  • 双变量分析考察年龄、性别、种族、优势手受伤、就业状态、体力劳动职业、保险、社会剥夺、BMI、糖尿病、吸烟、ASA分级、Charlson共病指数、非孤立伤、高能量损伤机制、无移位骨折、粉碎、上下移位、内外短缩及手术治疗等因素。
  • 证据等级为Level IV治疗性研究。

临床怎么用

  • 对存活出院的锁骨内侧骨折患者,可预期至少1年时功能结局良好、疼痛较轻。
  • 应重视该人群的高死亡风险,尤其伤后3年内,需关注老年及高能量损伤患者的整体状况。
  • 骨折移位、短缩或粉碎暂不能作为预后判断或手术决策的可靠依据,手术指征仍需进一步研究。

局限性

  • 回顾性研究,仅42%的总病例和65%的存活患者获得随访,存在失访偏倚。
  • 样本量小、检验效能不足,阴性关联结果应视为初步。
  • 仅2例接受手术,无法评价手术疗效。
  • 死亡信息部分依赖社会保障死亡索引与公开讣告。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Medial clavicle fractures are uncommon, occurring in older and multiply injured patients. The management of these fractures and the factors that predispose toward poor outcomes are controversial. Furthermore, the functional outcomes of treatment are not well characterized or correlated with fracture patterns. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) To determine minimum 1-year functional outcomes using QuickDASH scores and pain scores after medial clavicle fractures and (2) to identify factors associated with these outcome variables. METHODS: In an institutional review board-approved, retrospective study, we identified adult patients with medial clavicle fractures at two tertiary care referral centers in a single metropolitan area in the United States from January 2010 to March 2019. Our initial query identified 1950 patients with clavicle fractures, from which 74 adult patients with medial clavicle fractures and at least 1 year of follow-up were identified. We attempted to contact these eligible patients by telephone for functional outcomes and pain scores. Twenty-six patients were deceased according to the most recent Social Security Death Index data and public obituaries, three declined participation, and 14 could not be reached, leaving 42% of the total (31 of 74) and 65% (31 of 48) of living patients included in the analysis. Demographic characteristics, fracture characteristics, and clinical and radiographic union as assessed by plain radiography and CT were collected through record review. Twenty-nine patients were treated nonoperatively and two patients underwent open reduction internal fixation. Sixty-eight percent (21 of 31) of the included patients also had radiographic follow-up at least 6 weeks postoperatively; two patients had persistent nonunion at a mean of 5 ± 3 years after injury. Our primary response variable was the QuickDASH score at a minimum of 1 year (median [range] 5 years [2 to 10]). Our secondary response variable was the pain score on a 10-point Likert scale. A bivariate analysis was performed to identify factors associated with these response variables. The following explanatory variables were studied: age, gender, race, dominant hand injury, employment status, manual labor occupation, primary health insurance, social deprivation, BMI, diabetes mellitus, smoking status, American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status classification, Charlson Comorbidity Index, nonisolated injury, high-energy mechanism of injury, nondisplaced fracture, fracture comminution, superior-inferior fracture displacement, medial-lateral fracture shortening, and surgical treatment of the medial clavicle fracture. RESULTS: The mean QuickDASH score was 12 ± 15, and the mean pain score was 1 ± 1 at a mean of 5 ± 3 years after injury. The mortality rate of the cohort was 15% (11 of 74) at 1 year, 22% (16 of 74) at 3 years, and 34% (25 of 74) at 5 years after injury. With the numbers available, no factors were associated with the QuickDASH score or pain score, but it is likely we were underpowered to detect potentially important differences. CONCLUSION: Medial clavicle fractures have favorable functional outcomes and pain relief at minimum 1-year follow-up among those patients who survive the trauma, but a high proportion will die within 3 years of the injury. This likely reflects both the frailty of a predominantly older patient population and the fact that these often are high-energy injuries. The outcome measures in our cohort were not associated with fracture displacement, shortening, or comminution; however, our sample size was underpowered on these points, and so these findings should be considered preliminary. Further studies are needed to determine the subset of patients with this injury who would benefit from surgical intervention. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, therapeutic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lindsey MH, Grisdela P, Lu L, et al. What Are the Functional Outcomes and Pain Scores after Medial Clavicle Fracture Treatment? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 34100833. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001839

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。