髋臼周围骨盆骨肉瘤切除后保肢重建方法比较
本研究回顾122例髋臼周围骨肉瘤保肢手术患者,比较定制假体、冰淇淋锥假体、体外照射自体骨和非骨骼重建四种方式。定制假体主要并发症率62%、十年重建失败率19%;冰淇淋锥假体并发症率24%、失败率9%;非骨骼重建并发症率17%、失败率0%。功能结局与是否发生需再次手术的并发症密切相关。
要点
- 定制假体与非骨骼重建并发症率较高,冰淇淋锥假体较低。
- 功能评分在无重大并发症患者中显著更高。
- 累及髂骨切除时,无并发症者定制假体功能最佳;高风险者非骨骼重建合理。
核心结论
- 髋臼周围重建的功能结局与需再次手术的并发症发生密切相关。
- 累及髋臼和髂骨切除时,无并发症者骨骼重建可能效果最佳,并发症风险高时非骨骼重建是合理选择。
- 不累及髂骨的髋臼周围切除,抗生素骨水泥支撑的冰淇淋锥假体是可靠选择。
研究设计与样本
- 连续系列122例髋臼周围骨肉瘤行保肢手术患者,按重建方式分组:定制假体65例(53%)、冰淇淋锥假体21例(17%)、体外照射自体骨18例(15%)、非骨骼重建18例(15%)。
主要发现
- 需再次手术的重大并发症率分别为定制假体62%、冰淇淋锥假体24%、体外照射自体骨56%、非骨骼重建17%(p=0.001)。
- 十年重建失败累积发生率分别为定制假体19%、冰淇淋锥假体9%、体外照射自体骨33%、非骨骼重建0%。
- 失败主要原因:深部感染11%,局部复发6%。
- 平均MSTS功能评分分别为定制假体59%、冰淇淋锥假体74%、体外照射自体骨64%、非骨骼重建72%。
- 有重大并发症者平均MSTS评分52%(SD 20%)显著低于无并发症者74%(SD 19%)(p<0.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 累及髂骨的髋臼周围切除且无重大并发症者,定制假体平均MSTS评分最高82%(SD 10%)。
- 累及髂骨的髋臼周围切除且有重大并发症者,非骨骼重建平均MSTS评分最高78%(SD 12%)。
- 不累及髂骨的髋臼周围切除,冰淇淋锥假体平均MSTS评分显著更高79%(SD 17%)(p=0.031)。
临床怎么用
- 选择髋臼周围重建方式时需权衡并发症风险与功能结局。
- 累及髂骨且并发症风险高者可选非骨骼重建;不累及髂骨者冰淇淋锥假体可靠。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Limb salvage for pelvic sarcomas involving the acetabulum is a major surgical challenge. There remains no consensus about what is the optimum type of reconstruction after resection of the tumour. The aim of this study was to evaluate the surgical outcomes in these patients according to the methods of periacetabular reconstruction. METHODS: The study involved a consecutive series of 122 patients with a periacetabular bone sarcoma who underwent limb-salvage surgery involving a custom-made prosthesis in 65 (53%), an ice-cream cone prosthesis in 21 (17%), an extracorporeal irradiated autograft in 18 (15%), and nonskeletal reconstruction in 18 (15%). RESULTS: The rates of major complications necessitating further surgery were 62%, 24%, 56%, and 17% for custom-made prostheses, ice-cream cone prostheses, irradiated autografts and nonskeletal reconstructions, respectively (p = 0.001). The ten-year cumulative incidence of failure of the reconstruction was 19%, 9%, 33%, and 0%, respectively. The major cause of failure was deep infection (11%), followed by local recurrence (6%). The mean functional Musculoskeletal Tumour Society (MSTS) scores were 59%, 74%, 64%, and 72%, respectively. The scores were significantly lower in patients with major complications than in those without complications (mean 52% (SD 20%) vs 74% (SD 19%); p < 0.001). For periacetabular resections involving the ilium, the mean score was the highest with custom-made prostheses (82% (SD 10%)) in patients without any major complication; however, nonskeletal reconstruction resulted in the highest mean scores (78% (SD 12%)) in patients who had major complications. For periacetabular resections not involving the ilium, significantly higher mean scores were obtained with ice-cream cone prostheses (79% (SD 17%); p = 0.031). CONCLUSION: Functional outcome following periacetabular reconstruction is closely associated with the occurrence of complications requiring further surgery. For tumours treated with periacetabular and iliac resection, skeletal reconstruction may result in the best outcomes in the absence of complications, whereas nonskeletal reconstruction is a reasonable option if the risk of complications is high. For tumours requiring periacetabular resection without the ilium, reconstruction using an ice-cream cone prosthesis supported by antibiotic-laden cement is a reliable option. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2021;103-B(4):795-803.
引用
- Fujiwara T, Medellin Rincon MR, Sambri A, et al. Limb-salvage reconstruction following resection of pelvic bone sarcomas involving the acetabulum. Bone Joint J. 2021. PMID: 33789467. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.103B4.BJJ-2020-0665.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。