前交叉韧带重建术后10年创伤性骨关节炎的临床影像学发生率:MOON巢式队列数据
该研究基于MOON前瞻性队列中146例接受前交叉韧带重建(ACLR)的年轻运动患者,在至少10年随访时对双膝X线片按IKDC、OARSI和改良Kellgren-Lawrence标准盲法评分。在133例对侧膝影像学正常者中,以骨赘定义的症状性影像学创伤性骨关节炎(PTOA)10年发生率为37%,以关节间隙狭窄定义为23%,双侧骨赘与关节间隙狭窄分级差异多不超过1级。
要点
- ACLR后10年以骨赘定义的影像学PTOA发生率为37%,以关节间隙狭窄定义为23%。
- OARSI骨赘分级双膝最大差值≤1级者占85%,关节间隙狭窄≤1级者占96%。
- IKDC、OARSI与KL评分的评分者间一致性分别为0.71、0.84与0.48。
核心结论
- 在年轻运动患者中,ACLR后10年临床影像学PTOA发生率以骨赘定义为37%,以关节间隙狭窄定义为23%。
- ACLR膝与对侧膝之间骨赘形成与关节间隙狭窄程度的平均差异较小。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为病例系列,证据等级4级,属MOON前瞻性队列的巢式队列研究。
- 纳入146例运动相关ACL损伤、ACLR时年龄<33岁、无同侧或对侧膝关节手术史且随访前未行翻修ACLR的患者,至少随访10年。
- 由2名盲法评审者按IKDC、OARSI和改良Kellgren-Lawrence标准对双膝X线片进行评分。
- 在对侧无ACL损伤且对侧膝影像学正常的133例患者中分析同侧与对侧影像学OA的发生率与严重程度。
主要发现
- 评分者间一致性:IKDC的Gwet一致系数为0.71,KL为0.48,OARSI为0.84。
- 对侧膝影像学正常者中,ACLR后10年以骨赘定义的临床影像学PTOA发生率为37%,以关节间隙狭窄定义为23%。
- OARSI骨赘分级(内外侧间室最大差值)为0者占65%、1者占20%、≥2者占15%。
- OARSI关节间隙狭窄分级最大差值为0者占77%、1者占19%、≥2者占4%。
关键数值与推荐
- PTOA发生率:以骨赘定义为37%,以关节间隙狭窄定义为23%(对侧膝影像学正常者,N=133,随访10年)。
- 骨赘形成双膝差异≤1级者占85%,关节间隙狭窄差异≤1级者占96%。
- 评分者间一致性:IKDC Gwet AC1=0.71,KL=0.48,OARSI=0.84。
临床怎么用
- 可为年轻ACLR患者术后10年提供影像学PTOA发生风险的量化参考。
- 提示多数患者双膝骨赘与关节间隙狭窄分级差异较小,随访中可双侧对比评估。
- 研究为病例系列(证据等级4级),结果用于风险沟通而非确立治疗指征。
局限性
- 研究为病例系列,证据等级4级,未设非手术对照组。
- PTOA发生率分析仅基于对侧膝影像学正常的133例患者。
- 原文未报告症状与影像学相关性、危险因素分析等结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The incidence of posttraumatic osteoarthritis (PTOA) based on clinical radiographic grading criteria at 10 years after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction (ACLR) has not been well-defined in a prospective cohort of young athletic patients. HYPOTHESIS: Among young athletic patients, there is a high incidence of clinical radiographic PTOA at 10 years after ACLR. Additionally, there is a significant difference in clinical radiographic osteoarthritis (OA) changes (joint space narrowing and osteophyte formation) between ACL-reconstructed and contralateral knees at 10 years. STUDY DESIGN: Case series; Level of evidence, 4. METHODS: The first 146 patients in an ongoing nested cohort study of the Multicenter Orthopaedic Outcomes Network (MOON) prospective cohort presented for a minimum 10-year follow-up. Included patients had a sports-related ACL injury, were aged <33 years at the time of ACLR, had no history of ipsilateral or contralateral knee surgery, and did not undergo revision ACLR before follow-up. Bilateral knee metatarsophalangeal view radiographs were obtained and graded according to International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC), Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI), and modified Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) criteria by 2 blinded reviewers. The incidence and severity of ipsilateral and contralateral radiographic OA were determined among patients without a contralateral ACL injury before 10-year follow-up (N = 133). RESULTS: Interrater reliability was substantial for the IKDC (Gwet Agreement Coefficient [AC] 1 = 0.71), moderate for the KL (0.48), and almost perfect for the OARSI (0.84) grading systems. Among patients with a contralateral radiographically normal knee, the 10-year incidence of clinical radiographic PTOA after ACLR was 37% as defined by osteophytes and 23% as defined by joint space narrowing. The maximum side-to-side difference in the OARSI osteophyte grade in the medial or lateral compartment was 0 in 65% of patients, 1 in 20%, and ≥2 in 15%. The maximum side-to-side difference in the OARSI joint space narrowing grade was 0 in 77% of patients, 1 in 19%, and ≥2 in 4%. CONCLUSION: In young active patients, the 10-year incidence of clinical radiographic PTOA after ACLR was 37% as defined by osteophytes and 23% as defined by joint space narrowing. The mean difference in the degree of osteophyte formation (≤1 grade in 85%) and joint space narrowing (≤1 grade in 96%) between the ACL-reconstructed and contralateral knees was small. REGISTRATION: NCT02717559 (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier).
引用
- Everhart JS, Jones MH, Yalcin S, et al. The Clinical Radiographic Incidence of Posttraumatic Osteoarthritis 10 Years After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Data From the MOON Nested Cohort. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 33793363. doi:10.1177/0363546521995182
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。