胫骨后向载荷增加ACL重建中髌股关节峰值接触压力
一项尸体研究在9例人膝关节上测试前交叉韧带重建时不同胫骨后向载荷与移植物张力对髌股关节接触力学的影响,发现重建后髌股关节峰值接触压力较完整状态显著增加,高胫骨后向载荷可导致内侧髌股关节峰值接触压力升高,而移植物张力无显著影响。
要点
- ACL重建后髌股关节内外侧峰值接触压力较ACL完整状态显著增加。
- 高胫骨后向载荷可导致内侧髌股关节峰值接触压力显著升高。
- 移植物张力(20N、60N、80N)对髌股关节峰值接触压力无显著影响。
核心结论
- 在尸体模型中,ACL重建较ACL完整状态显著增加髌股关节小面峰值接触压力。
- 高胫骨后向载荷可导致内侧髌股关节峰值接触压力升高。
- 移植物张力对ACL重建中髌股关节接触压力无显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- 对照实验室研究,采用9例新鲜冷冻非配对人类尸体膝关节。
- 在定制夹具中于0°至120°膝关节屈曲范围测试,先测试ACL完整状态,再以不同胫骨后向载荷和移植物张力进行ACL重建。
- 胫骨后向载荷评估2个水平:33.5 N和67 N;移植物张力评估3个水平:低张力20 N、中张力60 N、高张力80 N。
- 比较ACL完整与ACL重建膝关节内侧和外侧髌骨小面峰值接触压力最大值,并在30°、60°、90°、120°屈曲时比较髌股关节运动学。
主要发现
- 低和高胫骨后向载荷重建ACL均导致内侧髌股关节峰值接触压力显著增加(差值范围0.46-0.92 MPa;P < .05)。
- 低和高胫骨后向载荷重建ACL均导致外侧髌股关节峰值接触压力显著增加(差值范围0.51-0.83 MPa;P < .05)。
- ACL重建膝关节与ACL完整膝关节之间髌股关节运动学无显著差异。
- 在ACL重建膝关节中,高胫骨后向载荷导致内侧髌骨侧高峰值接触压力(差值范围0.37-0.46 MPa;P < .05)。
- 不同移植物张力之间峰值接触压力无显著差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 胫骨后向载荷水平:33.5 N和67 N。
- 移植物张力水平:低张力20 N、中张力60 N、高张力80 N。
- 内侧髌股关节峰值接触压力差值范围0.46-0.92 MPa(P < .05)。
- 外侧髌股关节峰值接触压力差值范围0.51-0.83 MPa(P < .05)。
- 高胫骨后向载荷下内侧髌骨侧峰值接触压力差值范围0.37-0.46 MPa(P < .05)。
临床怎么用
- ACL重建术中过大的胫骨后向载荷可导致术中髌股关节接触压力增加。
- 数据提示ACL重建手术中可能偏好采用低胫骨后向载荷,以使髌股关节接触压力接近ACL完整状态。
局限性
- 本研究为尸体模型,结果需在临床研究中进一步验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Inappropriate posterior tibial loading and initial graft tension during anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction may cause altered patellofemoral joint (PFJ) contact mechanics, potentially resulting in pain and joint degeneration. HYPOTHESIS: PFJ contact pressure would increase with the increases in posterior tibial loading and graft tension during ACL reconstruction. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Nine fresh-frozen, nonpaired human cadaveric knees were tested in a customized jig from 0° to 120° of knee flexion. First, the knee was tested in the ACL-intact state. Second, reconstruction of the ACLs using different posterior tibial loadings and graft tensions were performed. The posterior tibial loading was evaluated at 2 levels: 33.5 and 67 N. Graft tension was assessed at 3 levels: low tension (20 N), medium tension (60 N), and high tension (80 N). Maximum values of peak contact pressure in the medial and lateral patellar facets were compared between ACL-intact and ACL-reconstructed knees. The PFJ kinematics between ACL-intact knees and ACL-reconstructed knees were compared during knee flexion at 30°, 60°, 90°, and 120°. RESULTS: Reconstruction of ACLs with both low and high posterior tibial loading resulted in significant increases of peak contact pressure in the medial (range of differences, 0.46-0.92 MPa; P < .05) and lateral (range of differences, 0.51-0.83 MPa; P < .05) PFJ compared with the ACL-intact condition. However, no significant differences in PFJ kinematics were identified between ACL-reconstructed knees and ACL-intact knees. In ACL-reconstructed knees, it was found that a high posterior tibial loading resulted in high peak contact pressure on the medial patellar side (range of differences, 0.37-0.46 MPa; P < .05). No significant difference in peak contact pressure was observed among the differing graft tensions. CONCLUSION: In this cadaveric model, ACL reconstruction resulted in significant increases of peak contact pressure in the PFJ facet when compared with the ACL-intact condition. A high posterior tibial loading can lead to high medial PFJ peak contact pressure. Graft tension was found to not significantly affect PFJ contact pressure during ACL reconstruction. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: An excessive posterior tibial loading during ACL reconstruction resulted in increased PFJ contact pressures at time of surgery. These data suggest that a low posterior tibial loading might be preferred during ACL reconstruction surgery to reduce the PFJ contact pressure close to that of the ACL-intact condition.
引用
- Huang W, Ong MT, Man GC, et al. Posterior Tibial Loading Results in Significant Increase of Peak Contact Pressure in the Patellofemoral Joint During Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Cadaveric Study. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 33689503. doi:10.1177/0363546521995546
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。