COVID-19期间关节置换专科培训中协作教育模式的兴起
结果显示网络学习工具(如AC、AAHKS FOCAL讲座、行业讲座、网络研讨会)使用增加,而机构讲座、教科书和期刊文章使用下降。多机构协作讲座和病例讨论在学员中具有较高感知价值,应作为后COVID-19时代的重要教育工具。
要点
- COVID-19后网络学习工具使用增加,多机构协作病例讨论获高价值认可。
- 机构讲座、教科书和期刊文章使用下降,在线手术视频使用变化不大。
- 未参与AC的fellow多数希望增加多机构病例讨论会。
核心结论
- COVID-19后学员教育更侧重网络学习,多机构协作讲座和病例讨论具有显著感知价值,应考虑作为重要教育工具。
研究设计与样本
- 对Arthroplasty Consortium(AC)参与者和AAHKS成人关节重建fellow进行匿名调查,评估COVID-19前后教育工具使用情况。
主要发现
- 网络学习使用增加:AC(疫情前不适用,疫情后61%)、AAHKS FOCAL讲座(疫情前不适用,疫情后82%)、行业讲座(53%升至86%)、AAHKS/AAOS网络研讨会(35%升至56%)。
- 使用下降:机构讲座(89%降至80%)、教科书(68%降至49%)、期刊文章(97%降至90%),在线手术视频变化极小(84%降至82%)。
- 未参与AC的fellow多数希望增加多机构病例讨论会;AC参与者认为最有价值的两项工具是AC和FOCAL讲座。
临床怎么用
- 后COVID-19时代应重视网络学习和多机构协作病例讨论在关节置换培训中的应用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: COVID-19 has created a void in surgical education. Given social distancing and postponed surgeries, unique educational opportunities have arisen. Attendings from 10 adult reconstruction fellowships led a multi-institution web-based weekly collaborative, the Arthroplasty Consortium (AC), developed to educate trainees through complex arthroplasty case-based discussions. METHODS: We performed an anonymous survey of AC participants and American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons (AAHKS) adult reconstruction fellows. Participants were polled with regards to educational tools used before and after COVID-19 and their value. Specifically, participation in the AC, AAHKS FOCAL (Fellows Orthopedic Continued AAHKS Learning) lectures, institutional lectures, industry lectures, textbooks, online videos, journal articles, and webinars was assessed. RESULTS: Fifty-seven participants responded with 49 (86%) at the fellow level. There was an increase in the use of web-based learning, including the AC (Not applicable pre, 61% post), AAHKS FOCAL lectures (Not applicable pre, 82% post), industry lectures (53% pre, 86% post), and AAHKS/AAOS webinars (35% pre, 56% post). Usage declined with institutional lectures (89% pre, 80% post), textbooks (68% pre, 49% post), and journal articles (97% pre, 90% post), with minimal change in the use of online surgical videos (84% pre, 82% post). The majority of fellows not involved in the AC would like to see the addition of a multi-institutional case conference added to fellowship education. Of AC participants, the 2 most valuable educational tools were the AC and FOCAL lectures. CONCLUSION: Trainee education has changed post-COVID-19 with a greater focus on web-based learning. Multi-institutional collaborative lectures and case-based discussions have significant perceived value among trainees and should be considered important educational tools post-COVID 19.
引用
- Moschetti WE, Frye BM, Gililland JM, et al. The Emergence of Collaboration in the Education of Fellows and Residents during COVID-19. J Arthroplasty. 2021. PMID: 33685742. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2021.02.019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。