固定平台与活动平台内侧单髁膝关节置换的生存率比较:澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记研究
该研究基于澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记系统(AOANJRR),分析了1999年9月至2018年12月间50,380例因骨关节炎行内侧单髁膝关节置换(UKA)的病例,比较四种轴承设计的累积翻修率(CPR)。结果显示,15年时固定模块化UKA的CPR最低(16%),活动平台为23%,全聚乙烯为26%,固定金属背衬为20%。固定模块化设计在生存率上表现最佳。
要点
- 固定模块化UKA的15年累积翻修率最低(16%),优于其他三种设计。
- 活动平台UKA翻修风险显著高于固定模块化(HR 1.5,95%CI 1.4-1.6,p<0.001)。
- 全聚乙烯UKA在65岁以下患者中翻修率最高,但在65岁及以上与活动平台无差异。
核心结论
- 对于孤立内侧间室骨关节炎,若考虑UKA,固定模块化轴承设计在当前UKA设计中具有最佳的生存率。
研究设计与样本
- 基于澳大利亚骨科协会国家关节置换登记系统(AOANJRR)的队列研究,纳入1999年9月至2018年12月间50,380例因骨关节炎行内侧UKA的病例。
- 研究组包括活动平台UKA 40%(20,208例)、固定模块化UKA 35%(17,822例)、全聚乙烯UKA 23%(11,461例)和固定模压金属背衬UKA 2%(889例)。
- 总体平均年龄65±9.4岁,男性占55%(27,496例),各组性别比例和年龄分布相似。
主要发现
- 15年时固定模块化UKA的CPR为16%(95%CI 15%-17%),活动平台为23%(95%CI 22%-24%),全聚乙烯为26%(95%CI 24%-27%),固定模压金属背衬为20%(95%CI 16%-24%)。
- 与固定模块化UKA相比,活动平台UKA的翻修风险更高(HR 1.5,95%CI 1.4-1.6,p<0.001),固定模压金属背衬UKA也更高(HR 1.3,95%CI 1.1-1.6,p=0.003)。
- 按性别或年龄分层后结果一致;全聚乙烯UKA在65岁以下患者中翻修率最高,但在65岁及以上患者中与活动平台UKA无差异。
- 与固定模块化UKA相比,活动平台UKA(HR 1.7,95%CI 1.5-1.9,p<0.001)和全聚乙烯UKA(HR 2.4,95%CI 2.1-2.7,p<0.001)因松动导致的翻修风险更高。
- 全聚乙烯UKA在所有时间点因疾病进展的翻修风险更高(HR 1.4,95%CI 1.3-1.6,p<0.001);活动平台UKA在8年后因疾病进展的翻修风险更高(8-12年:HR 1.4,95%CI 1.2-1.7,p<0.001;12年以上:HR 1.9,95%CI 1.5-2.3,p<0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 对于孤立内侧间室骨关节炎患者,若选择UKA,固定模块化轴承设计可能提供更好的长期生存率。
- 活动平台UKA翻修风险较高,尤其因松动和远期疾病进展,临床决策时需权衡。
- 全聚乙烯UKA在年轻患者(<65岁)中翻修风险最高,应谨慎选择。
局限性
- 研究为登记系统回顾性分析,可能存在未测量的混杂因素。
- 证据等级为III级(治疗性研究)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: During the last 5 years, there has been an increase in the use of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) to treat knee osteoarthritis in Australia, and these account for almost 6% of annual knee replacement procedures. However, there is debate as to whether a fixed bearing or a mobile bearing design is best for decreasing revision for loosening and disease progression as well as improving survivorship. Small sample sizes and possible confounding in the studies on the topic may have masked differences between fixed and mobile bearing designs. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Using data from the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry (AOANJRR), we selected the four contemporary designs of medial compartment UKA: mobile bearing, fixed modular, all-polyethylene, and fixed molded metal-backed used for the treatment of osteoarthritis to ask: (1) How do the different designs of unicompartmental knees compare with survivorship as measured by cumulative percentage revision (CPR)? (2) Is there a difference in the revision rate between designs as a function of patient sex or age? (3) Do the reasons for revision differ, and what types of revision procedures are performed when these UKA are revised? METHODS: The AOANJRR longitudinally maintains data on all primary and revision joint arthroplasties, with nearly 100% capture. The study population included all UKA procedures undertaken for osteoarthritis between September 1999 and December 2018. Of 56,628 unicompartmental knees recorded during the study period, 50,380 medial UKA procedures undertaken for osteoarthritis were included in the analysis after exclusion of procedures with unknown bearing types (31 of 56,628), lateral or patellofemoral compartment UKA procedures (5657 of 56,628), and those performed for a primary diagnosis other than osteoarthritis (560 of 56,628). There were 50,380 UKA procedures available for analysis. The study group consisted of 40% (20,208 of 50,380) mobile bearing UKA, 35% (17,822 of 50,380) fixed modular UKA, 23% (11,461 of 50,380) all-polyethylene UKA, and 2% (889 of 50,380) fixed molded metal-backed UKA. There were similar sex proportions and age distributions for each bearing group. The overall mean age of patients was 65 ± 9.4 years, and 55% (27,496 of 50,380) of patients were males. The outcome measure was the CPR, which was defined using Kaplan-Meier estimates of survivorship to describe the time to the first revision. Hazard ratios from Cox proportional hazards models, adjusted for sex and age, were performed to compare the revision rates among groups. The cohort was stratified into age groups of younger than 65 years and 65 years and older to compare revision rates as a function of age. Differences among bearing groups for the major causes and modes of revision were assessed using hazard ratios. RESULTS: At 15 years, fixed modular UKA had a CPR of 16% (95% CI 15% to 17%). In comparison, the CPR was 23% (95% CI 22% to 24%) for mobile bearing UKA, 26% (95% CI 24% to 27%) for all-polyethylene UKA, and 20% (95% CI 16% to 24%) for fixed molded metal-backed UKA. The lower revision rate for fixed modular UKA was seen through the entire period compared with mobile bearing UKA (hazard ratio 1.5 [95% CI 1.4 to 1.6]; p < 0.001) and fixed molded metal-backed UKA (HR 1.3 [95% CI 1.1 to 1.6]; p = 0.003), but it varied with time compared with all-polyethylene UKA. The findings were consistent when stratified by sex or age. Although all-polyethylene UKA had the highest revision rate overall and for patients younger than 65 years, for patients aged 65 years and older, there was no difference between all-polyethylene and mobile bearing UKA. When compared with fixed modular UKA, a higher revision risk for loosening was shown in both mobile bearing UKA (HR 1.7 [95% CI 1.5 to 1.9]; p < 0.001) and all-polyethylene UKA (HR 2.4 [95% CI 2.1 to 2.7]; p < 0.001). The revision risk for disease progression was higher for all-polyethylene UKA at all time points (HR 1.4 [95% CI 1.3 to 1.6]; p < 0.001) and for mobile bearing UKA after 8 years when each were compared with fixed modular UKA (8 to 12 years: HR 1.4 [95% CI 1.2 to 1.7]; p < 0.001; 12 or more years: HR 1.9 [95% CI 1.5 to 2.3]; p < 0.001). The risk of revision to TKA was higher for mobile bearing UKA compared with fixed modular UKA (HR 1.4 [95% CI 1.3 to 1.5]; p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: If UKA is to be considered for the treatment of isolated medial compartment osteoarthritis, the fixed modular UKA bearing has the best survivorship of the current UKA designs. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Kannan A, Lewis PL, Dyer C, et al. Do Fixed or Mobile Bearing Implants Have Better Survivorship in Medial Unicompartmental Knee Arthroplasty? A Study From the Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 33729206. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001698
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。