AAHKS最佳讲台报告研究奖:比较不同冲洗液对关节置换表面葡萄球菌生物膜的疗效
该研究在塑料、骨水泥珠和多孔钛表面培养MSSA生物膜,测试多种抗菌溶液浸泡3分钟后的杀菌效果。结果显示生理盐水、万古霉素和多粘菌素-杆菌肽无效,仅10%聚维酮碘及10%聚维酮碘与4%过氧化氢1:1混合液在所有表面和时间点有效。生物膜越成熟,溶液效力普遍下降,且成本增加未带来效力提升。
要点
- 10%聚维酮碘及10%聚维酮碘与4%过氧化氢1:1混合液对三种表面MSSA生物膜均有效。
- 生理盐水、万古霉素(1 mg/mL)和多粘菌素-杆菌肽对MSSA生物膜无效。
核心结论
- 不同商用抗菌溶液对MSSA生物膜的效力差异显著,仅10%聚维酮碘及10%聚维酮碘与4%过氧化氢1:1混合液在三种表面和两个时间点均有效。
- 溶液效力随生物膜成熟度增加而普遍下降,且溶液成本增加并未带来效力提升。
研究设计与样本
- 在塑料48孔板、聚甲基丙烯酸甲酯骨水泥珠和多孔Ti-6Al-4V髋臼螺钉帽上培养MSSA生物膜。
- 测试溶液包括生理盐水、万古霉素1 mg/mL、多粘菌素-杆菌肽500,000 U/L-50,000 U/L、0.3%聚维酮碘、10%聚维酮碘、10%聚维酮碘与4%过氧化氢1:1混合液、0.04%聚六亚甲基双胍与甜菜碱、含0.05%葡萄糖酸氯己定的商用溶液、含苯扎氯铵和乙醇的商用溶液。
- 实验设三复孔并至少重复一次,以菌落形成单位计数较对照降低3个log数量级作为溶液效力的衡量标准。
主要发现
- 生理盐水、万古霉素和多粘菌素-杆菌肽对浮游MSSA的效力不及其他溶液。
- 10%聚维酮碘和10%聚维酮碘与4%过氧化氢1:1混合液是唯一在所有三种表面和两个时间点均对生物膜有效的溶液。
- 随着生物膜成熟度增加,溶液效力普遍下降。
关键数值与推荐
- 以菌落形成单位计数较对照降低3个log数量级作为溶液效力的衡量标准。
- 溶液暴露时间为3分钟,以模拟术中条件。
临床怎么用
- 骨科医生选择抗菌冲洗液时应考虑其对生物膜的效力差异,10%聚维酮碘及10%聚维酮碘与4%过氧化氢1:1混合液在测试中表现更优。
- 不应仅依据成本选择抗菌溶液,因成本增加未带来效力提升。
局限性
- 研究仅针对MSSA生物膜,未涵盖其他菌种。
- 实验在体外生物材料表面进行,可能不完全反映临床体内环境。
- 实验设三复孔并至少重复一次,样本量有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A diverse array of antibacterial solutions is utilized by orthopedic surgeons in an attempt to disperse bacterial biofilm. Few studies compare these agents against biofilm grown on clinically relevant orthopedic biomaterials, such as plastic, acrylic cement, and porous titanium. METHODS: MSSA biofilm was grown on plastic 48-well plates, polymethylmethacrylate cement beads and porous Ti-6Al-4V acetabular screw caps. Antibacterial solutions were tested according to manufacturer guidance and included: isotonic saline, vancomycin (1 mg/mL), polymyxin-bacitracin (500,000 U/L-50,000 U/L), povidone-iodine 0.3%, povidone-iodine 10%, a 1:1 combination of povidone-iodine 10% & 4% hydrogen peroxide, polyhexamethylene biguanide (PHMB) and betaine 0.04%, a commercial solution containing chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) 0.05%, and a commercial solution containing benzalkonium chloride and ethanol. Twenty four and 72-hour biofilms were exposed to solutions for 3 minutes to reproduce intraoperative conditions. Solution efficacy was measured through sonication of treated surfaces followed by counting colony forming units and validated with a resazurin assay to assess cell viability. Experiments were performed in triplicate and repeated at least once. A three-fold log reduction in CFU counts versus controls was considered as a measure of solution efficacy. RESULTS: Saline, vancomycin and polymyxin-bacitracin were ineffective compared to other solutions against planktonic MSSA. Povidone-iodine 10% and a 1:1 solution of povidone-iodine 10% and 4% hydrogen peroxide were the only effective solutions against biofilm across all three surfaces and time points. CONCLUSION: Commercial antibacterial solutions vary significantly in their efficacy against MSSA biofilm. Efficacy globally decreased as biofilm maturity increased. Increased solution cost did not confer increased efficacy.
引用
- Premkumar A, Nishtala SN, Nguyen JT, et al. The AAHKS Best Podium Presentation Research Award: Comparing the Efficacy of Irrigation Solutions on Staphylococcal Biofilm Formed on Arthroplasty Surfaces. J Arthroplasty. 2021. PMID: 33750633. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2021.02.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。