陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换长期随访中摩擦音常见且随时间增加
该研究对62例第三代氧化铝对氧化铝陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换患者进行中位14年随访,发现53%患者自报摩擦音,钛钼锆铁股骨柄患者摩擦音风险更高,但摩擦音与翻修率和功能评分无显著差异。
要点
- 陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换长期随访中53%患者自报摩擦音。
- 钛钼锆铁股骨柄患者摩擦音风险是钛铝钒柄的3.8倍。
- 摩擦音与翻修率和HOOS JR功能评分无显著关联。
核心结论
- 陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换长期随访中摩擦音比既往报道更常见。
- 队列生存率低于预期,且本系列大多数翻修是因摩擦音。
- 摩擦音具有植入物依赖性,医生应告知患者术后数年可能出现摩擦音。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性队列研究,2003年1月1日至2008年8月31日共80例患者接受第三代氧化铝对氧化铝陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换。
- 排除死亡1例和失访17例,最终62例纳入分析,中位随访14年(范围11至16年)。
- 陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换占研究期间所有初次全髋关节置换的23%(80/343),优先用于50岁以下患者。
- 摩擦音通过邮寄问卷或电话访谈确定,使用研究者开发的10问题调查。
主要发现
- 53%(33/62)患者自报摩擦音。
- 钛钼锆铁股骨柄患者摩擦音比例为63%(29/46),钛铝钒柄为31%(4/13),比值比3.8(95%CI 1.02至14.4),p=0.046。
- 组件位置、组件尺寸、患者年龄、性别或BMI与摩擦音报告可能性无差异。
- 报告摩擦音患者10年无翻修生存率为91%(95%CI 74至97),无摩擦音患者为90%(95%CI 71至96),p=0.69。
- 报告摩擦音患者HOOS JR评分为3±3(95%CI 1.5至4.0),无摩擦音患者为3±5(95%CI 1.5至5.5),p=0.59。
关键数值与推荐
- 摩擦音定义为患者通过问卷或电话访谈自我报告的髋关节置换 audible「squeaking」。
- HOOS JR原始总分范围0(完美髋关节健康)至24(完全髋关节残疾)。
- 以任何原因翻修为终点,采用Kaplan-Meier分析比较摩擦音组与无摩擦音组生存率。
- 证据等级为III级,治疗性研究。
临床怎么用
- 对接受陶瓷对陶瓷全髋关节置换的患者,应告知摩擦音可能发生且可能在术后数年出现。
- 使用钛钼锆铁股骨柄时需特别关注摩擦音风险。
- 摩擦音的存在不必然提示功能结果更差或翻修风险更高。
局限性
- 样本量较小,仅62例纳入最终分析。
- 失访率较高(21%)。
- 摩擦音通过问卷或电话自我报告,可能存在回忆偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC) is a durable bearing with excellent wear characteristics, but squeaking remains a concern. The proportion of patients who report squeaking varies widely between studies performed at short- and mid-term follow-up. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What proportion of patients treated with CoC THA bearings report squeaking at a minimum of 10 years of follow-up? (2) Are patient, implant, or radiographic factors associated with squeaking? (3) Are THAs that squeak more likely to be revised than those that do not? (4) Are patient-reported functional outcome scores lower between THAs that squeak and THAs that do not squeak at long-term follow-up? METHODS: Between January 1, 2003 and August 31, 2008 a total of 80 patients received THAs with third-generation alumina-on-alumina bearings at one center. Of the original 80 patients, 1% (1 of 80) had died, and 21% (17 of 80) were lost to follow-up before 10 years, leaving 62 patients for analysis at a median (range) of 14 years (11 to 16). Ceramic-on-ceramic THA represented 23% (80 of 343) of all primary THAs performed during the study period. Ceramic-on-ceramic THA was used preferentially in patients younger than 50 years of age. The mean (range) age of patients in the cohort was 44 ± 11 years (18 to 65). Sixty-eight percent (42 of 62) were men. Two separate manufacturers' implants were included. There were uncemented acetabular and femoral components included in this study. All CoC bearings were third-generation alumina-on-alumina. Squeaking was determined through a mailed questionnaire or telephone interview. The 10-question survey developed by the researchers queried patients whether audible "squeaking" could be heard from their hip replacement. Patients were asked to write in their description of the noise to distinguish squeaking from other noises not relevant to the current study. Implant information, component position, and patient demographics were obtained via chart review and postoperative radiographs reviewed by one of the investigators not involved with the index operative procedure. Using revision for any reason as an endpoint, a Kaplan-Meier analysis was performed to compare survivorship between THAs that squeaked versus those that did not. Patient-reported outcomes were surveyed using the Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score for Joint Replacement (HOOS JR), which comprises six items regarding patient pain and function, raw summed scores range from 0 (perfect hip health) to 24 (total hip disability). RESULTS: Squeaking was self-reported by 53% (33 of 62) of patients in this group. Squeaking was more common in patients who received the titanium-molybdenum-zirconium-iron stem than in patients with the titanium-aluminum-vanadium stem (63% [29 of 46] versus 31% [4 of 13]; odds ratio 3.8 [95% CI 1.02 to 14.4]; p = 0.046). We found no differences in the likelihood a patient would report squeaking based on component position, component size, patient age, sex, or BMI. Ten-year survivorship free from revision was not lower in patients who reported squeaking (91% [95% CI 74 to 97] versus 90% [95% CI 71 to 96]; p = 0.69). Patient-reported outcome scores (HOOS JR) were not lower in those who reported squeaking (3 ± 3 [95% CI 1.5 to 4.0] versus 3 ± 5 [95% CI 1.5 to 5.5]; p = 0.59). CONCLUSION: At long-term follow-up, we found that CoC bearing squeaking in patients who underwent THA is more common than previously reported. Survivorship was lower than expected in this cohort, and most revisions in this series were for squeaking. Although implant-dependent, surgeons should counsel patients about the potential for squeaking in CoC THA, which may occur years after index procedure. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Taniguchi K, Quacinella M, Barlow B, et al. Squeaking Is Common and Increases Over Time Among Patients With Long-term Follow-up After Ceramic-on-ceramic THA. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 33724977. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001472
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。