运动员琼斯骨折手术治疗后重返赛场与骨折愈合的系统综述与Meta分析
该Meta分析纳入22项研究共646例运动员琼斯骨折,评估手术与非手术治疗后的重返赛场(RTP)率、RTP时间、愈合率及并发症。总体RTP率为98.4%,手术组(髓内螺钉固定)RTP率98.8%、时间9.6周,均显著优于非手术组(RTP率71.6%、时间13.1周)。手术组愈合率97.3%亦高于非手术组71.4%。推荐对所有运动员琼斯骨折行手术固定。
要点
- 运动员琼斯骨折术后总体重返赛场率高达98.4%,髓内螺钉固定组为98.8%。
- 髓内螺钉固定RTP时间9.6周,显著短于非手术组的13.1周。
- 手术组愈合率97.3%,非手术组71.4%;总体再骨折率10.2%。
核心结论
- 运动员琼斯骨折手术治疗后重返赛场率和时间均优异,不受植入物类型和运动项目影响。
- 髓内螺钉固定优于非手术治疗,体现在更高的RTP率、更短的RTP时间、更高的愈合率、更短的愈合时间及更好的功能结果。
- 推荐对所有运动员琼斯骨折行手术固定。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入22项仅针对运动员第五跖骨琼斯骨折的研究,共646例骨折。
主要发现
- 总体RTP率为98.4%(95%CI,97.3%-99.4%),626/646例骨折。
- 髓内螺钉固定RTP率98.8%(95%CI,97.8%-99.7%),其他手术固定方法98.4%(95%CI,95.8%-100.0%),非手术管理71.6%(95%CI,45.6%-97.6%)。
- 3项研究直接比较手术与非手术,手术显著优于非手术(OR,0.033 [95%CI,0.005-0.215];P < .001)。
- 按运动类型RTP率:足球99.0%(95%CI,97.5%-100.0%),篮球91.1%(95%CI,82.2%-99.4%),英式足球96.6%(95%CI,92.6%-100.0%)。
- 总体RTP时间9.6周(95%CI,8.5-10.7周);手术组(髓内螺钉固定)9.6周(95%CI,8.3-10.9周),非手术组13.1周(95%CI,8.2-18.0周)。
关键数值与推荐
- 推荐对所有运动员琼斯骨折行手术固定。
- 髓内螺钉固定RTP率98.8%(95%CI,97.8%-99.7%),RTP时间9.6周(95%CI,8.3-10.9周),愈合率97.3%(95%CI,95.1%-99.4%),愈合时间8.2周(95%CI,7.5-9.0周)。
- 非手术管理RTP率71.6%(95%CI,45.6%-97.6%),RTP时间13.1周(95%CI,8.2-18.0周),愈合率71.4%(95%CI,49.1%-93.7%),愈合时间13.7周(95%CI,12.7-14.6周)。
- 手术与非手术直接比较的OR为0.033(95%CI,0.005-0.215),P < .001,支持手术。
临床怎么用
- 对运动员琼斯骨折应优先考虑手术固定,尤其是髓内螺钉固定,以加快重返赛场和骨折愈合。
- 术后重返赛场时间可预期在9-10周左右,愈合时间约8周。
- 需告知运动员再骨折风险约10.2%,延迟愈合风险约2.5%。
局限性
- 原文未报告Meta分析的异质性、发表偏倚及纳入研究的方法学质量评价结果。
- 非手术组样本量较小,RTP率和愈合率的置信区间较宽。
- 原文未报告不同手术固定方式间的直接比较数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Proximal fifth metatarsal fractures are among the most common forefoot injuries in athletes. The management of this injury can be challenging because of delayed union and refractures. Intramedullary (IM) screw fixation rather than nonoperative management has been recommended in the athletic population. PURPOSE: To provide an updated summary of the return-to-play (RTP) rate and time to RTP after Jones fractures in athletes with regard to their management, whether operative or nonoperative, and to explore the union rate and time to union as well as the rate of complications such as refractures. STUDY DESIGN: Meta-analysis. METHODS: Following the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines, 2 independent team members searched several databases including PubMed, MEDLINE, Embase, Google Scholar, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, and ClinicalTrials.gov through November 2019 to identify studies reporting on Jones fractures of the fifth metatarsal exclusively in athletes. The primary outcomes were the RTP rate and time to RTP, whereas the secondary outcomes were the number of games missed, time to union, and union rate as well as the rates of nonunion, delayed union, and refractures. RESULTS: Of 168 studies identified, 22 studies were eligible for meta-analysis with a total of 646 Jones fractures. The overall RTP rate was 98.4% (95% CI, 97.3%-99.4%) in 626 of 646 Jones fractures. The RTP rate with IM screw fixation only was 98.8% (95% CI, 97.8%-99.7%), with other surgical fixation methods (plate, Minifix) was 98.4% (95% CI, 95.8%-100.0%), and with nonoperative management was 71.6% (95% CI, 45.6%-97.6%). There were 3 studies directly comparing RTP rates with surgical versus nonoperative management, which showed significant superiority in favor of surgery (odds ratio, 0.033 [95% CI, 0.005-0.215]; P < .001). The RTP rate according to type of sport was 99.0% (95% CI, 97.5%-100.0%) in football, 91.1% (95% CI, 82.2%-99.4%) in basketball, and 96.6% (95% CI, 92.6%-100.0%) in soccer. The overall time to RTP was 9.6 weeks (95% CI, 8.5-10.7 weeks). The time to RTP in the surgical group (IM screw fixation) was 9.6 weeks (95% CI, 8.3-10.9 weeks), which was significantly less than that in the nonoperative group of 13.1 weeks (95% CI, 8.2-18.0 weeks). The pooled union rate in the operative group (excluding refractures) was 97.3% (95% CI, 95.1%-99.4%), whereas the pooled union rate in the nonoperative group was 71.4% (95% CI, 49.1%-93.7%). The overall time to union was 9.1 weeks (95% CI, 7.7-10.4 weeks). The time to union with IM screw fixation (8.2 weeks [95% CI, 7.5-9.0 weeks]) was shorter than that with nonoperative treatment (13.7 weeks [95% CI, 12.7-14.6 weeks]). The rate of delayed union was 2.5% (95% CI, 1.2%-3.7%), and the overall refracture rate was 10.2% (95% CI, 5.9%-14.5%). CONCLUSION: The RTP rate and time to RTP after the surgical management of Jones fractures in athletes were excellent, regardless of the implant used and type of sport. IM screw fixation was superior to nonoperative management, as it led to a higher rate of RTP, shorter time to RTP, higher rate of union, shorter time to union, and improved functional outcomes. We recommend surgical fixation for all Jones fractures in athletes.
引用
- Attia AK, Taha T, Kong G, et al. Return to Play and Fracture Union After the Surgical Management of Jones Fractures in Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2021. PMID: 33740393. doi:10.1177/0363546521990020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。