文献速递手外科与足踝外科

临床医生因素而非患者因素影响治疗方案讨论

Clinician Factors Rather Than Patient Factors Affect Discussion of Treatment Options.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Orthop Relat Res · 2021-01-01

该研究基于荷兰与美国两个队列共123次手外科门诊录音,评估患者健康素养与临床医生沟通效果的关系。结果显示健康素养与沟通效果无关,而就诊时长和不同临床医生与沟通效果独立相关,医生沟通策略可解释29%的变异。

要点

  • 患者健康素养与临床医生沟通效果和努力无相关性。
  • 较长就诊时长和特定临床医生与更有效沟通独立相关。
  • 临床医生沟通策略解释29%的沟通效果变异。

核心结论

  • 整体沟通效果和努力均值较低且在不同临床医生间存在差异,不受患者健康素养等患者因素影响。
  • 临床医生可能受益于培训,从教导或说教风格转向使用动机性访谈的引导式沟通风格。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性横断面队列研究,合并荷兰城市社区医院86次录音就诊与美国三级医院72次录音就诊,最终分析123例患者(荷兰68例,美国55例)。
  • 使用Newest Vital Sign(NVS)评估患者健康素养,使用5条目Observing Patient Involvement(OPTION5)评估沟通效果和努力,并采用多变量线性回归分析相关因素。

主要发现

  • 健康素养与临床医生沟通效果和努力无相关性(r=0.087 [95% CI -0.09至0.26];p=0.34)。
  • 健康素养不足组与充足组的沟通效果均值差异为1.0(95% CI -2.6至0.54;p=0.20),无统计学意义。
  • 控制混杂变量后,就诊时长每增加1分钟(r2=0.31 [95% CI -0.14至0.48];p<0.001)、临床医生3(对比临床医生1:OR 33 [95% CI 4.8至229];p<0.001)和临床医生5(对比临床医生1:OR 11 [95% CI 1.5至80];p<0.02)与更有效沟通和努力独立相关。
  • 临床医生6与更差沟通效果独立相关(对比临床医生1:OR 0.08 [95% CI 0.01至0.75];p=0.03)。
  • 临床医生沟通策略解释29%的沟通效果变异,较长就诊时长解释11%,全模型解释47%(p<0.001)。

关键数值与推荐

  • OPTION5总分范围0至20分,评分越高表示患者参与决策的沟通质量越好。
  • NVS健康素养评分范围0至6分,0为低健康素养,6为高健康素养。
  • 两名独立评分者一致性kappa值为0.8(强一致)。

临床怎么用

  • 骨科智能体医生应关注自身沟通策略而非仅根据患者健康素养调整沟通方式。
  • 可尝试采用引导式沟通(如动机性访谈)替代教导或说教风格,以促进患者参与决策。
  • 适当延长就诊时长可能有助于提升沟通效果和患者参与度。

局限性

  • 研究为观察性设计,不能确定因果关系。
  • 样本来自荷兰与美国两个中心的手外科门诊,外推至其他骨科亚专业需谨慎。
  • 美国队列为既往研究的二次数据使用,可能存在信息偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Shared decision-making aims to combine what matters most to a patient with clinician expertise to develop a personalized health strategy. It is a dialogue between patient and clinician in which preferences are expressed, misconceptions reoriented, and available options are considered. To improve patient involvement, it would help to know more about specific barriers and facilitators of patient-clinician communication. Health literacy, the ability to obtain, process, and understand health information, may affect patient participation in decision-making. If the patient is quiet, deferential, and asks few questions, the clinician may assume a more paternalistic style. A patient with greater agency and engagement could be the catalyst for shared decisions. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We assessed (1) whether effective clinician communication and effort is related to patient health literacy, and (2) if there are other factors associated with effective clinician communication and effort. METHODS: We combined a prospective, cross-sectional cohort of 86 audio-recorded visits of adult patients seeking specialist hand care for a new problem at an urban community hospital in the Netherlands with a cohort of 72 audio-recorded hand surgery visits from a tertiary hospital in the United States collected for a prior study. The American cohort represents a secondary use of data from a set of patients from a separate study using audio-recorded visits and administering similar questionnaires that assessed different endpoints. In both cohorts, adult patients seeking specialist hand care for a new problem were screened. In total, 165 patients were initially screened, of which 96% (158) participated. Eight percent (13) of visits were excluded since the final diagnosis remained unclear, 8% (12) since it was not the first consultation for the current problem, 5% (8) in which only one treatment option was available, and < 1% (1) since there was a language barrier. A total of 123 patients were analyzed, 68 from the Netherlands and 55 from the United States. The Newest Vital Sign (NVS) health literacy test, validated in both English and Dutch, measures the ability to use health information and is based on a nutrition label from an ice cream container. It was used to assess patient health literacy on a scale ranging from 0 (low) to 6 (high). The 5-item Observing Patient Involvement (OPTION5) instrument is commonly used to assess the quality of patient-clinician discussion of options. Scores may be influenced by clinician effort to involve patients in decision-making as well as patient engagement and agency. Each item is scored from 0 (no effort) to 4 (maximum effort), with a total maximum score of 20. Two independent raters reached agreement (kappa value 0.8; strong agreement), after which all recordings were scored by one investigator. Visit duration and patient questions were assessed using the audio recordings. Patients had a median (interquartile range) age of 54 (38 to 66) years, 50% were men, 89% were white, 66% had a nontraumatic diagnosis, median (IRQ) years of education was 16 (12 to 18) years, and median (IQR) health literacy score was 5 (2 to 6). Median (IQR) visit duration was 9 (7 to 12) minutes. Cohorts did not differ in important ways. The number of visits per clinician ranged from 14 to 29, and the mean overall communication effectiveness and effort score for the visits was low (8.5 ± 4.2 points of 20 points). A multivariate linear regression model was used to assess factors associated with communication effectiveness and effort. RESULTS: There was no correlation between health literacy and clinician communication effectiveness and effort (r = 0.087 [95% CI -0.09 to 0.26]; p = 0.34), nor was there a difference in means (SD) when categorizing health literacy as inadequate (7.8 ± 3.8 points) and adequate (8.9 ± 4.5 points; mean difference 1.0 [95% CI -2.6 to 0.54]; p = 0.20). After controlling for potential confounding variables such as gender, patient questions, and health literacy, we found that longer visit duration (per 1 minute increase: r2 = 0.31 [95% CI -0.14 to 0.48]; p < 0.001), clinician 3 (compared with clinician 1: OR 33 [95% CI 4.8 to 229]; p < 0.001) and clinician 5 (compared with clinician 1: OR 11 [95% CI 1.5 to 80]; p = < 0.02) were independently associated with more effective communication and effort, whereas clinician 6 was associated with less effective communication and effort (compared with clinician 1: OR 0.08 [95% CI 0.01 to 0.75]; p = 0.03). Clinicians' communication strategies (the clinician variable on its own) accounted for 29% of the variation in communication effectiveness and effort, longer visit duration accounted for 11%, and the full model accounted for 47% of the variation (p < 0.001). CONCLUSION: The finding that the overall low mean communication effectiveness and effort differed between clinicians and was not influenced by patient factors including health literacy suggests clinicians may benefit from training that moves them away from a teaching or lecturing style where patients receive rote directives regarding their health. Clinicians can learn to adapt their communication to specific patient values and needs using a guiding rather than directing communication style (motivational interviewing).Level of Evidence Level II, prognostic study.

来源:Clin Orthop Relat Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. van Hoorn BT, van Rossenberg LX, Jacobs X, et al. Clinician Factors Rather Than Patient Factors Affect Discussion of Treatment Options. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 33626027. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001664

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。