开放与内镜下腕管松解术的成本效益分析
该研究基于已发表的荟萃分析数据构建马尔可夫模型,比较内镜下腕管松解术(ECTR)与开放腕管松解术(OCTR)的成本效益。从社会视角看,ECTR因返工更早而成本更低且QALY略高;从支付方视角看,ECTR仅在诊室局部麻醉下实施时才具有成本效益。
要点
- 社会视角下ECTR成本更低且QALY增加0.00141,但结果对术后误工天数敏感。
- 支付方视角下,诊室ECTR相比诊室OCTR的ICER为76,000美元/QALY。
- 支付方视角下,手术室ECTR相比诊室OCTR的ICER约1,332,000美元/QALY。
核心结论
- 从社会视角看,ECTR因返工更早而成本更低,并带来更高的QALYs。
- 从支付方视角看,ECTR更昂贵,仅在诊室局部麻醉下实施时才具有成本效益。
研究设计与样本
- 研究构建马尔可夫模型,比较单侧腕管松解术采用OCTR与ECTR的成本效益。
- 模型设定诊室局部麻醉和手术室监测麻醉护理两种场景。
- 采用终身时间跨度,模拟社会视角(50岁患者)和Medicare支付方视角(65岁患者)。
- 进行确定性和概率敏感性分析(PSA)。
主要发现
- ECTR相比OCTR额外获得0.00141个QALY。
- 社会视角下,假设ECTR术后比OCTR少误工8.21天,ECTR在所有手术场景下成本均更低。
- 结果对术后误工天数敏感。
- 支付方视角下,手术室ECTR比诊室OCTR成本高1,872美元,ICER约1,332,000美元/QALY。
- 支付方视角下,手术室ECTR比手术室OCTR成本高654美元,ICER为464,000美元/QALY。
关键数值与推荐
- 支付方视角下,诊室ECTR比诊室OCTR成本高107美元,ICER为76,000美元/QALY。
- 支付方视角下,在100,000美元/QALY的支付意愿阈值下,PSA迭代中77%的情况下诊室OCTR优于手术室ECTR。
- 社会视角下,PSA迭代中61%的情况下手术室ECTR优于诊室OCTR。
- 证据等级为经济与决策分析I级。
临床怎么用
- 从社会视角,ECTR因返工更早而可能节省成本,但需结合当代返工实践进一步确认。
- 从支付方视角,ECTR宜在诊室局部麻醉下实施以具备成本效益。
局限性
- 社会视角下ECTR成本更低的结果依赖于假设的术后误工天数差异(8.21天),结果对该参数敏感。
- 需基于当代返工实践进一步研究以确认返工相关发现。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Carpal tunnel syndrome is the most common upper-extremity nerve compression syndrome. Over 500,000 carpal tunnel release (CTR) procedures are performed in the U.S. yearly. We estimated the cost-effectiveness of endoscopic CTR (ECTR) versus open CTR (OCTR) using data from published meta-analyses comparing outcomes for ECTR and OCTR. METHODS: We developed a Markov model to examine the cost-effectiveness of OCTR versus ECTR for patients undergoing unilateral CTR in an office setting under local anesthesia and in an operating-room (OR) setting under monitored anesthesia care. The main outcomes were costs, quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs), and incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs). We modeled societal (modeled with a 50-year-old patient) and Medicare payer (modeled with a 65-year-old patient) perspectives, adopting a lifetime time horizon. We performed deterministic and probabilistic sensitivity analyses (PSAs). RESULTS: ECTR resulted in 0.00141 additional QALY compared with OCTR. From a societal perspective, assuming 8.21 fewer days of work missed after ECTR than after OCTR, ECTR cost less across all procedure settings. The results are sensitive to the number of days of work missed following surgery. From a payer perspective, ECTR in the OR (ECTROR) cost $1,872 more than OCTR in the office (OCTRoffice), for an ICER of approximately $1,332,000/QALY. The ECTROR cost $654 more than the OCTROR, for an ICER of $464,000/QALY. The ECTRoffice cost $107 more than the OCTRoffice, for an ICER of $76,000/QALY. From a payer perspective, for a willingness-to-pay threshold of $100,000/QALY, OCTRoffice was preferred over ECTROR in 77% of the PSA iterations. From a societal perspective, ECTROR was preferred over OCTRoffice in 61% of the PSA iterations. CONCLUSIONS: From a societal perspective, ECTR is associated with lower costs as a result of an earlier return to work and leads to higher QALYs. Additional research on return to work is needed to confirm these findings on the basis of contemporary return-to-work practices. From a payer perspective, ECTR is more expensive and is cost-effective only if performed in an office setting under local anesthesia. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Economic and Decision Analysis Level I. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
引用
- Barnes JI, Paci G, Zhuang T, et al. Cost-Effectiveness of Open Versus Endoscopic Carpal Tunnel Release. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2021. PMID: 33591684. doi:10.2106/JBJS.19.01354
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。