桡骨头手术治疗对肘部恐怖三联征结局至关重要
该研究随访88例肘部恐怖三联征患者平均4.5年,评估桡骨头治疗方式对临床和影像学结局的影响。结果显示,采用标准化方案可获良好肘关节稳定性和功能,但桡骨头置换术(RHA)组结局显著劣于重建组,尤其在Mason III型骨折中,RHA无 apparent 优势,推荐在可稳定固定时选择重建。
要点
- 桡骨头置换术(RHA)组在肘关节功能、关节炎发生率和术后并发症方面显著劣于重建组。
- Mason III型骨折中,成功重建桡骨头者结局更优,RHA无 apparent 优势。
- 总体再手术率为24%,其中ORIF 9例、RHA 10例、未处理桡骨头2例需翻修。
核心结论
- 采用标准化方案,大多数恐怖三联征可获得足够肘关节稳定性和良好结局。
- 桡骨头治疗方式可能独立影响结局,RHA组结局显著劣于重建组。
- Mason III型骨折中RHA无 apparent 优势,推荐在可稳定固定时选择重建。
研究设计与样本
- 对88例恐怖三联征患者进行随访评估,其中女性48例、男性40例,平均年龄57岁(18至82岁)。
- 随访时间平均4.5年(2.0至9.4年),评估MEPS、OES和DASH评分,并分析所有患者X线片。
- 骨折类型包括Mason I型13例、II型16例、III型59例;II型和可重建III型行ORIF,无法重建者行RHA。
主要发现
- 末次随访平均MEPS为87.1(20至100),平均OES为36.9(6至48),平均DASH评分为18.6(0至90)。
- 平均活动度:伸屈为118°(30°至150°),旋前旋后为162°(90°至180°)。
- 总体再手术率为24%,其中ORIF 9例、RHA 10例、未处理桡骨头2例需手术翻修。
- RHA治疗的Mason III型骨折结局显著较差;末次X线片显示退变或异位骨化者结果欠佳。
- Mason III型骨折中成功重建桡骨头者结局更 favorable。
关键数值与推荐
- Mason II型和可重建的III型骨折行切开复位内固定(ORIF),无法重建时行桡骨头置换术(RHA)。
- RHA组在肘关节功能、关节炎发生率和术后并发症方面显著劣于重建组。
- Mason III型骨折中RHA与重建组之间无 apparent 优势差异,推荐在可稳定固定时选择重建。
临床怎么用
- 对恐怖三联征患者,应优先尝试桡骨头重建(ORIF),仅在无法稳定固定时考虑RHA。
- Mason III型骨折若可成功重建,应避免RHA,因其结局显著较差。
- 术后需关注再手术风险(总体24%),尤其RHA和未处理桡骨头者。
局限性
- 治疗分配存在偏倚,更严重损伤被分配至RHA组,不能完全排除。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: To evaluate the outcomes of terrible triad injuries (TTIs) in mid-term follow-up and determine whether surgical treatment of the radial head influences clinical and radiological outcomes. METHODS: Follow-up assessment of 88 patients with TTI (48 women, 40 men; mean age 57 years (18 to 82)) was performed after a mean of 4.5 years (2.0 to 9.4). The Mayo Elbow Performance Score (MEPS), Oxford Elbow Score (OES), and Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH) score were evaluated. Radiographs of all patients were analyzed. Fracture types included 13 Mason type I, 16 type II, and 59 type III. Surgical treatment consisted of open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) in all type II and reconstructable type III fractures, while radial head arthroplasty (RHA) was performed if reconstruction was not possible. RESULTS: At follow-up the mean MEPS was 87.1 (20 to 100); mean OES, 36.9 (6 to 48); and mean DASH score, 18.6 (0 to 90). Mean movement was 118° (30° to 150°) for extension to flexion and 162° (90° to 180°) for pronation to supination. The overall reoperation rate was 24%, with nine ORIF, ten RHA, and two patients without treatment to the radial head needing surgical revision. When treated with RHA, Mason type III fractures exhibited significantly inferior outcomes. Suboptimal results were also identified in patients with degenerative or heterotopic changes on their latest radiograph. In contrast, more favourable outcomes were detected in patients with successful radial head reconstruction after Mason type III fractures. CONCLUSION: Using a standardized protocol, sufficient elbow stability and good outcomes can be achieved in most TTIs. Although some bias in treatment allocation, with more severe injuries assigned to RHA, cannot be completely omitted, treatment of radial head fractures may have an independent effect on outcome, as patients subjected to RHA showed significantly inferior results compared to those subjected to reconstruction, in terms of elbow function, incidence of arthrosis, and postoperative complications. As RHA showed no apparent advantage in Mason type III injuries between the two treatment groups, we recommend reconstruction, providing stable fixation can be achieved. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(12):1620-1628.
引用
- Klug A, Nagy A, Gramlich Y, et al. Surgical treatment of the radial head is crucial for the outcome in terrible triad injuries of the elbow. Bone Joint J. 2020. PMID: 33249911. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.102B12.BJJ-2020-0762.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。