模压伽马辐照氩气处理聚乙烯在旋转铰链膝巨假体中的失效风险低于气灭菌机加工棒材
单中心回顾性研究224例股骨远端巨假体患者,比较两种聚乙烯制造工艺。竞争风险分析显示,模压伽马辐照氩气处理聚乙烯(P2)因磨损或断裂导致翻修的风险低于气灭菌机加工棒材聚乙烯(P1),120个月时绝对风险降低17%。但P2组10年时仍有7%患者因聚乙烯损坏翻修。
要点
- 模压伽马辐照氩气处理聚乙烯较气灭菌机加工棒材聚乙烯的翻修风险更低。
- 120个月时绝对风险降低17%(95%CI 6.15至27.9)。
- 即使改进聚乙烯,10年时仍有7%患者因聚乙烯损坏翻修。
核心结论
- 模压伽马辐照氩气处理聚乙烯组因聚乙烯损坏导致翻修的风险低于气灭菌机加工棒材聚乙烯组。
- 尽管制造工艺改进,10年时仍有7%患者因聚乙烯损坏而翻修,需进一步改进并监测。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、观察性、回顾性比较研究,纳入1993至2015年224例股骨远端巨假体患者。
- P1组66例使用气灭菌机加工棒材聚乙烯,P2组158例使用模压伽马辐照氩气处理聚乙烯。
- 采用Fine-Gray竞争风险模型计算因聚乙烯磨损或断裂导致翻修的风险比。
主要发现
- P1组平均随访89±55个月,P2组79±63个月,两组无差异(p=0.24)。
- P1组27%(18/66)和P2组25%(40/158)随访超过10年。
- P1组失访5.7%(4/70),P2组9.2%(16/174),无统计学差异(p=0.37)。
- 120个月时P1组翻修风险比0.24(95%CI 0.13至0.36),P2组0.07(95%CI 0.03至0.12)。
- 估计绝对风险降低17%(95%CI 6.15至27.9)。
关键数值与推荐
- 翻修定义为聚乙烯断裂、内外翻应力下活动度增加或新发锁定或打软腿。
- 使用Fine-Gray子分布风险模型进行竞争风险分析。
临床怎么用
- 优先选用模压伽马辐照氩气处理聚乙烯的巨假体以降低聚乙烯损坏翻修风险。
- 对接受巨假体患者仍需监测聚乙烯损坏的体征和症状。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性观察性研究,证据等级为III级。
- P2组失访率(9.2%)高于P1组(5.7%),但无统计学差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Megaprostheses are commonly used for reconstruction after distal femoral resection in orthopaedic oncology. The polyethylene bearings in these reconstructions experience wear and wear-related complications that may result in revision surgery. Improved manufacturing and processing of polyethylene has increased the durability of components commonly used for routine arthroplasty. Alterations in the manufacture of polyethylene is expected to reduce the revision risk of oncologic megaprostheses, resulting in fewer revision procedures, but this has not been proven. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Is there a difference in the hazard of polyethylene wear or breakage leading to prosthetic revision between differences in polyethylene manufacture and processing based on a competing risk analysis? METHODS: This was a single-center, observational, retrospective comparative study of 224 patients who had distal femur megaprostheses with identical rotating hinge articulations and knee kinematics after oncologic surgery from 1993 to 2015. No differences in surgical indications, joint articular components and kinematics, age, sex, diagnosis, BMI, use of chemotherapy, or tumor stage were seen with the patient numbers available. Prosthetic survivorship free from prosthetic revision surgery because of polyethylene wear-related revisions, defined as breakage, increased excursion on varus-valgus stress, or new locking or giving way was compared between two groups of patients: group 1 polyethylene (P1) (66 patients) who had air-sterilized machined ram-extruded bar stock or group 2 polyethylene (P2) (158 patients) molded gamma-radiated argon-processed polyethylene components. The mean follow-up duration for the P1 group (89 ± 55 months) was not different from that of patients with P2 polyethylene (79 ± 63 months; p = 0.24) including 27% (18 of 66) of patients in the P1 group and 25% (40 of 158) of patients in the P2 group followed for more than 10 years. More patients in the P2 group were lost to follow-up (9.2%, 16 of 174) than in the P1 group (5.7%, 4 of 70) but this was not statistically different (chi square; p = 0.37). The hazard of revision because of polyethylene wear or breakage was calculated with a competing risk analysis using the Fine-Gray subdistribution hazard model. RESULTS: The P1 implants had a higher hazard ratio for revision caused by polyethylene damage at 120 months than did the P2 polyethylene implants (P1 HR 0.24 [95% CI 0.13 to 0.36] versus HR 0.07 [95% CI 0.03 to 0.12]), which represents an estimated absolute risk reduction of 17% (95% CI 6.15 to 27.9). CONCLUSION: Polyethylene damage can result in megaprosthetic revisions in patients undergoing oncologic procedures. The hazard of polyethylene failure resulting in revision surgery was lower in patients who received recent polyethylene than in patients with polyethylene produced by previous methods, enhancing the durability of distal femoral megaprosthetic reconstructions. Despite improvements in polyethylene manufacture and clinical results, revision solely because of polyethylene damage still occurs in 7% of patients by the 10-year timepoint; thus, more improvement is needed. Patients who receive these implants should be monitored for signs and symptoms of polyethylene damage. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, therapeutic study.
引用
- Belzarena AC, Elalfy MA, Yakoub MA, et al. Molded, Gamma-radiated, Argon-processed Polyethylene Components of Rotating Hinge Knee Megaprostheses Have a Lower Failure Hazard and Revision Rates Than Air-sterilized, Machined, Ram-extruded Bar Stock Components. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 33369586. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001439
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。