15°外翻冠状面畸形应否作为全踝关节置换的上限?
本研究匹配比较了术前踝关节冠状面胫距外翻≥15°与<15°患者行全踝关节置换(TAA)的手术方式和临床结局。结果显示两组患者的中期临床评分均显著改善且改善幅度相似,但外翻≥15°组术中辅助手术和术后二次手术更多。因此,冠状面外翻≥15°并非TAA的绝对禁忌证,但需处理相关畸形。
要点
- 术前冠状面外翻≥15°患者TAA术后中期临床评分改善与<15°患者相似。
- 外翻≥15°患者术中辅助手术(80% vs 26%)和术后二次手术(36% vs 14%)更多。
- 外翻≥15°不是TAA绝对禁忌证,但需处理相关畸形。
核心结论
- 术前踝关节冠状面外翻≥15°患者行TAA可获得满意中期结果,但需更多辅助手术。
- 冠状面外翻≥15°并非TAA的绝对禁忌证,前提是相关畸形得到处理。
研究设计与样本
- 匹配队列研究,比较术前冠状面胫距外翻≥15°(外翻组,n=50)与<15°(对照组,n=50)行TAA的患者。
- 所有手术由同一名外科医生完成,两组人口学资料和假体组件相似。
- 前瞻性收集术前和术后X线片、AOS疼痛与残疾评分及SF-36版本2评分。
主要发现
- 平均随访5.1年(外翻组,SD 2.6)和6.6年(对照组,SD 3.3),两组AOS评分均下降、SF-36评分均显著提高。
- 两组评分改善程度相似:AOS疼痛外翻组平均26.2分(SD 24.2),对照组平均22.3分(SD 26.4)。
- AOS残疾外翻组平均41.2分(SD 25.6),对照组平均34.6分(SD 24.3);SF-36 PCS外翻组平均9.1分(SD 14.1),对照组平均7.4分(SD 9.8)。
- 外翻组术中辅助手术更多(40例(80%)vs 13例(26%)),术后二次手术更多(18例(36%)vs 7例(14%))。
- 外翻组胫距畸形显著改善(p < 0.001)趋向正常负重轴;外翻组3例、对照组4例需后续融合,其中2例因深部感染(每组各1例)。
关键数值与推荐
- 术前冠状面胫距外翻≥15°曾被视为TAA禁忌证,本研究对此提出挑战。
- 外翻组术中辅助手术40例(80%),对照组13例(26%)。
- 外翻组术后二次手术18例(36%),对照组7例(14%)。
- 外翻组胫距畸形改善显著(p < 0.001)。
临床怎么用
- 对术前冠状面外翻≥15°的患者,TAA可作为选项而非绝对禁忌,但应预期更多术中辅助操作和术后二次手术。
- 术前需仔细评估并计划处理相关畸形,与患者充分沟通额外手术风险。
局限性
- 样本量有限(每组50例),随访时间不一致(外翻组平均5.1年,对照组6.6年)。
- 为单外科医生手术的匹配队列研究,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Preoperative talar valgus deformity ≥ 15° is considered a contraindication for total ankle arthroplasty (TAA). We compared operative procedures and clinical outcomes of TAA in patients with talar valgus deformity ≥ 15° and < 15°. METHODS: A matched cohort of patients similar for demographics and components used but differing in preoperative coronal-plane tibiotalar valgus deformity ≥ 15° (valgus, n = 50; 52% male, mean age 65.8 years (SD 10.3), mean body mass index (BMI) 29.4 (SD 5.2)) or < 15° (control, n = 50; 58% male, mean age 65.6 years (SD 9.8), mean BMI 28.7 (SD 4.2)), underwent TAA by one surgeon. Preoperative and postoperative radiographs, Ankle Osteoarthritis Scale (AOS) pain and disability and 36-item Short Form Health Survey (SF-36) version 2 scores were collected prospectively. Ancillary procedures, secondary procedures, and complications were recorded. RESULTS: At mean 5.1 years follow-up (SD 2.6) (valgus) and 6.6 years (SD 3.3) (controls), mean AOS scores decreased and SF-36 scores increased significantly in both groups. Improvements in scores were similar for both groups - AOS pain: valgus, mean 26.2 points (SD 24.2), controls, mean 22.3 points (SD 26.4); AOS disability: valgus, mean 41.2 points (SD 25.6); controls, mean 34.6 points (SD 24.3); and SF-36 PCS: valgus, mean 9.1 points (SD 14.1), controls, mean 7.4 points (SD 9.8). Valgus ankles underwent more ancillary procedures during TAA (40 (80%) vs 13 (26%)) and more secondary procedures postoperatively (18 (36%) vs 7 (14%)) than controls. Tibiotalar deformity improved significantly (p < 0.001) towards a normal weightbearing axis in valgus ankles. Three valgus and four control ankles required subsequent fusion, including two for deep infections (one in each group). CONCLUSION: Satisfactory mid-term results were achieved in patients with preoperative valgus malalignment ≥ 15°, but they required more adjunctive procedures during and after TAA. Valgus coronal-plane deformity ≥ 15° is not an absolute contraindication for TAA if associated deformities are addressed. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(12):1689-1696.
引用
- Halai MM, Pinsker E, Mann MA, et al. Should 15° of valgus coronal-plane deformity be the upper limit for a total ankle arthroplasty? Bone Joint J. 2020. PMID: 33249899. doi:10.1302/0301-620X.102B12.BJJ-2020-0140.R1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。