风险认知:美国髋膝关节外科医师协会会员民意调查
2019年对美国髋膝关节外科医师协会2800名会员进行匿名调查,回收474份回复。调查发现,竞争性质量/成本绩效指标促使医生关注可调整的医学风险因素,但因缺乏社会经济风险调整,多数医生感到压力而限制对社会支持有限、低收入等患者提供手术,导致医疗可及性差距。
要点
- 95%的医生在择期髋/膝关节置换术前处理可调整风险因素。
- 83%的医生因缺乏社会经济风险调整而感到压力,避免或限制某些患者手术。
- 93%的医生预测更合理的风险调整将增加医疗可及性。
核心结论
- 竞争性质量/成本绩效指标影响医生在提供下肢关节置换时关注医学风险因素,缺乏社会经济风险调整导致医生感知额外风险,造成特定医学和社会经济阶层患者医疗可及性边缘性丧失,加剧现有医疗差距,这是竞争性绩效指标的非预期后果。
研究设计与样本
- 2019年通过Survey Monkey向美国髋膝关节外科医师协会2800名外科会员发送匿名/保密民意调查,询问对风险调整的医学合并症和社会经济风险因素是否影响选择性提供手术的感知。
主要发现
- 共474名外科医生回复。
- 择期全髋/全膝关节置换术前,95%处理可调整风险因素;52%要求体重指数<40,64%要求戒烟,96%要求糖化血红蛋白达标,82%检查营养,63%期望控制酒精。
- 因缺乏社会经济风险调整,83%报告感到压力避免/限制社会支持有限患者,具体包括医疗补助/保险不足81%、非裔美国人29%、西班牙裔/其他族裔27%、低社会经济地位73%。
- 93%的受访者预测更适当的风险调整将增加医疗可及性。
关键数值与推荐
- 择期全髋/全膝关节置换术前,52%的医生要求体重指数<40。
- 64%的医生要求戒烟。
- 96%的医生要求糖化血红蛋白达标。
- 82%的医生检查营养。
- 63%的医生期望控制酒精。
临床怎么用
- 骨科智能体医生应了解竞争性绩效指标可能促使医生选择性提供手术,需关注风险调整对医疗公平性的影响。
- 在临床决策中,应平衡医学风险因素管理与社会经济风险因素,避免因缺乏风险调整而加剧医疗差距。
局限性
- 调查为匿名民意调查,可能存在回复偏倚,且仅代表美国髋膝关节外科医师协会会员的观点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Providers of total hip and knee replacements are being judged regarding quality/cost by payers using competition-based performance measures with poor medical and no socioeconomic risk adjustment. Providers might assume that other providers shed risk and the perception of added risk can influence practice. A poll was collected to examine such perceptions. METHODS: In 2019 a poll was sent to the 2800 surgeon members of the American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons using Survey Monkey while protecting respondent anonymity/confidentiality. The questions asked whether the perception of poorly risk-adjusted medical comorbidities and socioeconomic risk factors influence surgeons to selectively offer surgery. RESULTS: There were 474 surgeon responses. Prior to elective total hip arthroplasty/total knee arthroplasty, 95% address modifiable risk factors; 52% require a body mass index <40, 64% smoking cessation, 96% an adequate hemoglobin A1C; 82% check nutrition; and 63% expect control of alcohol 2. Due to lack of socioeconomic risk adjustment, 83% reported feeling pressure to avoid/restrict access to patients with limited social support, specifically the following: Medicaid/underinsured, 81%; African Americans, 29%; Hispanics/ethnicities, 27%; and low socioeconomic status, 73%. Of the respondents, 93% predicted increased access to care with more appropriate risk adjustment. CONCLUSION: Competition-based quality/cost performance measures influence surgeons to focus on medical risk factors in offering lower extremity arthroplasty. The lack of socioeconomic risk adjustment leads to perceptions of added risk from such factors as well. This leads to marginal loss of access for patients within certain medical and socioeconomic classes, contributing to existing healthcare disparities. This represents an unintended consequence of competition-based performance measures.
引用
- Yates AJ, Jones LC, Nelson CL, et al. Perception of Risk: A Poll of American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons Members. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 33250329. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.10.059
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。