作者财务利益冲突对机器人辅助关节置换研究的影响
该系统综述纳入54项比较机器人辅助与传统技术行全髋、全膝及单髁膝关节置换的研究,其中49项(91%)存在作者财务利益冲突。有利益冲突的研究更倾向于报告机器人辅助的有利结果,且支持机器人的研究其冲突作者数量及人均行业付款更高。作者认为无利益冲突的进一步研究可能提供无偏结果。
要点
- 54项纳入研究中49项(91%)存在作者财务利益冲突。
- 有利益冲突的研究比无冲突研究更可能报告机器人辅助的有利结果。
- 支持机器人的研究较支持传统技术者冲突作者数更多、人均行业付款更高。
核心结论
- 几乎所有比较机器人辅助全髋、全膝及单髁膝关节置换与传统技术的研究均涉及有财务利益冲突的作者。
- 作者认为无利益冲突的进一步研究可能提供无偏结果。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,识别所有评估机器人用于全髋、全膝及单髁膝关节置换的研究。
- 通过美国骨科医师学会或研究文章中的相关披露确定作者财务利益冲突,并查询Open Payments网站记录发表前一年机器人公司的所有付款。
- 将每项研究分类为支持机器人(n=42)、中立(n=10)或支持传统技术(n=2),比较冲突作者数、期刊影响因子、证据等级及每位作者年均行业付款。
主要发现
- 54项符合纳入标准的研究中,49项(91%)存在作者财务利益冲突。
- 有利益冲突的研究比无冲突研究更可能报告机器人辅助的有利结果。
- 与支持传统技术的研究相比,显示机器人有利结果的研究冲突作者数更多且每位作者平均行业付款更高。
- 证据等级或期刊影响因子无差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recent studies have suggested clinical superiority with robotic-assisted arthroplasty compared to traditional techniques. However, concerns exist regarding the author's financial conflicts of interest (COI), which may influence research outcomes. This study aimed to determine whether COI relating to robotic-assisted arthroplasty influences the results of published outcomes following total hip (THA), total knee (TKA), and unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA). METHODS: We performed a systematic review to identify all studies evaluating the use of robotics in THA, TKA, and UKA. An author's financial COI was identified if they reported a relevant disclosure through the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons or within the study article. We then queried the Open Payments website to record all payments made from a robotic company in the year prior to publication. Each study was categorized as either favoring robotics (n = 42), neutral (n = 10), or favoring traditional techniques (n = 2). We then compared the number of conflicted authors, journal impact factor, level of evidence, and mean annual industry payment to each author. RESULTS: Of the 54 studies meeting inclusion criteria, 49 (91%) had an author financial COI. Conflicted studies were more likely to report favorable results of robotics than nonconflicted studies. When compared to studies favoring conventional techniques, those demonstrating favorable robotics outcomes had a higher number of conflicted authors and a higher mean industry payment per author. There was no difference in the level of evidence or journal impact factor. DISCUSSION: Nearly all studies comparing robotic THA, TKA, and UKA to conventional techniques involve financially conflicted authors. Further studies without COI may provide unbiased results.
引用
- DeFrance MJ, Yayac MF, Courtney PM, et al. The Impact of Author Financial Conflicts on Robotic-Assisted Joint Arthroplasty Research. J Arthroplasty. 2020. PMID: 33199093. doi:10.1016/j.arth.2020.10.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。