短柄与常规长度柄在THA中大腿疼痛或骨丢失无临床重要差异:一项随机临床试验
该随机对照试验纳入100例初次非骨水泥全髋关节置换术患者,比较短柄(n=56)与标准长度柄(n=44)在5年随访中大腿疼痛发生率、改良Harris髋关节评分、假体松动及骨密度方面的差异。结果显示两组大腿疼痛比例无差异(16%对14%,p=0.79),无假体松动或翻修,短柄组在Gruen 2、3、5区骨密度下降略小但差异似乎无临床重要性。作者推荐在一般实践中使用标准长度柄。
要点
- 短柄与标准柄THA术后5年大腿疼痛发生率无差异(16%对14%,p=0.79)。
- 两组均无假体松动或翻修,改良Harris髋关节评分5年均值无显著差异(89±13对95±7分,p=0.06)。
- 短柄组Gruen 2、3、5区骨密度下降略小于标准柄组,但差异似乎无临床重要性。
核心结论
- 在随机试验中,短柄与标准长度柄THA术后5年未发现临床重要差异(总体差异很少)。
- 因此,作者推荐临床医生在一般实践中使用标准长度柄,因为标准长度柄在其他研究中有更长的发表追踪记录,而短柄可能使患者暴露于与新颖性相关的不确定性,且无明显抵消获益。
研究设计与样本
- 2013年3月至2014年1月间,三名外科医生实施了205例初次THA。
- 纳入标准为年龄至少20岁、无既往髋部手术史、无代谢性骨病。
- 共100例患者随机接受短柄THA(n=56)或标准长度柄THA(n=44),两组均为近端涂层、锥形、非骨水泥柄,短柄通常比标准柄短30至35毫米。
- 短柄组73%(41/56)和标准柄组77%(34/44)的患者至少随访5年并纳入分析。
- 主要终点为5年随访期间大腿疼痛发生率,研究把握度80%以检测大腿疼痛比例10%的差异,显著性水平0.05。
主要发现
- 短柄组16%(9/56)和标准柄组14%(6/44)的患者在随访期间出现大腿疼痛(p=0.79)。
- 所有患者疼痛为轻度或中度(VAS评分4或6分)。
- 在15例报告大腿疼痛的患者中,两组平均疼痛严重程度无差异(短柄组4.3±0.8对标准柄组4.2±0.7;p=0.78)。
- 术后5年改良Harris髋关节评分均值短柄组89±13分对标准柄组95±7分(p=0.06)。
- 两组均无假体松动,无髋关节翻修。
关键数值与推荐
- 松动定义为系列X线片上下沉>3 mm或位置变化>3°。
- 大腿疼痛活动时采用10分VAS评估。
- 骨密度采用双能X线吸收法在术后4天、1年、2年和5年测量。
临床怎么用
- 作者推荐临床医生在一般实践中使用标准长度柄,因为标准长度柄在其他研究中有更长的发表追踪记录,而短柄可能使患者暴露于与新颖性相关的不确定性,且无明显抵消获益。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Short-length stems were developed to reduce bone loss of the proximal femur and potentially decrease the incidence of thigh pain after cementless THA. However, it remains unknown whether short stems indeed reduce bone loss or the frequency of thigh pain. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: Is there a difference between short- and standard-length stems in terms of: (1) the frequency or severity of thigh pain, (2) modified Harris hip scores, (3) implant loosening, or (4) bone mineral density as measured by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry? METHODS: Between March 2013 and January 2014, three surgeons performed 205 primary THAs. To be eligible, patients needed to be at least 20 years of age, have not undergone previous history of hip surgery, and have no metabolic bone disease. A total of 100 patients were randomized to receive THA either with a short stem (n = 56) or with a standard-length stem (n = 44). Both stems were proximally coated, tapered, cementless stems. Compared with standard stems, short stems typically were 30- to 35-mm shorter. A total of 73% (41 of 56) and 77% (34 of 44) of those groups, respectively, were accounted for at a minimum of 5 years and were analyzed. The presence of thigh pain during activity was evaluated using a 10-point VAS, and the modified Harris hip score was calculated by research assistants who were blinded to the treatment groups. Plain radiographs were taken at 6 weeks, 6 months, and 12 months postoperatively, and every 1 year thereafter; loosening was defined as subsidence > 3 mm or a position change > 3° on serial radiographs. Radiological assessment was performed by two researchers who did not participate in the surgery and follow-up evaluations. Bone mineral density of the proximal femur was measured using dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry at 4 days, 1 year, 2 years, and 5 years postoperatively. The primary endpoint of our study was the incidence of thigh pain during 5-year follow-up. Our study was powered at 80% to detect a 10% difference in the proportion of patients reporting thigh pain at the level of 0.05. RESULTS: With the numbers available, we found no difference between the groups in the proportion of patients with thigh pain; 16% (9 of 56) of patients in the short-stem group and 14% (6 of 44) of patients in the standard-stem group experienced thigh pain during the follow-up period (p = 0.79). In all patients, the pain was mild or moderate (VAS score of 4 or 6 points). Among the 15 available patients who reported thigh pain, there was no difference between the implant groups in mean severity of thigh pain (4.3 ± 0.8 versus 4.2 ± 0.7; p = 0.78). There were no between-group differences in the short versus standard-length stem groups in terms of mean modified Harris hip score by 5 years after surgery (89 ± 13 versus 95 ± 7 points; p = 0.06). No implant was loose and no hip underwent revision in either group. Patients in the short-stem group showed a slightly smaller decrease in bone mineral density in Gruen Zones 2, 3, and 5 than those in the standard-stem group did; the magnitude of the difference seems unlikely to be clinically important. CONCLUSION: We found no clinically important differences (and few differences overall) between short and standard-length THA stems 5 years after surgery in a randomized trial. Consequently, we recommend that clinicians use standard-length stems in general practice because standard-length stems have a much longer published track record in other studies, and short stems can expose patients to the uncertainty associated with novelty, without any apparent offsetting benefit. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level I, therapeutic study.
引用
- Won SH, Park JW, Lee YK, et al. No Clinically Important Differences in Thigh Pain or Bone Loss Between Short Stems and Conventional-length Stems in THA: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2021. PMID: 33009239. doi:10.1097/CORR.0000000000001505
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。